Film Previews & Reviews


Film Previews & Reviews
Film Previews & Reviews

But this Bengali film Dosor

Qwest IF-Rockerz

Banned for Advertising
Joined: 24 February 2006
Posts: 6734

Posted: 22 June 2006 at 10:46pm | IP Logged

Yet another tale of marital infidelity. But this Bengali film finds Rituparno Ghosh in fine form, managing to do what he knows best.

Magazine| May 29, 2006


Starring: Konkana Sen Sharma, Prasenjit, Pallabi Chatterjee
Directed by Rituparno Ghosh
Rating: ***

Yet another tale of marital infidelity. There may not seem anything remarkably different about Dosor. But this Bengali film finds Rituparno Ghosh in fine form, managing to do what he knows best: looking intimately at the fragility of relationships, exploring the depths of his characters' innermost emotions.

Something about Dosor reminded me of Kieslowski's Three Colours Blue. The car accident, a death, its repercussions, the hidden betrayals that a catastrophe can brutally bring to surface and a journey of reconciliation that the protagonist has to go on. Like Blue, the central character is that of a wife reconciling with grief. But, unlike Blue, the husband is still alive; it's the seeming end of her relationship with him that she is really mourning. 

After a weekend rendezvous, Kaushik and Mita meet with an accident in which Mita dies and their clandestine relationship comes out in the open. The pivot of the film is a lovely performance from Konkana as the wife who learns of the deceptions and lies even as she faces up to the tragedy. As Kaberi, she charts out the journey of the affronted wife very credibly. The grief, anger, deep humiliation and yet the care and concern for the man. There are some moving moments: when she talks to her mother about living alone in the future, when she erupts in front of her husband's boss only to politely apologise later, when she sees her SMS on his mobile and calls back on the number only to hear her voice, or when she gives bath to the injured Kaushik, her irritation gradually giving way to compassion. Should she forgive everything just because the other woman is dead? The most interesting element is her attempt to reach out to Subir, the husband of Mita. The initial discomfort, exchanging things of each other's spouses, the dry comment about how Subir looked better with the moustache. There is a matter-of-fact poignancy in their interaction that later grows into a strange bonding. The black and white images, stillness of frames and minimal music—all adds up to create a nice piece of introspective cinema. But the film falters in the parallel stories of unfaithfulness, in consciously trying to create an intricate web of infidelities.  

Edited by Qwest - 23 June 2006 at 8:56am

Qwest IF-Rockerz

Banned for Advertising
Joined: 24 February 2006
Posts: 6734

Posted: 23 June 2006 at 1:46pm | IP Logged

A maverick in black and white ANUJ KUMAR
After bringing Bangla cinema back to national consciousness, Rituparno Ghosh now experiments with black and white in "Dosor".

Most films are judgmental about extramarital relations. "Dosor" just explores the different facets.

THE MAN AND HIS MOODS Rituparno Ghosh directing Konkona Sen Sharma and Prasenjit Chatterjee
What puts Rituparno Ghosh in a different league? Come along. When even Salim and Anarkali have donned colours, Ritu has just completed "Dosor" in black and white format. "When we got colour as an option, black and white ceased to be an alternative. This happens with technology. It's not that it was a must for my script, I wanted to exploit black and white as an option," says Ritu, fresh from a 20-hour shift.

The Bangla film deals with an extra marital affair, a subject squeezed out by filmmakers from Bhatt to Balaji. Languishing on a Victorian sofa in his sedate house in South Kolkata, Ritu smiles, "Right, but what I have seen of Hindi films, most of the time they are judgemental about the subject. Either the other lady is adjudged an adulteress, or the man is termed debauched. My film just explores the different facets of the relationships." Real life incident

Produced by Planman Motion Pictures, the storyline revolves around a lady whose unfaithful husband has just got severely injured in an accident where his female 'friend' got killed. "I got the basic idea from a real life incident when I was working with Anand Bazaar Patrika." The film brings together two of his favourites, Prasenjit Chatterjee and Konkona Sen Sharma. "I have developed a certain chemistry with Bubba (Prasenjit's pet name in Kolkata) since 'Unishe April'. He does so many films, but when I have a character for him he takes out time." A person so busy with his commercial flicks that he literally juggles between sets, Bubba, says Ritu, "studied books, went to doctors to study his character. I just told him that his backbone gets injured. He went on to study the medical history of patients to get the reflexes right!" What has surprised him is the growth of Konkona from Koko. "I worked with her in 'Titli'. That was more of a picnic, but today she is an extension of her mother, yet has a distinct personality of her own. The best thing is, she can portray a character within the age group of 18 to 35." Breather for Bollywood

Known for helping Bollywood actors seeking a fresh breath in their careers, Ritu is bound to meet with raised eyebrows when he says, "It was a relief to work with a Bengali cast after a long time." Quickly he substitutes the word bonus for "relief". "Be it Aishwarya, Kiron, Ajay or Jackie, they just suited the roles." He is often charged with doing this to gather a pan Indian acceptance for his films. "Do you think I need to do this?" he counters. One doesn't know, but his first foray into Hindi cinema "Raincoat" suffered because his anglicised heroine could not master the Bihari accent in the fast-paced schedule of a dozen-odd days. "That had more to do with my limitation with the vernacular. I should have taken care. Aishwarya gave her best."

Still from "Dosor".
"Dosor" is an exception, but Ritu is credited with bringing literature back to Indian celluloid with his "Chokher Bali" which won both critical acclaim and box office success. His soon-to-be-released "Antarmahal" is again loosely based on a short story by Tarashanker Bandopadhyaya. Interestingly, in Bangla there is a common word for book and cinema - boi. "Yes, it is. Literature has always inspired cinema in Bengal, whatever be the trend in other parts of the country. However, we must interpret literature according to the times we are living in. I did it in 'Chokher Bali' where I didn't agree with the way Tagore ended the novel. I kept an unresolved ending. Similarly, I adapted O Henry's story in 'Raincoat' differently from the novel." On his next project on the Mahabharat, he points out, "It is an epic and should not be treated as a religious text." Often his works are compared with Satyajit Ray and Ritwik Ghatak, but Ritu says it is for the critics to judge. "I believe I am overrated because there is not too much of talent around." Another acclaimed director Anjan Das says Ritu has been able to turn Ray's sensibilities into box office success, which Ray himself could not do consistently. "I don't believe in intellectualising cinema too much. Who has the patience to watch Mani Kaul's 'Duvidha'?" Fascination for perfection

Still from "Dosor".
Ritu's fascination for perfection is well documented. His trusted cameraman Abhik Mukherjee shares, "When we decided on black and white format, we decided to shoot backgrounds to be used in colour and changed them to black and white to see the effect. He wanted the densities and tones of the props to match with the background. Even cups and vases! Some colour combinations look gaudy in colour, but they are perfect in black and white." Konkona says though Ritu always pushes to get what exactly he has in his mind but he also allows the actor to grow into the character on the sets. "He is always ready to listen to my inputs on the character. This is quite unlike my mother, who relies more on pre-shooting workshops." Ritu says he imbibed this fascination early from his father, who was a documentary filmmaker. "I have seen cinema getting demystified on the dining table, like I discovered the difference between a rush print and a final print very early. However, I could not relate to documentary films as I wanted to be a storyteller... interpreting the truth, which documentary filmmakers call distorting the truth." Another intriguing feature is the speed with which he delivers. If "Raincoat" was a quickie, "Dosor," completed in some 14 days, is already in postproduction, and "Antarmahal," which premiered recently at the Locarno Film Festival, is ready for release. "It has more to do with the team and planning. I don't intend to make a record. It's the team that wants to stick to the schedule, at times literally forcing me to complete the shot." And the affection shows. In an industry where the backroom guys are tuned to remain in the background, Ritu introduces almost his entire crew to the press. "The rest succumbed to the 20-hour shift." So what makes Rituparno Ghosh different?

Perhaps he is a league unto himself.

Edited by Qwest - 23 June 2006 at 1:47pm
pinky no1 IF-Rockerz
pinky no1
pinky no1

Joined: 27 January 2005
Posts: 7531

Posted: 24 June 2006 at 10:32am | IP Logged
thanx.but I dont like this movie really.only Konkona was good.I dont like anyone else in this movie.
  • Page 1 of 1

Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Author Replies Views Last Post
Kismat Konnection Review-MUST WATCH FILM

Author: *fairytale*   Replies: 3   Views: 879

*fairytale* 3 879 01 December 2008 at 10:53am by Siddhi_
Rani-Saif’s new film Thoda Pyaar Thoda Ma

2 3

Author: iss3   Replies: 18   Views: 3269

iss3 18 3269 27 April 2008 at 3:18pm by Echoesofpassion
Awaited Film

2 3

Author: PRABii   Replies: 17   Views: 1853

PRABii 17 1853 17 April 2008 at 5:38am by payal40
Which Is The Best Film In These 4 film

2 3

Author: KIRAN_20   Replies: 17   Views: 1936

KIRAN_20 17 1936 19 November 2006 at 11:11am by meghavi
Bengali Movie Renting in Edison NJ ?

Author: angel_111   Replies: 3   Views: 925

angel_111 3 925 04 May 2006 at 5:35pm by Rosesz

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels

  • Please login to check your Last 10 Topics posted

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index