Madhubala - Ek Ishq Ek Junoon

India-Forums

   
Madhubala - Ek Ishq Ek Junoon
Madhubala - Ek Ishq Ek Junoon

Show's weakest aspect (Page 2)

Nu_Adu Senior Member
Nu_Adu
Nu_Adu

Joined: 07 January 2010
Posts: 984

Posted: 05 September 2012 at 1:50pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by nitya

Well all i wud say is raj zusti said makers have done some changes in d track resently and wen there's sudden change in plan minor discripencies r bound 2 happen. It better 2 ignour small things in name of creative liberty and enjoy d bigger picture.

I wouldn't be complaining if his mom, dad and brother fit into the picture. I just can't accept them yet. They look so out of place in this show. They needed to cast stronger actors/actresses to play RK's parents and family I think. 

FireSafireFiree IF-Sizzlerz
FireSafireFiree
FireSafireFiree

Joined: 28 October 2007
Posts: 10625

Posted: 05 September 2012 at 1:51pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by TheBlackJaguar

Completely disagree. 

1. You can never predict how any human mind is going to react to a certain situation or how it is going to shape them as an individual. Rishabh has been shown as a hypersensitive 12 year old whose father's death's mystery is yet to be revealed - as his mom has mentioned ' that one super traumatic night' . He could not accept his mother's second marriage , had a terrible relationship with his step relatives and he became alienated. So, what you have today is basically a frustoo lost 12 year old locked in past. 

2. Rishabh is living in his house , his father's  house as Kukku Bhatia mentioned. Why should he go anywhere? Its his house and he is putting up with them because of his mother. He is just paying back the blood bond. 

3. Yes, numerous industry wives move around like Rishabh's mom. And no, am not talking about immediate Bollywood. 

4. Creatives never justify Rishabh's behaviour - they just tell you where he is coming from and that his problem is a troubled lonely childhood. 

5. When Rishabh was in jail, the casting and the story points had not been locked, except Razaa Muraad. That is why you got the Bangkok excuse. 

The logics of the creatives are totally in place - its just that you perceive the situation with a different POV. 

I completly agree.. There still lot to come out.. And i so dont want tjis to go in super light speed. Is not a film. Its a daily show.

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

desaitTheBlackJaguarleelaa9

pretstill Newbie
pretstill
pretstill

Joined: 22 August 2012
Posts: 34

Posted: 05 September 2012 at 1:51pm | IP Logged
I agree. The writing has been very clumsy and downright bad when it comes to consistency. I am hoping, however, that the missing father son mom trio will somehow be linked to the Accident - which started the story. It is possile, even within the shambolic mess they have made of the back-story, to come up with a coherent case of Step!namoonas talking mom into leaving the country immediately after the accident, making sure she remains largey unaware of the jailtime etc until much later, when she makes her appearance. Presumably they could justify this by implying that RK has got the Step!namoonas out of trouble  before, and so the mom could be convinced that he would do so again and come through unscathed as always.
 
I am also hoping there is an interesting story of Kukku being a stealing partner ( repeated references by RK to thieves and swindlers) of the dad, who convinced the mom to marry him under some sort of duress (probably debt or a legal battle) or some such thing.
 
But there is NO justification for him tolerating relatives he despises in his home. None.
But I agree with you. Better to have created a strong story first rather than have to fix it retrospectively.


Edited by pretstill - 05 September 2012 at 1:53pm

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

Nu_Adu_sasi_

TheBlackJaguar IF-Stunnerz
TheBlackJaguar
TheBlackJaguar

Joined: 15 January 2005
Posts: 47914

Posted: 05 September 2012 at 1:52pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by FIRESafiReFIRE

Originally posted by TheBlackJaguar

Completely disagree. 

1. You can never predict how any human mind is going to react to a certain situation or how it is going to shape them as an individual. Rishabh has been shown as a hypersensitive 12 year old whose father's death's mystery is yet to be revealed - as his mom has mentioned ' that one super traumatic night' . He could not accept his mother's second marriage , had a terrible relationship with his step relatives and he became alienated. So, what you have today is basically a frustoo lost 12 year old locked in past. 

2. Rishabh is living in his house , his father's  house as Kukku Bhatia mentioned. Why should he go anywhere? Its his house and he is putting up with them because of his mother. He is just paying back the blood bond. 

3. Yes, numerous industry wives move around like Rishabh's mom. And no, am not talking about immediate Bollywood. 

4. Creatives never justify Rishabh's behaviour - they just tell you where he is coming from and that his problem is a troubled lonely childhood. 

5. When Rishabh was in jail, the casting and the story points had not been locked, except Razaa Muraad. That is why you got the Bangkok excuse. 

The logics of the creatives are totally in place - its just that you perceive the situation with a different POV. 

I completly agree.. There still lot to come out.. And i so dont want tjis to go in super light speed. Is not a film. Its a daily show.
 

Yeah and we need to put that on a notice board  before people watch this show.LOL

The following 5 member(s) liked the above post:

Courageous_LeodesaitFireSafireFireemysteriousmillileelaa9

Lola13 Goldie
Lola13
Lola13

Joined: 30 December 2010
Posts: 2248

Posted: 05 September 2012 at 1:53pm | IP Logged
two first points are right.. but I feel it's still something to come.. we don't know the whole truth...

if not... then I will personally call RK a crybaby..who still can't accept that his mother married for his sake again.. even after 15 (?) years..  :p

about RK's mother clothes..


Rani's mother

=)


Edited by Lola13 - 05 September 2012 at 1:58pm

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

Maria-capriTheBlackJaguar

FireSafireFiree IF-Sizzlerz
FireSafireFiree
FireSafireFiree

Joined: 28 October 2007
Posts: 10625

Posted: 05 September 2012 at 1:54pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by TheBlackJaguar

Originally posted by FIRESafiReFIRE

Originally posted by TheBlackJaguar

Completely disagree. 

1. You can never predict how any human mind is going to react to a certain situation or how it is going to shape them as an individual. Rishabh has been shown as a hypersensitive 12 year old whose father's death's mystery is yet to be revealed - as his mom has mentioned ' that one super traumatic night' . He could not accept his mother's second marriage , had a terrible relationship with his step relatives and he became alienated. So, what you have today is basically a frustoo lost 12 year old locked in past. 

2. Rishabh is living in his house , his father's  house as Kukku Bhatia mentioned. Why should he go anywhere? Its his house and he is putting up with them because of his mother. He is just paying back the blood bond. 

3. Yes, numerous industry wives move around like Rishabh's mom. And no, am not talking about immediate Bollywood. 

4. Creatives never justify Rishabh's behaviour - they just tell you where he is coming from and that his problem is a troubled lonely childhood. 

5. When Rishabh was in jail, the casting and the story points had not been locked, except Razaa Muraad. That is why you got the Bangkok excuse. 

The logics of the creatives are totally in place - its just that you perceive the situation with a different POV. 

I completly agree.. There still lot to come out.. And i so dont want tjis to go in super light speed. Is not a film. Its a daily show.
 

Yeah and we need to put that on a notice board  before people watch this show.LOL

You r so rit lol.
It irritates me sometime..
Have paitence :) 

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

-brokensoul-TheBlackJaguar

TheBlackJaguar IF-Stunnerz
TheBlackJaguar
TheBlackJaguar

Joined: 15 January 2005
Posts: 47914

Posted: 05 September 2012 at 1:57pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by FIRESafiReFIRE

Originally posted by TheBlackJaguar

Originally posted by FIRESafiReFIRE

Originally posted by TheBlackJaguar

Completely disagree. 

1. You can never predict how any human mind is going to react to a certain situation or how it is going to shape them as an individual. Rishabh has been shown as a hypersensitive 12 year old whose father's death's mystery is yet to be revealed - as his mom has mentioned ' that one super traumatic night' . He could not accept his mother's second marriage , had a terrible relationship with his step relatives and he became alienated. So, what you have today is basically a frustoo lost 12 year old locked in past. 

2. Rishabh is living in his house , his father's  house as Kukku Bhatia mentioned. Why should he go anywhere? Its his house and he is putting up with them because of his mother. He is just paying back the blood bond. 

3. Yes, numerous industry wives move around like Rishabh's mom. And no, am not talking about immediate Bollywood. 

4. Creatives never justify Rishabh's behaviour - they just tell you where he is coming from and that his problem is a troubled lonely childhood. 

5. When Rishabh was in jail, the casting and the story points had not been locked, except Razaa Muraad. That is why you got the Bangkok excuse. 

The logics of the creatives are totally in place - its just that you perceive the situation with a different POV. 

I completly agree.. There still lot to come out.. And i so dont want tjis to go in super light speed. Is not a film. Its a daily show.
 

Yeah and we need to put that on a notice board  before people watch this show.LOL

You r so rit lol.
It irritates me sometime..
Have paitence :) 
 

Lol, i do keep patience  for the sake of respecting other person's POV but sometimes, you just have to raise your finger and point out stuff. LOL

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

FireSafireFiree-brokensoul-

Nu_Adu Senior Member
Nu_Adu
Nu_Adu

Joined: 07 January 2010
Posts: 984

Posted: 05 September 2012 at 2:00pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by pretstill

I agree. The writing has been very clumsy and downright bad when it comes to consistency. I am hoping, however, that the missing father son mom trio will somehow be linked to the Accident - which started the story. It is possile, even within the shambolic mess they have made of the back-story, to come up with a coherent case of Step!namoonas talking mom into leaving the country immediately after the accident, making sure she remains largey unaware of the jailtime etc until much later, when she makes her appearance. Presumably they could justify this by implying that RK has got the Step!namoonas out of trouble  before, and so the mom could be convinced that he would do so again and come through unscathed as always.
 
I am also hoping there is an interesting story of Kukku being a stealing partner ( repeated references by RK to thieves and swindlers) of the dad, who convinced the mom to marry him under some sort of duress (probably debt or a legal battle) or some such thing.
 
But there is NO justification for him tolerating relatives he despises in his home. None.
But I agree with you. Better to have created a strong story first rather than have to fix it retrospectively.


During the scene when his mom made her entry, I was silently praying that they show his mom lives in another house and just came over to see him and discovers all this mess in his life... Confused


Edited by Nu_Adu - 05 September 2012 at 2:00pm

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

Foucaults-qalamleelaa9

Go to top

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Madhubala - Ek Ishq Ek Junoon Topic Index

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index