Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon

India-Forums

   
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon

IP REDUX; Janus !! (Page 82)

ranjitha IF-Dazzler
ranjitha
ranjitha

Joined: 23 October 2005
Posts: 4885

Posted: 07 August 2012 at 11:32pm | IP Logged

Hola reduxians Hug

Yesterday from 8 to 9:30 I experienced several emotions.. was dancing looking at ASR-Dadi confrontation... was feeling proud that I understood ASR everytime... was feeling emotional seeing the entire forum going ga-ga over Barun's performance...was wondering all these just for a show? a fictional character? for the love of the actor who doesnt even know that I exist?

EPISODE:

There are bad episodes, good episodes, there are sooper awesome episodes and then there are 'whistle worthy' episodes and this was one such...StarStarStar

I felt like whisteling for each and every dialogue of ASR... what a chemistry this dadi-pota have... two strong characters portrayed by two fantabulous actors... wavvv whatta treat it was!!!!Clap

I was always telling that when time comes, ASR will stand by what is right and will also take the responsiblity of all thw wrongs that happened and yesterday's episode just proved that. Sathu, Sampin, Anna, Anu, Divs, JW everybody kept telling that crying buckets is not his style of redemption.. he will repent.. he will redeem.. but in ASR's style... even after watching yesterday's episode, if people have prolem with ASR, then that just means that they have not understood the him at all !!!!

ASR and Dadi are xerox copies of each other and what we witnessed yesterday was truly 'THE CLASH OF TITANS'. A young boy who was born with a silver sppon, was all off a sudden thrown out of his sheesh mahal to witness how the real world was...Unfortunately he witnessed the cruel part of the world... this world took away the innocence and the warmth from chote... it killed the malik in him and then was born the Arnav Singh Raizada... arrogant, ruthless angry young man!!!

It took him 14 years to realize that the world is not all that cruel... this world of his still has people worth his love and care and who care to love him.. He was all set to give his heart its due importance that his past came stood in front of him in the form of dadi. No matter who says what, certain things can never be forgotten and a bad past will stay with us forever... and now his anger, frustration, fear are making a comeback in his life... but will Khushi stand by him and help him fight them? Only time can tell !!

PERFORMANCES:

Barun Sobti: Actually I had no intention to list the performances, but then dadi was too good, so yeah.. Somebody said it right yesterday, everyday you outdo yourself and set new benchmark in acting... Every wrinkle every cell of yours emotes !!! Your eyes and voice modulation are your USP and yesterday you were just perfect... TAKE A BOW !!! ClapClapClapClapClapClapClapClapClap

Swatijee: I have always felt that, a confrontation scene can fall flat if either of the two actors involved are not upto the mark... yesterday's scene was epic because both of you were acting as if you were asked to prove who's better than whom... Not once did I feel that it was your first major scene with Barun... if Daljeet-Barun look like real siblings, then you both do look like real dadi-pota... ClapClap 

REDUX:

@Sathu: Thank you for that sweet message.. louv ya Hug

@ANNA: you have explained the clash of titans extremely well.. kudos galHugHug

@JACHU: The USP of redux is, each one of them have their unique style of analysing the episode and you have just added a new category to it 'THE FEELINGS'. Your take on raksha bandhan was one of the best I had read that day and today's analysis is no exception... Not once did I even bother to think how Arnav's bonding would have been with his father.. thanks a ton for this post deae Hug Someday I really really want to hear from Arnav what all he went through and what made him become the shaitaan !!


TRP:

Frankly speaking, I did expect the TRP to rise this week, for every episode was top notch. I'm yet to understand what is that the audience wants? what will make them come back and watch this show? I really hope SP understands that its not always the TRP that decides how good the show is, just the way you cannot judge somebody's intelligent by one test or exam !!

CVs and Gul:

You are giving us one of the best possible tracks of IPK. Do not get influenced by TRP or other pressures. I have seen many shows that, though not high with TRPs, have made  amark for themselves by giving good story  and performances. Please stick to your story.

The following 10 member(s) liked the above post:

suhanamausamstar303malsubNina90sunshine99namedxsharmibalan..mrinalini..vaatuhaarariti4u

riti4u IF-Stunnerz
riti4u
riti4u

Joined: 29 August 2010
Posts: 27410

Posted: 07 August 2012 at 11:33pm | IP Logged
I have less time today but wanted to say something to all fabulous writers here...it is great to see your passion and love for this show ..Each day you not only take time out but pen down your feelings here with so much depth and emotions..I cud see so many long posts in starting pages but I hardly get time to read many of you... but take this as my compliment for all wonderful work you have done so far ...ClapClapClapClapClap
 

The following 5 member(s) liked the above post:

nivedha84sunshine99namedx..mrinalini..vaatuhaara

swapna08 Goldie
swapna08
swapna08

Joined: 08 February 2012
Posts: 2117

Posted: 07 August 2012 at 11:34pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by swapna08

Originally posted by tanthya

Originally posted by swapna08

Originally posted by tanthya

Originally posted by sunshine99

Originally posted by tanthya

Originally posted by swapna08


Why could not she have come for the wedding ??
she never approved of manorama and since not her own family she decided not to take part
Why did she shift lock,stock & Barrel to Ashram??What triggered it ?? 
did not want "that women" to stay at home the first time around , nobody approved  so she left being a widow best not to interfere
Why does Nani say,"U handed over the  rights of caring for this children over to me " what does this mean...Does it not imply that Dadi did come back to hand over the kids or that she was aware of something which Nani was not...
after the trajady took place she did come back but was not in the right frame of mind as most ppl judged her son and the younger one threw them out of sheesh mahal leading for them no place to stay so handed over to nani

Why is the uptight Dadi quite approving of Papa ??

 probably knew her son's attraction  so did not approve of the women to stay,
or as royal think servants are to be used and thrown, so does not think her son was wrong and squarely blames that women


What has Manorama got to do with it ?? This was  Malik wedding  not Raizada Wedding ..


She does not come across as a weak woman, her words carry weight

Had she been at home, How the hell would Chachaji dare to throw out his elder bro's son...


She has a class distinction n seems to be friend of  Nani..would she have approved of her Son's liaison with another woman ..Would she have been approving of her son at all..
I think she took some decisions on the wedding night or prior to that which backfired with catastrophe and she couldnot take it and left for Ashram to live a life of recluse... somehow the info has come to her tht there is a similar upheaval in the lives of her grandchildren due to a middle class/low class girl who worked for them...and she has come back to set things right tht she failed to do earlier... galat jagah pe dhundh rahi hain..she is again concentrating on the wrong end like she did in the past... but why do I feel she will do more damage than good "scattering of chanas.." and Khushi and Arnav will have to set things right... thus freeing all of them of the past.


That is interesting, Koel ..

Now  comes the intriguing part.. Agreed that she took a decision, a wrong one...BUT why is there a marked lack of n anger at her Son, A man who brought infamy, who destryed  the lifes of many, Why does she want  Arnav to accept n respect  his father??



sathu there was a dialogue by arnav where he says i dont want anyone saying his name in this house even though i respect him a lot


DG,

Arnav was a little Boy then... Dadi was not ..So why does Dadi  not bear any anger on the SOn n wants Arnav to accept his father



dont know yaar dimaag ka Khichdi pak gaya 
probably junior malik responsible put blame on senior malik and dadi holds senior responsible but later finds out its juniors fault so expects arnav to forgive and respect

 and 15 years is not a young boys yaar will know gud and bad


or the affair could have happened a few years ago  after which the lady was thrown out  and returns after a couple of years with a kid  which causes  to a lot of hoolahoop,
dadi  might have been home the first time around and then would have left to ashram thinking she has spoil t her friends daughters life, but after a lot of request would have returned back to seesh mahal for wedding  and then the mom would have killed herself with this ladies reappearance  leading her to gine the kids to nani and return back to aashram, 

sharmibalan IF-Rockerz
sharmibalan
sharmibalan

Joined: 16 April 2012
Posts: 6967

Posted: 07 August 2012 at 11:34pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by tanthya

Originally posted by sunshine99

Originally posted by tanthya

Originally posted by swapna08


Why could not she have come for the wedding ??
she never approved of manorama and since not her own family she decided not to take part
Why did she shift lock,stock & Barrel to Ashram??What triggered it ?? 
did not want "that women" to stay at home the first time around , nobody approved  so she left being a widow best not to interfere
Why does Nani say,"U handed over the  rights of caring for this children over to me " what does this mean...Does it not imply that Dadi did come back to hand over the kids or that she was aware of something which Nani was not...
after the trajady took place she did come back but was not in the right frame of mind as most ppl judged her son and the younger one threw them out of sheesh mahal leading for them no place to stay so handed over to nani

Why is the uptight Dadi quite approving of Papa ??

 probably knew her son's attraction  so did not approve of the women to stay,
or as royal think servants are to be used and thrown, so does not think her son was wrong and squarely blames that women


What has Manorama got to do with it ?? This was  Malik wedding  not Raizada Wedding ..


She does not come across as a weak woman, her words carry weight

Had she been at home, How the hell would Chachaji dare to throw out his elder bro's son...


She has a class distinction n seems to be friend of  Nani..would she have approved of her Son's liaison with another woman ..Would she have been approving of her son at all..
I think she took some decisions on the wedding night or prior to that which backfired with catastrophe and she couldnot take it and left for Ashram to live a life of recluse... somehow the info has come to her tht there is a similar upheaval in the lives of her grandchildren due to a middle class/low class girl who worked for them...and she has come back to set things right tht she failed to do earlier... galat jagah pe dhundh rahi hain..she is again concentrating on the wrong end like she did in the past... but why do I feel she will do more damage than good "scattering of chanas.." and Khushi and Arnav will have to set things right... thus freeing all of them of the past.


That is interesting, Koel ..

Now  comes the intriguing part.. Agreed that she took a decision, a wrong one...BUT why is there a marked lack of n anger at her Son, A man who brought infamy, who destryed  the lifes of many, Why does she want  Arnav to accept n respect  his father??
 
Sathya...from what i observed in the conversation...
 
Looks like Dadi had taken the alliance for her son to Nani...(they are childhood friends)
 
 
We are not sure whether the proposal was accepted by Asr's dad...Dadi being the one to decide might have forced the alliance on her son...
 
 
ASR being shrewd must have observed this from the beginning(childhood days)...Hence the anger...He always grew up as an angry child...unable to help his mom...Kids from broken marriage are usually of that nature...
 
 
Dadi must have always tried to contain the situation...for her son...Until that fateful day...where everything fell apart...
 
Some people are with the mentality where they always blame others for the mistakes...(thats what Dadi has to learn)
 
Thats why dadi blames the other lady instead of her son...and commands ASR to respect his dad...
 
Asr loves his mom...he doesn't care for his dad nor the other women...as both have wronged his mom...
 
 
 
(please pardon my spellings and grammer...blaming it on my healthCry)


Edited by sharmibalan - 07 August 2012 at 11:40pm

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

hyde2004sunshine99

.Mandy. Channel Moderator
.Mandy.
.Mandy.

Joined: 24 January 2005
Posts: 52631

Posted: 07 August 2012 at 11:35pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by ranjitha

TRP:

Frankly speaking, I did expect the TRP to rise this week, for every episode was top notch. I'm yet to understand what is that the audience wants? what will make them come back and watch this show? I really hope SP understands that its not always the TRP that decides how good the show is, just the way you cannot judge somebody's intelligent by one test or exam !!

CVs and Gul:

You are giving us one of the best possible tracks of IPK. Do not get influenced by TRP or other pressures. I have seen many shows that, though not high with TRPs, have made  amark for themselves by giving good story  and performances. Please stick to your story.


The TRPs remaining steady is impressive given many shows slipped, with this track I'm hoping the TRPs increase but if not I don't want the CVs to be disheartened because so far they've delivered with this track.

The following 5 member(s) liked the above post:

star303Nina90namedxsharmibalan..mrinalini..

nivedha84 IF-Dazzler
nivedha84
nivedha84

Joined: 21 June 2009
Posts: 4696

Posted: 07 August 2012 at 11:36pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by tanthya

Originally posted by sunshine99

Originally posted by tanthya

Originally posted by swapna08


Why could not she have come for the wedding ??
she never approved of manorama and since not her own family she decided not to take part
Why did she shift lock,stock & Barrel to Ashram??What triggered it ?? 
did not want "that women" to stay at home the first time around , nobody approved  so she left being a widow best not to interfere
Why does Nani say,"U handed over the  rights of caring for this children over to me " what does this mean...Does it not imply that Dadi did come back to hand over the kids or that she was aware of something which Nani was not...
after the trajady took place she did come back but was not in the right frame of mind as most ppl judged her son and the younger one threw them out of sheesh mahal leading for them no place to stay so handed over to nani

Why is the uptight Dadi quite approving of Papa ??

 probably knew her son's attraction  so did not approve of the women to stay,
or as royal think servants are to be used and thrown, so does not think her son was wrong and squarely blames that women



What has Manorama got to do with it ?? This was  Malik wedding  not Raizada Wedding ..


She does not come across as a weak woman, her words carry weight

Had she been at home, How the hell would Chachaji dare to throw out his elder bro's son...


She has a class distinction n seems to be friend of  Nani..would she have approved of her Son's liaison with another woman ..Would she have been approving of her son at all..
I think she took some decisions on the wedding night or prior to that which backfired with catastrophe and she couldnot take it and left for Ashram to live a life of recluse... somehow the info has come to her tht there is a similar upheaval in the lives of her grandchildren due to a middle class/low class girl who worked for them...and she has come back to set things right tht she failed to do earlier... galat jagah pe dhundh rahi hain..she is again concentrating on the wrong end like she did in the past... but why do I feel she will do more damage than good "scattering of chanas.." and Khushi and Arnav will have to set things right... thus freeing all of them of the past.


That is interesting, Koel ..

Now  comes the intriguing part.. Agreed that she took a decision, a wrong one...BUT why is there a marked lack of n anger at her Son, A man who brought infamy, who destryed  the lifes of many, Why does she want  Arnav to accept n respect  his father??

May be Dadi knows something which others dont know,as u asked couple of days back what if Sr.Malik is a Gem of a Person?

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

sunshine99sharmibalan

riti4u IF-Stunnerz
riti4u
riti4u

Joined: 29 August 2010
Posts: 27410

Posted: 07 August 2012 at 11:36pm | IP Logged
just was gonna log off...so why u do this to me redux...LOL
@ranju - yesterday was whistle blowing episode...I cud understand ur emotions..and very well said...his style of redemption is not about crying buckets,..but to correct what he has done wrong...Sometimes I just feel proud of him...like he is one of my own and man who makes him as my own -Take a bow...

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

hyde2004ranjithasharmibalan

ranjitha IF-Dazzler
ranjitha
ranjitha

Joined: 23 October 2005
Posts: 4885

Posted: 07 August 2012 at 11:38pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by .Mandy.

Originally posted by ranjitha

TRP:

Frankly speaking, I did expect the TRP to rise this week, for every episode was top notch. I'm yet to understand what is that the audience wants? what will make them come back and watch this show? I really hope SP understands that its not always the TRP that decides how good the show is, just the way you cannot judge somebody's intelligent by one test or exam !!

CVs and Gul:

You are giving us one of the best possible tracks of IPK. Do not get influenced by TRP or other pressures. I have seen many shows that, though not high with TRPs, have made  amark for themselves by giving good story  and performances. Please stick to your story.


The TRPs remaining steady is impressive given many shows slipped, with this track I'm hoping the TRPs increase but if not I don't want the CVs to be disheartened because so far they've delivered with this track.
Hey Mod... it is very rare that I have a normal convo with any mod.. LOL
yes true, CVs should not be disheartened at all... And we are in better position in SP shows too.. so yeah wanna be optimistic Big smile

The following 5 member(s) liked the above post:

suhanamausamhyde2004sharmibalan..mrinalini..tanthya

Go to top

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Topic Index

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index