Buddha
Buddha

India-Forums

   

The 9th avatar of Lord Vishnu??? (Page 7)

ShivangBuch Goldie
ShivangBuch
ShivangBuch

Joined: 31 August 2009
Posts: 1045

Posted: 25 July 2012 at 8:40am | IP Logged
Originally posted by .Vrish.

In this case, I'm not sure about what happened to that dynasty - not very familiar w/ Nepali history.  I asked last weeks MOTW - a Nepali - about it, and she said that the kingdom was probably annexed by the Senas or the Shah dynasty.  Essentially, Sudhodhana's dynasty was over as a result of Siddhartha's actions.
Was it invaded and won by outsiders or subjects were properly handed over by Sidhdharth to a relative dynasty?


Actually, I think that would only be true for Vaishnavs - Shaivyas wouldn't be using the Geeta as the sole book by which to live.
If they consider Geeta to be said by Krishna then they may not accept it to be the sole book. If they see to it as verdict of Supreme speaking through Krishna (May it be Shiv or Durga or anyone), they may accept it to be sole book to guide. I know Shaiva friends who consider it to be acceptable like this. My own family is the follower of Shaivism.

But its DONTs very clearly negate what's allowed in Hinduism.  To continue w/ my example, idolatry is not unlawful, so if a non-Hindu religion condemns idolatry and worse, cracks down on it, then it's very much anti-Hindu in that it's inserting a restriction that doesn't exist in the original.
What you call anti-Hindu, I call it anti-subset of Hinduism. That's precisely my point. Nothing else. What I say and what you say is otherwise not different. Only a matter of terminology or way of defining more than interpreting actually.


The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

Debipriya

ShivangBuch Goldie
ShivangBuch
ShivangBuch

Joined: 31 August 2009
Posts: 1045

Posted: 25 July 2012 at 9:04am | IP Logged

Content Removed

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

Debipriya

bhas1066 Senior Member
bhas1066
bhas1066

Joined: 08 January 2011
Posts: 473

Posted: 25 July 2012 at 9:38am | IP Logged

Content Removed

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

DebipriyaShivangBuch.Vrish.

ShivangBuch Goldie
ShivangBuch
ShivangBuch

Joined: 31 August 2009
Posts: 1045

Posted: 25 July 2012 at 9:55am | IP Logged
Originally posted by bhas1066


Hi ShivangBuch

BTW these are just my conclusion / interpretations of whatever has been said till now in this topic.
Of course. That was clear in your post (although there were quite a few new added points as well). I just asked for confirmation whether what I interpreted from your summarized well compiled conclusion paragraphs was correct or not.

i was myself trying to make  out the answer to my question hence consolidated the points in favour and against Buddha as the 9th avatar. ( and wasn't successfull!!Unhappy. still myself confused!!) . Didint mean to disapprove or offend. In fact i would be glad to have answers for these points against Buddha as it will clear my doubts ,..like the point of Mahaveera ... i didnt know that!!
And the point of Geet Govind I didn't know. Smile Well what we can get through this discussions are the logical inputs of all and we can be clearer in the process and the process is ongoing. One can't be absolutely sure in this but Varaali still has come up with many objective evidences and Lola is absolutely sure in her feelings about Buddha. So I have personally enjoyed and have gained only through this thread. Vrish and Janaki's views are also firm. Probably you are just confused because both views are firm. But both the views are very valid and logical and openminded. And logical arguments haven't actually ended. We are still in harmonization process of thoughts.

No hard feelings or indignation please.
Not at all. Where did you see hard feelings in my post???!!!!!!!!! All were questions asking for clarification or confirmation of what I understood. Questioning is not disagreement. Even logical disagreement in a debate is not what can be called hard feeling.


Edited by ShivangBuch - 25 July 2012 at 9:58am

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

Debipriya

bhas1066 Senior Member
bhas1066
bhas1066

Joined: 08 January 2011
Posts: 473

Posted: 25 July 2012 at 10:18am | IP Logged
@ ShivangBuch
than god u r not offended!!! its just that while in some other forums esp mytho ones people are so passionate on their belief that it leads to them  bashing others as they get hurt by remarks opposing their belief. hence was clarifying beforehand!! i have just only started posting and u r a senior member so thats y i was unsure.

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

DebipriyaShivangBuch

ShivangBuch Goldie
ShivangBuch
ShivangBuch

Joined: 31 August 2009
Posts: 1045

Posted: 25 July 2012 at 10:28am | IP Logged
Smile Oh no no. Not at all offended. In fact, if I am a senior member and you are new member, then on the contrary, I am not supposed to get offended. Big smile Right? Wink Actually I was surprised by your such worry since you must have read many of my posts by now in this thread itself only discussing about opposite views.LOL


And your post in fact was one of the best posts of the thread since it was very well compiled and systematic and open minded and neutral. Highly unbiased and balanced in terms of concluding different views.


Edited by ShivangBuch - 25 July 2012 at 10:41am

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

Debipriya

varaali IF-Dazzler
varaali
varaali

Joined: 17 July 2006
Posts: 2810

Posted: 25 July 2012 at 11:12pm | IP Logged
We seem to be going around in circles.Presently the question in circulation seems to be twofold :

  • Whether Buddha was an avatar of Vishnu or not
  • If so, does he figure in the top 10, or in the larger group of 22?
Let me try to summarize everybody's arguments:

Vrish 's : objection to Gautama Buddha is that in his search for enlightenment, he abandoned his family / kingdom midway without providing for their future. This act of renunciation / abandonment is not sanctified by scriptures, hence this counts against him. Verdict : Cannot be considered an avatar

Janaki : allows Buddha to be an avatar but in the larger group of 22, not in the Dasha Avatar subsect

Shivang : Not all the avatars of Vishnu need to have had identical philosophies. Each avatar was distinct / different from each other. Similarly, despite all the arguments marshalled against Gautama, he can be considered an avatar. Verdict : Can be considered an avatar , that too in the top ten.

Varaali : Now,first of all, I would like to ask who's word do we take as the final authority?  For me, I would like to consider Srimad Bhagavatham / Veda Vyasa  as the guiding source.  And here, there are answers to the questions raised in this thread.

As I said earlier, SB mentions 22 avatars of Vishnu. Let us forget the subsect of Dasha Avatars for a minute and concentrate on the bigger list of 22. In that list, there are avatars as diverse as Kurma (who did nothing put to support the mountain) , King Prithu, Sage Kapila , Mohini and the four Sanat Kumaras.

It is in this list that Buddha is included. Our problem in reconciling with Buddha seems to be the fact that the  tenets that he preached  seem to go against the pillars on which Hinduism stood . My answer to that is this was what he was supposed to do anyway. His birth and his preachings had been predicted at the dawn of Kali Yuga itself. 

Srimad Bhagavtham, Veda Vyasa and Suta Goswami had no problems with accepting the fact that in His next incarnation as Buddha, Vishnu is not going to talk about the Vedas, yagnas, rituals,  etc but will preach on more basic, fundamental  social ethics. 

It is also said in SB itself that such an unique / different avatar will be required because  of the turbulent times the world will be passing through. Scientific knowledge would have advanced so much that men would be shooting invisible rockets / missiles into outer space which will hold a threat of not only destroying life on Earth, but lives(if at all)  on other spheres as well. 

So I am not going to reject Gautama Buddha's claim to avatar hood just because he did not give importance to what is considered sacrosanct in Hinduism. If SB, Vyasa and  Suta have allowed him to be an avatr who am I to question it ?

But that doesn't mean I am going to start celebrating Buddha Jayanti with gusto (except maybe to wish Shivang on his birthday Big smile) . That is because over a period of years, Buddha's followers have changed the colour of his teachings so much that it today stands as a separate religion which makes it difficult for us Hindus to accept them as a part of our faith, let alone accept their founder as an  embodiment of our God. 

Personally though I must admit that while teaching my children, I have found it  more comfortable to include Balarama in, and leave out Buddha. But it is a different story that I don't give much importance to the Top Ten. I like the larger, more inclusive list of 22. 








Edited by varaali - 25 July 2012 at 11:11pm

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

ShivangBuch

.Vrish. Viewbie
.Vrish.
.Vrish.

Joined: 25 October 2008
Posts: 21294

Posted: 25 July 2012 at 11:50pm | IP Logged

Content Removed

Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Author Replies Views Last Post
About Buddha & Vishnu

2 3

Author: Proud-India   Replies: 23   Views: 910

Proud-India 23 910 20 March 2014 at 4:42am by .Vrish.
Himanshu Soni had played Vishnu in Zee TV Ramayan

Author: nneeiill   Replies: 9   Views: 2472

nneeiill 9 2472 30 October 2013 at 10:51am by RoseFairy
Lord of Kings

Author: SRK-MS.DHONIfan   Replies: 3   Views: 223

SRK-MS.DHONIfan 3 223 28 September 2013 at 4:20pm by Ms.S.K.
Lord buddha is born in india

2

Author: sandiya_21683   Replies: 12   Views: 694

sandiya_21683 12 694 16 September 2013 at 7:15am by jyoti06
Buddha-avatar of lord vishnu

Author: Joyel   Replies: 7   Views: 583

Joyel 7 583 10 September 2013 at 5:12pm by SilverBell

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Buddha Topic Index

  • Please login to check your Last 10 Topics posted

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index