I am not trained in music and have less technical knowledge, but based on what I felt on hearing every song, these are my views. I am giving marks on 10 to every member as an encouragement...if I choose just 2, the others would definitely want to know where they stand.
Please take these as honest, constructive feedback.
Entry 1: It took too long for the song to start...I was wondering if this was a prank.
Very good singing. I felt the karaoke was slightly loud. 8/10
Entry 2: You started off the song from the antra...it would have been better to start from the mukhda. Good singing but the volume was too low at low pitches. 7/10
Entry 3: The starting was a bit abrupt and it sounded out of sur. .Tere was a point where the male voice is coming from the karaoke and there's suddenly a female voice which I am not sure if it's you or part of the karaoke. You could have avoided the karaoke, it would have sounded better in your own scale 6/10
Entry 4: At times your sur was off-key. Nice singing,your voice is very clear. 7/10
Entry 5: The recording quality is not very good. The volume is suddenly going down and you are taking long pauses. If there's Karaoke it's fine but when you are singing without Karaoke, such long pauses can be avoided. Otherwise nice singing. 7.5/10
Entry 6; Nice song. Maybe the voice could have been a bit subtle. The mukhda need not be repeated twice instead another antra could have been added. 7/10
Entry 7; Classical!!!! Ooopsss...too technical for me to even think of judging.
You are a trained singer and when people like you are here others have no chance.
It's not fair to judge this song along with the film songs which the rest of the people have sung. 10/10
Entry 8: Another person has chosen the same song...this one with Karaoke. Lovely singing. 9/10
Entry 9: Good singing. Maybe it was a bit flat at times...you should have tried this song with karaoke. This song needs a rhythm in the background to get a proper feel. 7.5/10
Entry 10: lovely song. At times it sounded as if you were scared of someone listening...come on, you are not on a stage...
You need to pause a bit before starting off the antra...at one point the mukhda ended and the antra continued from there without a pause. 7/10
Entry 11: When the video started and I saw Agneepath, I thought if someone would sing Chikni chameli.
It would have been nice if someone had tried it.
Anyway this song was very well sung. At times I felt I was listening to the original.
Well sung, nice voice. It matches the mood of the song. 9/10
Were you also dancing along with the song? That would have been a real treat to watch.
nice sweet voice. Well sung...it was entertaining to see the shaking image.
Nice, clear voice. Maybe the taal was a bit off...you should have tried this song with karaoke. 8/10
Nice to hear an English song. Volume was very low at times...you need to open up a bit more. The sur and taal were a bit off. 6/10
It was a bit flat at times...but nice voice. 7/10
Excellent song...very well sung. It should be a bit more subtle at times..when Asha jis says 'chura liya'...she starts off softly. Your high notes are good. But again...at the point where it says 'aaj tum itna waada'...it has to be a bit more soft. The end was a bit abrupt. Nevertheless, 9/10.
The mic was vibrating at some points...(not your fault). Well sung. 7/10
Your voice is very good...it has a classical touch. But the song has to be a bit more sutble...it's a romantic song, but the feel is like your inspiring someone to go to battle (something like baar baar haan, bolo yaar haan... apni jeet ho unki haar haan
Everyone has sung well. It's tough to choose one from these.
My votes go to no 11 and no 17.