Khushi: Guilty or Not Guilty - Page 2

Originally posted by: incandescent

Payal's marriage was not on her mind. It was on Garima and Buaji's mind. Babuji and KHushi were in favor of telling the truth. KHushi only changed her mind after going to RM and seeing Anjali's obsessive love.

She did making a huge mistake by not telling though. I would call it a mistake. 

Its a very grey area we cannot put it into black or white zones - its the actions of some people that avalanched into this mess.

Khushi and her family are guilty of withholding the truth...they are not the ones who get to decide if Shyam is going to redeem himself or not. They shud've approached Naani given that they are sending one of their daughters to the wolf's lair..Shyam cud've manipulated the situation and blackmailed them into giving Khushi to him...Shyam cudve done so much more damage. Now that Khushi also in living in the same place not one of them have addressed the issue of how she is coping till now.

Having said that let me make it clear that i am not making any excuse for any of Arnav's actions...he may love Khushi but he never gave her the benefit of doubt and he never gave her the choice.
He is the sole reason for Khushi encountering Shyam in the first place.

What everyone needs to do is to share the blame and work towards solving the problem rather than stretching it out playing the blame game.

Ok, according to me hiding such a big truth is wrong. But it is not a crime. And I don't think Khushi should be blamed entirely for this...Even the Guptas are at fault.  They are much more elder and therefore, should be more adept at handling this matter. And lets not forget that Arnav has made the same mistake too.Telling such a truth is not an easy matter in real life. Such truths should be handled carefully and revealed appropriately...which is why the Guptas should have handled this. But Khushi being young and naive thought hiding the truth would solve all problems. And yes, she is wrong. But she isn't guilty of a crime... she just took a wrong desicion and she has been/is facing the consequences of her wrong desicion.. 

Originally posted by: preetihere

Its a very grey area we cannot put it into black or white zones - its the actions of some people that avalanched into this mess.

Khushi and her family are guilty of withholding the truth...they are not the ones who get to decide if Shyam is going to redeem himself or not. They shud've approached Naani given that they are sending one of their daughters to the wolf's lair..Shyam cud've manipulated the situation and blackmailed them into giving Khushi to him...Shyam cudve done so much more damage. Now that Khushi also in living in the same place not one of them have addressed the issue of how she is coping till now.

Having said that let me make it clear that i am not making any excuse for any of Arnav's actions...he may love Khushi but he never gave her the benefit of doubt and he never gave her the choice.
He is the sole reason for Khushi encountering Shyam in the first place.

What everyone needs to do is to share the blame and work towards solving the problem rather than stretching it out playing the blame game.

I think khushi is guilty..It wil surface mor clearly wen truth abt shyam plans 2 kill anjali wil b out..

she is guilty ... i mean where is her maturity wen u need it the most?

To me everyone is to blame.

Hmmm...interesting.

I think it was the responsibility of the elders and NOT Khushi to reveal Shyam's true face - this is especially when you are getting your daughter married to the same family.  By not revealing the truth, the Gupta's have aided Shyam in his dishonesty. The foundation of Payash marriage is weak due to this as the trust element is missing. 

Originally posted by: -Gautami

I think khushi is guilty..It wil surface mor clearly wen truth abt shyam plans 2 kill anjali wil b out..