Jhalak Dikhhla Ja 5

India-Forums

   
Jhalak Dikhhla Ja 5
Jhalak Dikhhla Ja 5

Giaa and Shibani's scores Deserving?[DT Note Pg10] (Page 11)

Parijatrocks IF-Sizzlerz
Parijatrocks
Parijatrocks

Joined: 18 June 2011
Posts: 21115

Posted: 22 July 2012 at 11:36am | IP Logged
Originally posted by Beelte003

Originally posted by bhavya

Originally posted by Beelte003

Originally posted by Mandy20

i think GIaa deserved perfect 30..  come on, it is her first perfect 30... give her a break yaar... no offense.. it just one 30, and ppl are being rude and saying she didnt deserve it.. aerial performance is very difficult and Giaa is afraid of heights, but she still did so so well... pls be fair ppl.. we didnt say anything when GC or isha or anyone got 30... take a chill pill and just enjoy ur favorite ppl's performance Big smile

I certainly was appreciating, stating their performances were GOOD and not PERFECT, if you'd care to re-read my very first post under this topic. I don't think I've been rude in any manner, I'd rather have the MODS let me know if I was. I think i'm being reasonably fair here in just stating my own opinion. 

p.s. Kudos to Giaa for overcoming her fear but sympathetic appraisal and votes ain't going to last long. No offense, just saying.

lol Topic was really good... nice post... first 30 was okay may be she has to hard work still to get perfect 30 once more..but whether sympathy votes or her performance its votes which counts 50%... the JDJ is not based only on performance its on votes too...but cool she got perfect 30 from judges..already and viewers if they think she deserved thier votes they will vote or else no..

sympathy ho yaa popularity gia will get votes and also scores thats the point lol...Wink


That's why non-deserving contestants always get away with the trophy.  
how can u say she is non deserving so early its just 5 weeks lol...dnt u think she is improving every week...but calling her non deserving when she has not reached even semi finals is really a joke lol... when she reaches semi finals and her performance is below average than u can call her non deserving till than the non-deserving word wont suit her... and even if anyone says she will win its just thier wish lol not a reality...
LOL

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

NazimKiDewani

.Ranju. IF-Dazzler
.Ranju.
.Ranju.

Joined: 11 January 2012
Posts: 3036

Posted: 22 July 2012 at 11:38am | IP Logged
Originally posted by Beelte003

Originally posted by ran2012

At TM I respect your opinion. I am Giaa fan and I really dont have any problem if you think she doesnt deserve 30. But here in the forum always fans of a particular celebrity are criticized saying they are blind and cant take the critics etc etc. Its quite natural for a human being to support the one whom you like. But there are ppl here in the forum who comment negatively about a celebrity coz they just dont like them. Most of the times even though he/she has performed well they are criticized. They are very few ppl in the forum who give their opinion on dance. 

I am certainly aware of those kinda people but then again, there also are people who'd go to any extent to appraise their favorite, whether or not they've performed well or not. They'd be ready to bash a member, call them insecure or jealous if we mention their favorite's performance was average*. All i'm saying is, give respect to earn respect. Don't be blinded by love so much you don't realize you start passing on personal comments and remarks.

I agree that fans get carried away. Jealousy is not a right word to use. But wouldnt it be nice if somebody points both negative and positive aspects of a celebrity. Ppl who dislike a celebrity will never appreciate even if he/she has done well thats when the fights between fans starts!!
nishu786 IF-Sizzlerz
nishu786
nishu786

Joined: 01 December 2009
Posts: 11657

Posted: 22 July 2012 at 11:39am | IP Logged
Gia doesn't deserve to win bcoz there r three(Isha,GC & Shibani) other dancers who r much better than her & more consistent than her...Gia don't deserve to be in top-3 also...she is improving for sure,but the trio i mentioned r more deserving than her anyday.

The following 5 member(s) liked the above post:

NoCommentsmegustajalebikhushboorathTinkerBella-GayabCat-

.Ranju. IF-Dazzler
.Ranju.
.Ranju.

Joined: 11 January 2012
Posts: 3036

Posted: 22 July 2012 at 11:44am | IP Logged
Originally posted by nishu786

Gia doesn't deserve to win bcoz there r three(Isha,GC & Shibani) other dancers who r much better than her & more consistent than her...Gia don't deserve to be in top-3 also...she is improving for sure,but the trio i mentioned r more deserving than her anyday.

Dear isnt it too early to say this? What if GC/Shibahi/Isha dont perform well in the next episodes?And how can you be so sure that Giaa will not perform well in next episodes? Are you not doing the samething as any other fan of a particular celebrity does? Lets wait for sometime and then comment. Yes I agree at current stage she has to improve a lot but it doesnt mean that she cant improve!!
Parijatrocks IF-Sizzlerz
Parijatrocks
Parijatrocks

Joined: 18 June 2011
Posts: 21115

Posted: 22 July 2012 at 11:45am | IP Logged
Originally posted by nishu786

Gia doesn't deserve to win bcoz there r three(Isha,GC & Shibani) other dancers who r much better than her & more consistent than her...Gia don't deserve to be in top-3 also...she is improving for sure,but the trio i mentioned r more deserving than her anyday.
 and i have said gia is in fifth place but why they are calling her non-desrving is a big question... judges know better to give her scores...

first 30 made all think she will win JDJ and started telling she is non-deserving to win and will win JDJ  OMG... come on guys its just first 30 and calling her non-deserving to win JDJ is not good...LOL

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

NazimKiDewaniMandy20

megustajalebi Goldie
megustajalebi
megustajalebi

Joined: 15 February 2012
Posts: 1836

Posted: 22 July 2012 at 11:49am | IP Logged
Originally posted by nishu786

Gia doesn't deserve to win bcoz there r three(Isha,GC & Shibani) other dancers who r much better than her & more consistent than her...Gia don't deserve to be in top-3 also...she is improving for sure,but the trio i mentioned r more deserving than her anyday.

Isha and GC will most likely make it to the the top three mainly thanks to Isha's superb dancing and GC's large fanbase. The third person most likely seems to be Shibani (I remember when people were predicting her elimination so she's improved a lot). Darsheel has a chance too and if Bharti gets higher scores (sad to see her 24) then she has a shot as well. 

But of course, only time will tell. And we also have a wildcard coming in so that can change things 

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

R1U2K3nishu786

R1U2K3 IF-Rockerz
R1U2K3
R1U2K3

Joined: 02 May 2006
Posts: 9572

Posted: 22 July 2012 at 11:53am | IP Logged
Originally posted by bhavya

Originally posted by Beelte003

Originally posted by bhavya

Originally posted by Beelte003

Originally posted by Mandy20

i think GIaa deserved perfect 30..  come on, it is her first perfect 30... give her a break yaar... no offense.. it just one 30, and ppl are being rude and saying she didnt deserve it.. aerial performance is very difficult and Giaa is afraid of heights, but she still did so so well... pls be fair ppl.. we didnt say anything when GC or isha or anyone got 30... take a chill pill and just enjoy ur favorite ppl's performance Big smile

I certainly was appreciating, stating their performances were GOOD and not PERFECT, if you'd care to re-read my very first post under this topic. I don't think I've been rude in any manner, I'd rather have the MODS let me know if I was. I think i'm being reasonably fair here in just stating my own opinion. 

p.s. Kudos to Giaa for overcoming her fear but sympathetic appraisal and votes ain't going to last long. No offense, just saying.

lol Topic was really good... nice post... first 30 was okay may be she has to hard work still to get perfect 30 once more..but whether sympathy votes or her performance its votes which counts 50%... the JDJ is not based only on performance its on votes too...but cool she got perfect 30 from judges..already and viewers if they think she deserved thier votes they will vote or else no..

sympathy ho yaa popularity gia will get votes and also scores thats the point lol...Wink


That's why non-deserving contestants always get away with the trophy.  
how can u say she is non deserving so early its just 5 weeks lol...dnt u think she is improving every week...but calling her non deserving when she has not reached even semi finals is really a joke lol... when she reaches semi finals and her performance is below average than u can call her non deserving till than the non-deserving word wont suit her... and even if anyone says she will win its just thier wish lol not a reality...
LOL

I think I didn't call Giaa non-deserving? It was a mere comment based on the winners of all the previous seasons of Jhalak. I rest my case here.
R1U2K3 IF-Rockerz
R1U2K3
R1U2K3

Joined: 02 May 2006
Posts: 9572

Posted: 22 July 2012 at 11:54am | IP Logged
Originally posted by ran2012

Originally posted by Beelte003

Originally posted by ran2012

At TM I respect your opinion. I am Giaa fan and I really dont have any problem if you think she doesnt deserve 30. But here in the forum always fans of a particular celebrity are criticized saying they are blind and cant take the critics etc etc. Its quite natural for a human being to support the one whom you like. But there are ppl here in the forum who comment negatively about a celebrity coz they just dont like them. Most of the times even though he/she has performed well they are criticized. They are very few ppl in the forum who give their opinion on dance. 

I am certainly aware of those kinda people but then again, there also are people who'd go to any extent to appraise their favorite, whether or not they've performed well or not. They'd be ready to bash a member, call them insecure or jealous if we mention their favorite's performance was average*. All i'm saying is, give respect to earn respect. Don't be blinded by love so much you don't realize you start passing on personal comments and remarks.

I agree that fans get carried away. Jealousy is not a right word to use. But wouldnt it be nice if somebody points both negative and positive aspects of a celebrity. Ppl who dislike a celebrity will never appreciate even if he/she has done well thats when the fights between fans starts!!

Hence, I go back to my first post where I said the performances were good* but not perfect*. I didn't jump onto criticism from scratch.

Go to top

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Jhalak Dikhhla Ja 5 Topic Index

  • Please login to check your Last 10 Topics posted

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index