Originally posted by: Rashiii
Enjoyed reading the post but I don't agree totally be honest..
I wrote a long reply but I dint get posted :-( and in a hurry to type it all again, will keep it shorter this time,
I Do understand and agree to what you stated, but since you have already elaborated that part, and the rest of members too,without repeating the same, I am gonna write about the other side of the coin :-)
You have quoted two of his lines, but there is one more line that he speaks much more frequently than these two, his promises to Manvi, "Main tumhe kuchh nahi hone doonga,kuch bhi nahi" "is Janam mein toh kya, able janam mein bhi" "maine is patte ko kuch bhi nahi hone diya, kitni aandhi toofaan aaye fir bhi" and the various other times, when he has said the same thing, i think infact he repeats this in every alternate scene of theirs...After such dialogues, I cant see him letting Manvi die just like that either... for me, his character gets affected even if he doesn't support Jeevs and lets Manvi die :'( ..
He has still lived so far by the two lines you quoted, but he is yet to fulfill his promise of not letting anything happen to her..
Its not about being selfish, coz like others, he also loses in both the cases.. In fact, Viren Jeevika Manvi, all three atleast own something or someone in this case, that they can sacrifice selflessly,for the happiness of someone they love root to save the other, but technically Viraat owns nothing here,its not his life technically(he does own Manvi, but not like that, I mean you get my point right?)For me,even though the pain of losing is more for other three but decision wise, Viraat has the toughest choice to make, and in a way he goes against Manvi in both the cases,in some way or the other.
So anyways,if we can support Jeevika while she fulfills her promise of protecting Manvi, why can't we support Viraat when he tries to do the same.
And for the four main characters, its not like some battle of Plassey with clear cut X v/s Y...It can NEVER be like that, the lines are too blurred to get divided into teams like that, esp for boys...And personally I feel, this wont be stretched and will settle down quickly cos No production house, no team can ever justify any of the sides here.. both the choices come with right as well as wrong..Characters get affected in both the cases...
So for Viraat, want him to be BY Manvi's side, in her pain, in these possibly last days, but still be against her and opt for marrow over 10 wks life,without being totally cold hearted towards his bhai-bhabhi and the unborn...
P.S. No offence :-)
Rashii thank you for such a lovely reply and showing the otherside of the coin...
@bold - yes virat can go to any extent to save M.. but going against M for saving M .. would be very tough for him and tough for Maanvi, to see him standing against herself...
@red - i loved all your points @red - it was a great treat to read.. in fact relations are complex and blurred,.,, in testing times... in spite of knowing who side Virat is gonna take from spoilers .. I had this wishful thinking, the outcome of which is this post ,..
you know the toughest thing is life is standing against the one's you love more than your life.. Jeevika, Maanvi and Virat will be standing in the same situation..., standing against the most loved person only to see each other happy .. but VIRAT as you said...loses in EITHER case
comment:
p_commentcount