indira bach gayi--mandira phas gayi. - Page 2

[there is nothing likve proviking.. Mandira had no idea what type of person is Sameer... she had no clue of his Pycho nature..

@adinats: sometimes oversmartness is deadly... same is with mandira...

I think everyone is well aware of Mandira's character very well. She was shown a girl who lives only for her. This is what in today's episode I have seen when Indira made the same remark.

Originally posted by: -Sachin-

Agree that no girl will invite.

Well under Law this needs to be justify. Under what circumstances a person has made the crime.

But here it was Mandira herself knowing Sameer attitude ... provoked too much & challenged Sameer... .Mandira already blackmailing her by those fake pics in her mobile.

So she was also on fault. This is what CVs wanted to show.

So u meant,that Sameer didn't have any other option to keep Mandira's mouth shut,other than raping her?? Really?????

Originally posted by: ANTARA-2244

So u meant,that Sameer didn't have any other option to keep Mandira's mouth shut,other than raping her?? Really?????

Originally posted by: -Sachin-

<font face="Georgia, 'Times New Roman', Times, serif" size="3" color="#009966">I think everyone is well aware of Mandira's character very well. She was shown a girl who lives only for her. This is what in today's episode I have seen when Indira made the same remark.</font>

<font face="Georgia, 'Times New Roman', Times, serif" size="3" color="#009966">In past also she herself made into same situation when she ran away with Manoj Chaddha to Macau. Where in hotel room chadda very cleverly mixed some white powder in Mandir's drink & want her to drink. </font>

<font face="Georgia, 'Times New Roman', Times, serif" size="3" color="#009966">So she was very much aware of such facts that provoking a man can result into such situation. </font>

Not provoking 'a man',it should be actually provoking 'a sick *****rd' like Sameer,can result into such situation.Mandira's fault was that she didn't know Sameer was a low-level creature,much lower than her capability of thinking.That's why she is suffering right now.

Originally posted by: -Sachin-

Agree that no girl will invite. 

Well under Law this needs to be justify. Under what circumstances a person has made the crime. 

But here it was Mandira herself knowing Sameer attitude ... provoked too much & challenged Sameer... .Mandira already blackmailing her by those fake pics in her mobile. 

So she was also on fault. This is what CVs wanted to show.

@bold
no.not justification is needed under law.

rape huwa hai yaa nahi only matters.

i raped her because she provoked me dose not hold any water in the eyes of law.

punishment dose not decline even if victim is provoked the rapist.

law is very clear.

rape is offense--it is going to be punished irrespective of circumstances.
Edited by 100raj - 12 years ago

Originally posted by: 100raj

@bold
no.not justification is needed under law.

rape huwa hai yaa nahi only matters.

i raped her because she provoked me dose not hold any water in the eyes of law.

punishment dose not decline even if victim is provoked the rapist.

law is very clear.

rape is offense--it is going to be punished irrespective of circumstances.

I agree... Mandira may be at fault... & sameer might try to put provocation point but it is very important to establish that rape has happened... that is enough to put somebody behind bars...

Law always need justification.It clearly states what was the objective behind the crime. 

Originally posted by: misty85

I agree... Mandira may be at fault... & sameer might try to put provocation point but it is very important to establish that rape has happened... that is enough to put somebody behind bars...

his line of defense is court should be--i am not raped her.

and if he says--i raped her because she provoked me then it result in immediate punishment.no more arguments going to be left.