My Post Closed... WHYY?? - Page 9

Originally posted by: maggie131984

Reading your reply, it raises a very importan question.
For frustrations/"negative " comments, all should be done in the "frustration thread". Outside of this thread, such topics are not allowed.

So similarly, why cant be there one thread for appreciation/"postive comments" on episdoes/ong oign tracks? Why are "apreciation"topics allowed from everyone and no negative topics?

As someone mentioned in this topic, why are topics made about " I am goldie", I am a dazzler. I am senior member.. blah blah.. Why isnt there one thread for that? Such topics have 10 pages of comments in them.

Originally posted by: shaktheback

10 pages🥳

Originally posted by: CravingKhana

why dont we just have topics opened by mods and stickeyed so we can comment in the appropriate thread...neat and tidy...

appreciation thread

frustration thread

lu thread

daily updates

vedewo updates

stories

sarcasm

humor

and then regularly dump the sarcasm thread inot the Problem usesrs space...

oh how tardy of me i forgot the OMGGG thread

and of course the check out the meat thread...

and seee i am growing up on IF thread...

Like the idea! Good one! I forgot to appreciate on the food topic you made :)

Originally posted by: maggie131984

Like the idea! Good one! I forgot to appreciate on the food topic you made :)

I'm assuming it didn't have a "I LOVE ASR/GH/BARUN SOBTI" footnote. It's okay. Everybody makes mistakes. Be careful the next time.

Originally posted by: boyznaka

I'm assuming it didn't have a "I LOVE ASR/GH/BARUN SOBTI" footnote. It's okay. Everybody makes mistakes. Be careful the next time.

lol so true! hehe lol seen ure lots posts yesterday! that got closed aswelll!😆am suprised it lasted so long1😆Edited by starry66 - 11 years ago

Originally posted by: maggie131984

Reading your reply, it raises a very importan question.
For frustrations/"negative " comments, all should be done in the "frustration thread". Outside of this thread, such topics are not allowed.

So similarly, why cant be there one thread for appreciation/"postive comments" on episdoes/ong oign tracks? Why are "apreciation"topics allowed from everyone and no negative topics?

As someone mentioned in this topic, why are topics made about " I am goldie", I am a dazzler. I am senior member.. blah blah.. Why isnt there one thread for that? Such topics have 10 pages of comments in them.

I understand your point, but I guess there is a limit to what can be posted in a negative light outside the frustration thread. In my opinion, when people start offending others or making generic comments, that's when the post is no longer a constructive negative post.
Appreciation/positive posts aren't limited as this is supposed to be a generally positive forum. Please don't get me wrong - I am all for constructive criticism. I have criticised the show myself before and have had healthy debates with other members. It's when comments outside the topic are made, comments regarding other users, that I feel a line has to be drawn.

As for the 'I am a goldie' threads... I completely disagree with those and I feel they just clutter the forum. If people really want to express that or congratulate others, they should be compiled into one thread.

Originally posted by: .Ghausia.

I understand your point, but I guess there is a limit to what can be posted in a negative light outside the frustration thread. In my opinion, when people start offending others or making generic comments, that's when the post is no longer a constructive negative post.
Appreciation/positive posts aren't limited as this is supposed to be a generally positive forum. Please don't get me wrong - I am all for constructive criticism. I have criticised the show myself before and have had healthy debates with other members. It's when comments outside the topic are made, comments regarding other users, that I feel a line has to be drawn.

As for the 'I am a goldie' threads... I completely disagree with those and I feel they just clutter the forum. If people really want to express that or congratulate others, they should be compiled into one thread.

Originally posted by: CravingKhana

if i am not mistaken its this "clutter" that makes the ipk forum no 1 right...

oh well the idea that one can deem something nonsensical or not...according to thier sensibilites and the unfairness of that is the issue here...

I wouldn't know about that. Mods act for a reason, so ultimately their view of the thread counts. In this instant I agreed with the decision made by them, but there are times that I don't. Everyone has different opinions, and unfortunately you can't always please everyone.

Originally posted by: .Ghausia.

I wouldn't know about that. Mods act for a reason, so ultimately their view of the thread counts. In this instant I agreed with the decision made by them, but there are times that I don't. Everyone has different opinions, and unfortunately you can't always please everyone.