Crooner 1.16 :When the clock strikes 12 - Updtd - Page 28

Posted: 11 years ago
Originally posted by Sunshine80


Hola my buddies๐Ÿค—

Just peeped to say Hello Hi

Hello hi darling๐Ÿค—๐Ÿค—
Posted: 11 years ago
anjali,
wonderful you bring back the elements. you are right about the water and earth also the lizard i'm sure. we were told it's lucky to have a lizard fall on you, you'll be king. there was too much of the shuddhi thing going on too. i had a problem with the rose scene so couldn't feel it that much. but i like the elements. and yes you'd said water would be the most important of all. the last scene made that pretty clear. all dadi's fire will soon be doused i hope.

i felt dadi was just the kind of mother who gave birth to a son like arnav's dad, who from what nani says and how everyone else keeps mum about, wasn't the nicest guy to know. i also feel that night 14 years ago, its secrets and aftermath shut down arnav's gentler truer side bringing his dadi like aukat conscious side to the fore to face the harsh realities of of his world. just thoughts.

lovely post.Edited by indi52 - 11 years ago
Posted: 11 years ago
Originally posted by indi52


hi shweta,
just read your post, enjoyed the way you asked how did dadi just presume she knew who was what in hat home after her 14 year stay away. sometimes, commin sense iscgiven such a bye bye.

ok, since you have a special affinity with khushi thought i'd say this to you. somehow that roses scene did nothing for me. felt forced. as forced as khushi giving roses to di the other day. so a rose metaphor is now being held up to us, but the plots are too obvious.

and if khushi doesn't feel arnav has given her the respect she deserves, and the contract still bothers her, which is fine with me, it's normal and i love it when khushi believes she deserves something; in such a situation would khushi be entering his extremely personal world and tending his plants? maybe she would. it was just a funny feeling, while she looked lovely, something didn't gel. would appreciate your thoughts.


Yes Di.. I agree with you when you say that the scene seemed a little forced.. a disconnected small scene with nothing preceding it and nothing following either, except for the water in the tub that could have been shown in many other possible ways! Thats why I also mentioned in my post that the small scene was done only for a certain significance.. for the roses maybe, which has always had an importance in our show and Priya also explained how its significant!

Other than that, I feel it may have been added also to show how Khushi was tending to something which is extremely personal to Arnav!
After the night of the pearl necklace and the silent communication only that morning, Khushi may have begun to accept her place in his life, to believe in his love for her and to also assume some haq!!
Only to be brought back to reality later on by Daadi's harsh comments and Maami's reminder! This is just a way of showing that even though Khushi is trying to accept ASR's love and acknowledging all his efforts, the insecurities do surface every now and then! She was again made conscious of how she got married and how she has not been given the due respect!! This will go away only with ASR's renewed and repeated efforts!!

This is what I gathered from the episode.. I hope I made some sense Di..!!

Posted: 11 years ago
Originally posted by Nandalala


"I shut my eyes and all the world drops dead; 
I lift my eyes and all is born again." 

~Sylvia Plath

 Pic Credit: FB

Edited~

 I just love that first quote by Virginia Wolf, hun...and your title is perfect...taking us back to midnight...in that garden again...where past and present meet.  A fabulous, insightful and concise Crooner! ๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘ For me, this epi hit several important notes with one common theme...It was defined by those roses she was tending to. Roses that he planted, she was now the caretaker...Roses that symbolize love, faithfulness, and purity...The same roses which have thorns that can cause you to abandon them because of the pain.  And then the rosebuds--nascent, tender and without thorns.  A perfect metaphor for the past and present; old and new.  The other note for me was the re-introduction of certain elements...namely, Water, Fire & Earth...We all know the significance of Water in this show, so I won't touch on that right now...But I was more intrigued by the Earth brought in--with Khushi tending to those roses...and then with Daadi not allowing Khushi to step foot into "her" space, delineating an invisible line immediately...again, marking a difference between past and present...old and new. Finally, the Bal Gopal reference--Janamashtami--a time of rebirth...new beginnings...the new baby on the horizon and its implications for our story. Taking an age old tradition in the 21st century and still giving it the same importance that it was given centuries ago...the more things change, the more they stay the same...

"...Jise Hum Itna Pyaar Kartein Hain"

These fabulous words eclipsed and set the tone from Friday's fantastic episode.  She has now had her awakening!  She has now recognized the love that he brings to her being.  Accepted it.  If she dares to shut out that very love as she learns about his past, their past--hum unhe teekh se jaante bhi nahi-she will be drawn into to a dark world.  An ultimate test for Khushi as the gatekeeper for all things Raizada and Gupta, too.  Thus to my quote today: will she chose to keep her eyes open or her eyes shut?  Will love motivate her, or make her a victim?  

The answer came to me in the next scene.  She walks with the basin of water to tend to the plants outside--again--the nurturer--here.  Very interesting...she sees a lizard. Lizards are a symbol of dreams and perceptions...Again, the CVs don't leave anything to chance, do they?๐Ÿ˜† She throws the water on the ground and unto Dadi... A cleansing...Water on Dadi's face..Every ritual in the Hindu tradition begins with water and fire.  Water is needed to purify--the mind, the space and the being itself!  When I had written about Seize-Fire in my seat-filler edition of the Crooner, I had said water will always trump every other element!  For me, Dadi represents the past--part of fire--just as Shyam and Anjali do, too...It will be Arnav--Water--who will be the key there to wash away the sins of the old...and allow them to triumph anew as a couple.  Yes, Khushi's education into his past is critical and she will be the "key" for him, but not before he steps up to quell the fire! 

In a deliberate attempt to talk about "class", social distinction, and societal norms, the CVs took some broad liberties today...I, too, was amazed and irked at how quickly Khushi was marginalized to a "servant" where as all of a sudden Payal appeared to be "elevated" to the Raizada bahu.  Was it because Payal is, in fact, the only Raizada bahu?  Khushi is really a Mallik bahu, after all! It was also interesting to note that this perception was at play while Naani and Anjali were both out of the house.  I think the point was to show that within a generation, mindsets can be so different.  Naani is just as opinionated on certain matters as Dadi, but she never once made Khushi feel like a "naukar"...As you pointed out, Manorama was also a maid to Naani, but now accepted as the bahu.  I found it interesting that Dadi was willing to talk and take items from Manorama, knowing who she is...so double standard, much?  The implications of princess to naukar and vice versa are obvious here!  Not to mention the reference to 12 again...

"Welcome to 'Unwelcome.'"
~Jarod Kintz

Earth...stepping into unwelcome space...After talking to Payal, Khushi decides she will go and talk to Dadi to find out more about her.  Khushi was willing to take the first step again to find out more about her beloved's past.  But her attempt was thwarted by Dadi.  Just a gesture...that hand forbidding  her to come within. Khushi walks back...tracing back her footsteps! I had to wonder here about the distance: will Khushi be given all the facts about the past or will it be that they will only reveal that which they want her to see while bridging that gap between Mallik and Raizada to get to Arnav?  Seeing the Bal Gopal in that scene  brought me back to Janamashtami last year...where Arnav and Khushi held the diya so that the flame didn't extinguish; I couldn't help but connect that scene to what we saw on Friday, and also its implications for all the revelations on the horizon! Finally, Earth as Mother...seeing Anjali and Daadi together--Anjali's initial reaction was heart wrenching, but Dadi seemed very cold to her until she commented on her pregnancy (did Shyam possibly tell her?) Followed by Anjali's questioning her about abandonment...After the death of their mother on that fateful night, Anjali and Arnav became orphans...A relationship that they seemed to have cherished, walked its way away from them.  Ground slipping from under them! Dadi did not offer her an explanation other than to say she was back and everything would be alright...I absolutely loved your reference to bhikarna here--those pearls, memories of the past, truths...all scattered...and all waiting to become whole and complete again!

"The past lies beneath the surface, intransigent truth. Remembered or not, what we say and do remains, always." 
~Meredith Hill

My aha moment in the epi came while seeing the two sides of the chessboard at play! We saw Anjali and Dadi on one end, and Naani and Arnav at the other ...in that one frame.  Past and Present. Arnav's face was absolutely a give away here--his shock at seeing Dadi in his home, but his eyes gave away his pain at being abandoned and alone...More importantly, a realization for me, that somewhere along the way, he obviously had found out that Dadi was in an ashram, but it sounds like he never made an attempt to contact her--the total opposite of Anjali!  He wanted the past to stay where it belonged--away from him!  Completely in keeping with his character!

Other thoughts~

~NK was awesome today!  Loved his reference to "taare" above!  We all know the significance there!

~Mamiji and Payal were just hopeless...hopeless!  Ultimately, such COWARDS!

~Anjali was spot-on!  Loved her scene...it was emotional, but she hit it to a T!

~Oh, I have some thoughts on Subhadra...let me think on them some more before I share it with all of you!๐Ÿ˜ƒ

PRECAP:  Here is where Arnav becomes ASR for everyone but Khushi!!!๐Ÿ˜ƒ  United we stand, divided we fall!๐Ÿ˜ƒ Super LOVED it!!

After a long time, I felt a lull in watching today...but the precap made up for it! I loved Sanaya in the scene with the roses--so "earthy" right there!  I agree, Daljeet made up for her lackluster emoting in the latter part of last week...Enjoyed her thoroughly!  Swati Chitnis--I have watched some of her scenes in the past--and this genre of acting is her forte!  She is very good in playing the matriarch and I am sure she will be a treat to watch...But for now, we wait for tomorrow!

HAPPY BIRTHDAY to your ARNAB, hun!  Absolutely LOVE that song!!!!๐Ÿ˜Š

Finally, CONGRATULATIONS to all my gals!!!๐Ÿค—๐Ÿค—
 



Brilliant take once again GS...loved it to bits especially the part where you have written about the elements and also the rose symbolism๐Ÿ‘

I have also given up on Mami and Payal...inhe koi get out hi kardo baba๐Ÿ˜ก
Posted: 11 years ago
Originally posted by --Nishita--



Hello hi darling๐Ÿค—๐Ÿค—

Jhappi darling๐Ÿค—
Posted: 11 years ago
Originally posted by indi52


hi harichandana,
respect to you and your husband. that's what love is about i guess.

Thank you for those lovely words ๐Ÿ˜Š
Posted: 11 years ago
๐Ÿ‘ mindblowing episode. where is the whistle smiley when you need it! i love swati chitnis' acting. powerhouse performance by both her and Barun. what a pair!!!  was smiling wryly so much when he was describing dadi's characteristics... it sounded so much like self description hehehehe. ๐Ÿ˜†
Posted: 11 years ago
Originally posted by mashira


๐Ÿ‘ mindblowing episode. where is the whistle smiley when you need it! i love swati chitnis' acting. powerhouse performance by both her and Barun. what a pair!!!  was smiling wryly so much when he was describing dadi's characteristics... it sounded so much like self description hehehehe. ๐Ÿ˜†

I read about the first head to head takkar...Arnav vs Dadi sounds very very interesting. 
Posted: 11 years ago
Originally posted by mashira


mindblowing episode. where is the whistle smiley when you need it! i love swati chitnis' acting. powerhouse performance by both her and Barun. what a pair!!! was smiling wryly so much when he was describing dadi's characteristics... it sounded so much like self description hehehehe. ๐Ÿ˜†


Ditto!! And when dadi said "jab hum baat kar rahe hain toh...". Dadi-pota ek hi mitti ke bane hain. ๐Ÿ˜†

Fab epi... Loved the scene between Dadi and Arnav... Such powerful performances!
Posted: 11 years ago
Originally posted by mashira


๐Ÿ‘ mindblowing episode. where is the whistle smiley when you need it! i love swati chitnis' acting. powerhouse performance by both her and Barun. what a pair!!!  was smiling wryly so much when he was describing dadi's characteristics... it sounded so much like self description hehehehe. ๐Ÿ˜†


                 

Related Topics

No Related topics found

Topic Info

45 Participants 346 Replies 21984Views

Topic started by honeypriya

Last replied by ShinyJiji

loader
loader
up-open TOP