Posted: 07 August 2012 at 7:12am | IP Logged
Originally posted by tara_211
Disclaimer: This post is not a Manvi bashing post at all!
EHMMBH has been disappointing from the past few weeks (well for me its been disappointing since much longer!!)
I know fans are really happy to see the new promo. After days of rona-dhona a happy track is definitely sumthing to look forward to!
BUT the entire baby se pehle tu aati hai mannu wasn't a dialogue well written.
(i really dint like the chutku word hence will use baby)
Not only did it blindly give away the future track...but also it was sad to hear it from a few weeks pregnant woman!
It is pretty clear that Jeevika wont even think twice before giving her baby away for Manvi...well yes it does go superbly well with the title of the show...but for a mother...sacrificing ur baby for anyone is not at all easy! And the promo just made it too easy!!
The dialogue would have been much better had it been baby ke saath tu bhi mere liye utni hi zaroori hai...nd hence would have also given a glimpse of the dilemma Jeevika might have to go through in the future track!!
PS. will definitely reply to logical replies...nd will ignore the rest conveniently!
I completely agree with you. I liked the promo. It was over all a good one except for Jeevika's dialogue at the end. Manvi is more important than my baby !? What was the necessity of that dialogue at that point. It was just Manvi's roka. She looked hale and healthy. So why?
If it was meant to give insight to the future track, then no I dint get it.
What I got from the promo was, Jeevika wont even think twice before giving up the baby for Manvi. Is that what the CVs planned?!
Frankly I am not up for this Jeevika's choosing btw Manvi and her baby to glorify the behna band. The CVs should have taken some other route. Personally, I ll accept this track if and only if the baby is unharmed.
But, anyway, this is going to be the track. And this is a very sensitive topic to touch upon. They are already messing up with cancer. So I am not having much expectations.
If this track is not handled carefully+sensitively, I fear they are gonna lose much of the audience !!