Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon

India-Forums

   
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon

The Gross and The Stupid (Page 25)

EXPELLIARMUS IF-Rockerz
EXPELLIARMUS
EXPELLIARMUS

Joined: 31 July 2012
Posts: 8111

Posted: 04 September 2012 at 12:17pm | IP Logged
Wonderful post, exactly my thoughts!
I am all ranted out about IPK vs DKS, Anjali vs Khushi, lovers vs siblings etc..
I literally have no energy left to argue those points again.
However,I do have one question.
WHY???
Why would anyone take a beautifully crafted,nuanced love story and turn it into some crap about Di and her saut?
Why would you take the focus away from arguably the best on screen chemistry on television, and instead concentrate on the best twitching/crying ever?
Why would anyone not continue the kind of storytelling that brought them 4+ TRPs?
Why would anyone take away the subtle touches that made this show unique?

Does this give them creative satisfation to twist their own story so much that it doesnt bear any resemblance to the original show that brought us to it from all over the world?
Does it even make any kind of business sense?

I am genuinely baffled,because I just dont understand why someone could destroy something that was so wonderful.
These days,watching old scenes on YT no longer entertains me. It just makes me sad, for what could have been.
And I ask myself again, Why??

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

FuzzbucketSiri22FairyLiquidSoap

FairyLiquidSoap IF-Sizzlerz
FairyLiquidSoap
FairyLiquidSoap

Joined: 26 November 2011
Posts: 13826

Posted: 04 September 2012 at 12:27pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by EXPELLIARMUS

Wonderful post, exactly my thoughts!
I am all ranted out about IPK vs DKS, Anjali vs Khushi, lovers vs siblings etc..
I literally have no energy left to argue those points again.
However,I do have one question.
WHY???
Why would anyone take a beautifully crafted,nuanced love story and turn it into some crap about Di and her saut?
Why would you take the focus away from arguably the best on screen chemistry on television, and instead concentrate on the best twitching/crying ever?
Why would anyone not continue the kind of storytelling that brought them 4+ TRPs?
Why would anyone take away the subtle touches that made this show unique?

Does this give them creative satisfation to twist their own story so much that it doesnt bear any resemblance to the original show that brought us to it from all over the world?
Does it even make any kind of business sense?

I am genuinely baffled,because I just dont understand why someone could destroy something that was so wonderful.
These days,watching old scenes on YT no longer entertains me. It just makes me sad, for what could have been.
And I ask myself again, Why??
Hola ESmile thank youSmile
very well asked and even the pleasure of watching the old scenes is gone as you only end up comparing and feel irritated over what they have done to this serial they had the best global audience cutting across cultural geographical language and social barriers different faiths different beliefs and yet all interested in this one damn serial the youtube sensation the online frenzy and now so mediocre so ordinaire and only if you are some one so blind deaf and dumb not to see the downgrading of this once pretty superior product will you still justify this drivel It moves only one segment now and good luck to them while it lasts

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

EXPELLIARMUS

abracadabra IF-Rockerz
abracadabra
abracadabra

Joined: 21 February 2011
Posts: 5456

Posted: 04 September 2012 at 12:30pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by FairyLiquidSoap

Originally posted by chaitra2011

Originally posted by FairyLiquidSoap

Originally posted by chaitra2011

Originally posted by FairyLiquidSoap

Originally posted by chaitra2011

Swathi, Love you for this post! what a commendable writer you are truly. Smile


This is what we all have wanted them to do, to be crystal clear about what they intend to do. Do the PH think we are brainless nit-wits so as to accept whatever they dish out at us?

They have been monkeying around much and its already resulting in animosity between us and them. Much more of this and the loyal viewers are no more there. We still have that hope lying around because they did give us a unique story to love, unique characters who had an identity of their own and the best leads we all fell in love with. This is how the show was promoted. Now we cant do a 360 degree turn and watch this show as DKS. Hope they understand that.
Khushi has been reduced to a stress buster in the show. What was the point of building her character so much when she has been reduced to this! I really feel bad for her. And i think it's high time Sanaya has a really good talk with the PH.

 I'm glad there are numerous people out here on the form who voice their opinions and have their own stand rather than accepting nonsense.

If the PH maintains being stubborn their baby truly dies a sad death slowly. Even Devi Maiyya cannot save i say
@ red Amen sistah you said it
thanks chaitra for your warm words This post was really something i wrote in frustration never intended to write one for some time but a trigger happened and voila my rant
@Blue obviously yes considering the age of their current target segmentWink
once again love our interaction and hope to see more of it always a pleasure chatting with likeminded people


My pleasure Swathi Smile Often enough when you are frustrated it is good to get it out. But here it is with a cause. So all in good faith. By seeing the number of replies, our case only gets stronger.

Hehehe.. Whatever their target is, it shall soon fall whatever little they have left Wink I skipped today. Only reading the Written Update. For my peace of mind this is good. For now.
chaitra think bolllwyood dishum dishum hero vs villain lots of punches you aint getting your dirty hands on my Di oh yeah she is my wife Story done for todayDead 
and ooh yeah remove their reason for it and voila they will desert faster than rats a sinking ship we know what attracts themWink


LOL That pretty much sums it up. No need for WU either. Oh lord! Dishum dishum bhi hua? Waah re waah!  Desert to karenge na yaar. For how long can anyone hold on to a sinking ship? They'll die Big smile  I would suggest people go out more and "see" other people :P
people yes but err fanatics lunatics ???????? who do they go see Wink


Actually no need to see.. Coz everywhere they go they'll only see one personwa.. Tongue

And what am i reading? UK trip cancelled? This had to happen now? hahaha. And what would have they promoted anyway? Didi ko dekho, hum sab uske aas paas props rahenge.. especially Khushi will be the main prop. Yeh promote karna tha?

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

FairyLiquidSoap

FairyLiquidSoap IF-Sizzlerz
FairyLiquidSoap
FairyLiquidSoap

Joined: 26 November 2011
Posts: 13826

Posted: 04 September 2012 at 12:33pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by chaitra2011

Originally posted by FairyLiquidSoap

Originally posted by chaitra2011

Originally posted by FairyLiquidSoap

Originally posted by chaitra2011

Originally posted by FairyLiquidSoap

Originally posted by chaitra2011

Swathi, Love you for this post! what a commendable writer you are truly. Smile


This is what we all have wanted them to do, to be crystal clear about what they intend to do. Do the PH think we are brainless nit-wits so as to accept whatever they dish out at us?

They have been monkeying around much and its already resulting in animosity between us and them. Much more of this and the loyal viewers are no more there. We still have that hope lying around because they did give us a unique story to love, unique characters who had an identity of their own and the best leads we all fell in love with. This is how the show was promoted. Now we cant do a 360 degree turn and watch this show as DKS. Hope they understand that.
Khushi has been reduced to a stress buster in the show. What was the point of building her character so much when she has been reduced to this! I really feel bad for her. And i think it's high time Sanaya has a really good talk with the PH.

 I'm glad there are numerous people out here on the form who voice their opinions and have their own stand rather than accepting nonsense.

If the PH maintains being stubborn their baby truly dies a sad death slowly. Even Devi Maiyya cannot save i say
@ red Amen sistah you said it
thanks chaitra for your warm words This post was really something i wrote in frustration never intended to write one for some time but a trigger happened and voila my rant
@Blue obviously yes considering the age of their current target segmentWink
once again love our interaction and hope to see more of it always a pleasure chatting with likeminded people


My pleasure Swathi Smile Often enough when you are frustrated it is good to get it out. But here it is with a cause. So all in good faith. By seeing the number of replies, our case only gets stronger.

Hehehe.. Whatever their target is, it shall soon fall whatever little they have left Wink I skipped today. Only reading the Written Update. For my peace of mind this is good. For now.
chaitra think bolllwyood dishum dishum hero vs villain lots of punches you aint getting your dirty hands on my Di oh yeah she is my wife Story done for todayDead 
and ooh yeah remove their reason for it and voila they will desert faster than rats a sinking ship we know what attracts themWink


LOL That pretty much sums it up. No need for WU either. Oh lord! Dishum dishum bhi hua? Waah re waah!  Desert to karenge na yaar. For how long can anyone hold on to a sinking ship? They'll die Big smile  I would suggest people go out more and "see" other people :P
people yes but err fanatics lunatics ???????? who do they go see Wink


Actually no need to see.. Coz everywhere they go they'll only see one personwa.. Tongue

And what am i reading? UK trip cancelled? This had to happen now? hahaha. And what would have they promoted anyway? Didi ko dekho, hum sab uske aas paas props rahenge.. especially Khushi will be the main prop. Yeh promote karna tha?
cancelled? i thought it was in a diff format that is no dining no meet greet just concert with the parivar

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

abracadabra

abracadabra IF-Rockerz
abracadabra
abracadabra

Joined: 21 February 2011
Posts: 5456

Posted: 04 September 2012 at 12:44pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by FairyLiquidSoap

Originally posted by chaitra2011

Originally posted by FairyLiquidSoap

Originally posted by chaitra2011

Originally posted by FairyLiquidSoap

Originally posted by chaitra2011

Originally posted by FairyLiquidSoap

Originally posted by chaitra2011

Swathi, Love you for this post! what a commendable writer you are truly. Smile


This is what we all have wanted them to do, to be crystal clear about what they intend to do. Do the PH think we are brainless nit-wits so as to accept whatever they dish out at us?

They have been monkeying around much and its already resulting in animosity between us and them. Much more of this and the loyal viewers are no more there. We still have that hope lying around because they did give us a unique story to love, unique characters who had an identity of their own and the best leads we all fell in love with. This is how the show was promoted. Now we cant do a 360 degree turn and watch this show as DKS. Hope they understand that.
Khushi has been reduced to a stress buster in the show. What was the point of building her character so much when she has been reduced to this! I really feel bad for her. And i think it's high time Sanaya has a really good talk with the PH.

 I'm glad there are numerous people out here on the form who voice their opinions and have their own stand rather than accepting nonsense.

If the PH maintains being stubborn their baby truly dies a sad death slowly. Even Devi Maiyya cannot save i say
@ red Amen sistah you said it
thanks chaitra for your warm words This post was really something i wrote in frustration never intended to write one for some time but a trigger happened and voila my rant
@Blue obviously yes considering the age of their current target segmentWink
once again love our interaction and hope to see more of it always a pleasure chatting with likeminded people


My pleasure Swathi Smile Often enough when you are frustrated it is good to get it out. But here it is with a cause. So all in good faith. By seeing the number of replies, our case only gets stronger.

Hehehe.. Whatever their target is, it shall soon fall whatever little they have left Wink I skipped today. Only reading the Written Update. For my peace of mind this is good. For now.
chaitra think bolllwyood dishum dishum hero vs villain lots of punches you aint getting your dirty hands on my Di oh yeah she is my wife Story done for todayDead 
and ooh yeah remove their reason for it and voila they will desert faster than rats a sinking ship we know what attracts themWink


LOL That pretty much sums it up. No need for WU either. Oh lord! Dishum dishum bhi hua? Waah re waah!  Desert to karenge na yaar. For how long can anyone hold on to a sinking ship? They'll die Big smile  I would suggest people go out more and "see" other people :P
people yes but err fanatics lunatics ???????? who do they go see Wink


Actually no need to see.. Coz everywhere they go they'll only see one personwa.. Tongue

And what am i reading? UK trip cancelled? This had to happen now? hahaha. And what would have they promoted anyway? Didi ko dekho, hum sab uske aas paas props rahenge.. especially Khushi will be the main prop. Yeh promote karna tha?
cancelled? i thought it was in a diff format that is no dining no meet greet just concert with the parivar


Ok swathi, mereko confuse ho raha hai Big smile concert with star parivaar? please elaborate na? i missed all the gup shup. .. went out :)

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

FairyLiquidSoap

sbk2 IF-Sizzlerz
sbk2
sbk2

Joined: 17 August 2011
Posts: 10431

Posted: 04 September 2012 at 12:45pm | IP Logged
Swathi...


After Friday's episode I was utterly upset with the way the CVs ruined the remarriage track...I was ranting and raving...pasting some of my incoherent rant here...since you're badgering me to post it Tongue

What's there to get confused about? Gul Khan doesn't give a shit about Khushi's character. The writers work for her, right?! So they too have no regard for her character. Haven't you seen, till now they have not shown ASR properly apologizing to Khushi for all the bad things he has done - its always a half hearted, rushed scene...except of course the Gazebo apology, but that too was because ASR was sympathetic towards her being an orphan.

Half of the forum is complaining about the same thing - all of us expected ASR to break down and cry and feel guilty for hurting Khushi - that necver happened. Instead he blackmailed her even more, bullied her, tried to consummate the marriage, despite her concerns about not being married properly.

Its clear the PH has been deceiving the public since the beginning. They showcased this serial as a love story, but were actually trying to show ASR the God's story...this was never about Khushi and him...this is only about him, his mahanta, his demons, his pain.
Let the other characters go to hell - but don't let ASR's aura decrease - show him as a person who is always justified, somehow show it is someone else's mistake that causes him to be the way he is!
The writers don't care about maintaining the strength or consistency in Khushi's character - she's a mere prop, a means to an end. They need eye candy to attract romantics, right?
Khushi has been shown like a mess, a mass of contradictions - totally neglected by the attention of writers. At one time she comes off strong, the next moment they show her weak and doormatish.

The public fell for their deceit and thought it was a love story...
Now the PH has revealed that they fooled us all...this is not about Khushi and Arnav, so why will they show Khushi getting justice and closure and a nice repentance by Arnav? That will show that he was wrong...how can Gul's dream character be wrong?!

They showed that hasty apology, because they had to show him breaking down for his sister and us fans would be upset that he did not even apologize to his lady love!

They also changed the past story...have you seen - ASR's mom probably MUed his Dad...the writers and Gul are chauvinistic...somehow they always show the woman being at fault for all catastrophies in IPK... The Mighty ASR and now his Dad - they are portrayed as innocent selfless people, victims of circumstances created by the women in their lives!

Now they will show Khushi pressuring Arnav to get Shyam back - so yet again its she who will be blamed henceforth, for yet again letting the Snake run amock.

And now their remarriage too will be a simple ceremony...why spend money on a marriage that only Khushi wants?! Jaldi jaldi rafa dafa kar do...or better yet show it being stopped...afterall, they need to accommodate more of Rudali and her delusional hysterics and Dadi and Snake...Grrr!



Edited by sbk2 - 04 September 2012 at 12:45pm

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

rvarierEmerald-FairyLiquidSoap

FairyLiquidSoap IF-Sizzlerz
FairyLiquidSoap
FairyLiquidSoap

Joined: 26 November 2011
Posts: 13826

Posted: 04 September 2012 at 12:46pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by chaitra2011

Originally posted by FairyLiquidSoap

Originally posted by chaitra2011

Originally posted by FairyLiquidSoap

Originally posted by chaitra2011

Originally posted by FairyLiquidSoap

Originally posted by chaitra2011

Originally posted by FairyLiquidSoap

Originally posted by chaitra2011

Swathi, Love you for this post! what a commendable writer you are truly. Smile


This is what we all have wanted them to do, to be crystal clear about what they intend to do. Do the PH think we are brainless nit-wits so as to accept whatever they dish out at us?

They have been monkeying around much and its already resulting in animosity between us and them. Much more of this and the loyal viewers are no more there. We still have that hope lying around because they did give us a unique story to love, unique characters who had an identity of their own and the best leads we all fell in love with. This is how the show was promoted. Now we cant do a 360 degree turn and watch this show as DKS. Hope they understand that.
Khushi has been reduced to a stress buster in the show. What was the point of building her character so much when she has been reduced to this! I really feel bad for her. And i think it's high time Sanaya has a really good talk with the PH.

 I'm glad there are numerous people out here on the form who voice their opinions and have their own stand rather than accepting nonsense.

If the PH maintains being stubborn their baby truly dies a sad death slowly. Even Devi Maiyya cannot save i say
@ red Amen sistah you said it
thanks chaitra for your warm words This post was really something i wrote in frustration never intended to write one for some time but a trigger happened and voila my rant
@Blue obviously yes considering the age of their current target segmentWink
once again love our interaction and hope to see more of it always a pleasure chatting with likeminded people


My pleasure Swathi Smile Often enough when you are frustrated it is good to get it out. But here it is with a cause. So all in good faith. By seeing the number of replies, our case only gets stronger.

Hehehe.. Whatever their target is, it shall soon fall whatever little they have left Wink I skipped today. Only reading the Written Update. For my peace of mind this is good. For now.
chaitra think bolllwyood dishum dishum hero vs villain lots of punches you aint getting your dirty hands on my Di oh yeah she is my wife Story done for todayDead 
and ooh yeah remove their reason for it and voila they will desert faster than rats a sinking ship we know what attracts themWink


LOL That pretty much sums it up. No need for WU either. Oh lord! Dishum dishum bhi hua? Waah re waah!  Desert to karenge na yaar. For how long can anyone hold on to a sinking ship? They'll die Big smile  I would suggest people go out more and "see" other people :P
people yes but err fanatics lunatics ???????? who do they go see Wink


Actually no need to see.. Coz everywhere they go they'll only see one personwa.. Tongue

And what am i reading? UK trip cancelled? This had to happen now? hahaha. And what would have they promoted anyway? Didi ko dekho, hum sab uske aas paas props rahenge.. especially Khushi will be the main prop. Yeh promote karna tha?
cancelled? i thought it was in a diff format that is no dining no meet greet just concert with the parivar


Ok swathi, mereko confuse ho raha hai Big smile concert with star parivaar? please elaborate na? i missed all the gup shup. .. went out :)
thats what the grapevine is saying some star parivar jaunt is what this is and not exclusive bytes and bites am not sure myself but will tell if i know

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

abracadabra

Emerald- Goldie
Emerald-
Emerald-

Joined: 10 February 2012
Posts: 2349

Posted: 04 September 2012 at 12:46pm | IP Logged

Brilliantly written Fairy!

They have messed up the story and it's characters.  

 

 

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

FairyLiquidSoap

Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Author Replies Views Last Post
WU: 1 Dec: Stupid plans r alws successful

2 3 4 5

Author: --sunshine--   Replies: 39   Views: 10761

--sunshine-- 39 10761 02 December 2011 at 11:37am by --sunshine--
Anjali may b not dat stupid

2 3 4

Author: rushshri   Replies: 24   Views: 2667

rushshri 24 2667 23 November 2011 at 3:04am by ketki_arshi
CV's are stupid

Author: CHIPPEDCUP   Replies: 4   Views: 735

CHIPPEDCUP 4 735 16 November 2011 at 11:51am by sofi288
Its Sooo Stupid

Author: Ks_143   Replies: 2   Views: 738

Ks_143 2 738 11 November 2011 at 3:02am by Sanlicious
How stupid can they get?

Author: -Sanjana-   Replies: 7   Views: 969

-Sanjana- 7 969 09 November 2011 at 10:13pm by Starktastic

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Topic Index

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index