Debate Mansion
Debate Mansion

India-Forums

   

Do we have rights to commit suicide ? (Page 5)

--arti-- Goldie
--arti--
--arti--

Kasturi, RKS Banner Contest Winner
Joined: 20 June 2008
Posts: 1670

Posted: 19 October 2012 at 4:19pm | IP Logged
I really think we need to challenge the liberal* framework of individual rights sometimes, and particularly when it comes to things like "right to suicide," "right to wage slavery," "right to buy bottled water," etc. When I say liberal here, I am invoking the intellectual-philosophical tradition that has informed much of how modern society is organized. Also, this tradition has a particular history, particular roots, and particular proponents.. it didn't just come into place because everyone thought it was great or because it is some kind of "natural" development in human history. I say this as a preface because it is important to understand that intellectual biases have histories, sometimes violent histories. I also say this by way of introducing some politics into this conversation. And that's because suicide is political.

Obviously liberalism played a big role in shaping modern society and our conception of rights and responsibilities, and there is merit to using that concept when we have to negotiate our current legal framework. There are notable ways in which social movements have used the language of rights to mobilize for change and so on. But there are also major problems with this approach.

First, it assumes that the framework of rights addresses human freedom, social justice and so on, and it actually doesn't. Instead it abstracts us as somehow all having certain rights when the truth is that we all face different social realities. Having the "right" to buy food is irrelevant if I can't afford it. And having the "right" to free speech means nothing if I can't access education, or if I can't speak up because I have always been told to be quiet.

Second, it ignores power relations more broadly. Anytime we debate a question with social implications, I think we should ask about how power operates in that context. Not power as a disembodied thing. Everyday social situations or encounters are always marked by power, whether we see it or not. For example, wealth, access to education, access to markers of a fulfilling life, like a decent job, or an emotional support system, etc.

People may be driven to suicide because of a range of factors, but instead of looking at it abstractly, we may want to ask, what are certain factors that contribute to a good quality of life, and who does not have access to such a good quality of life. If we do that, then we have to talk about economic justice, exploitation, and certain other social problems. Then our conversation about suicide becomes a responsible conversation that actually grounds the problem in the real world.

Following from that, if we were to say that we need to address social problems (something let's say that as a society, we are all collectively accountable for) to prevent suicide, then we have ourselves a different question to debate altogether. I would much rather debate that question. Why? Because I think it is grounded in social realities, not decontextualized and abstracted as if it is a mathematical problem that can be solved by logic alone. I think when we are asked such questions, it is important to complicate the terms of the debate a bit and not take it at face value. In fact, challenging the terms of the debate is in itself an important analytical contribution to any debate.

Suicide involves death and is obviously tragic. But other forms of death are also tragic. It's tragic die from preventable illnesses, for example.  But why is it that terms like cowardice are used to talk about suicide? Why does suicide demand the kind of attention that it does, and why does it horrify or fascinate people in the way that it does? Could it be that it potentially signifies the extreme end of individual freedom.. that someone could cut themselves off from society? I don't really know. But I do know that the individualism that is inherently produced through the phrase "right to suicide" needs to be challenged if we are going to try to understand why it happens, or even better, if we are interested in preventing it.

As my homeboy Marx said philosophers have interpreted the world, but the point is to change it.

* and by liberal, I mean the technical philophical term, and I am not (mis)using it to mean "leftist." Liberalism as a philosophy of individualism and individual self-determination, etc.
-Raichu- IF-Rockerz
-Raichu-
-Raichu-

Joined: 07 April 2012
Posts: 5908

Posted: 21 October 2012 at 6:39am | IP Logged
My personal opinion is No !


return_to_hades IF-Veteran Member
return_to_hades
return_to_hades

Joined: 18 January 2006
Posts: 21526

Posted: 21 October 2012 at 7:19am | IP Logged
Originally posted by Agathe

My personal opinion is No !




And the rationale for it?

Just saying, this is Debate Mansion. TongueLOL

Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Author Replies Views Last Post
Why do people commit suicide

2 3 4 5

Author: raatkarahi   Replies: 32   Views: 2607

raatkarahi 32 2607 16 December 2010 at 2:38am by Summer3
India- officially worst human rights abuser

2 3

Author: Shambo   Replies: 18   Views: 1335

Shambo 18 1335 01 October 2009 at 4:39pm by qwertyesque
Women equal rights vs Women Reservation

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

Author: -Believe-   Replies: 71   Views: 6946

-Believe- 71 6946 02 September 2009 at 4:08am by angelic_devil
A person suppose to commit suicude, your reaction?

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Author: vinay.batra   Replies: 76   Views: 2992

vinay.batra 76 2992 08 August 2009 at 11:25am by Fair-n-luvly
Women-Men...equal rights?

2 3 4

Author: SmarterDesiKid   Replies: 26   Views: 1816

SmarterDesiKid 26 1816 17 June 2009 at 3:18am by _Angie_

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Debate Mansion Topic Index

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index