I think Bhagat Singh and his friends or companions should be given respect.If u call Gandhi, Ghandhiji then atleast Bhagat Singh and his friends shouldnt be called Bhagat Singh and his gang.They were not some gangsters. They need a more respectful name to be adressed to.
1.Do you think India's independence was ultimately the result of Bhagat Singh's methods or Gandhiji's methods or a combination?
India got Independence bcz of both ways . Voilence & non- voilence. so Bhagat Singh, Rajguru, Sukhdev, Netaji, Azad & other freedom fighters , they choose the way of voilence . Gandhi choose non- voilent way.freedom fighters, whether they choose voilence or non- voilence but their aim was one- Independence.
but some ppl give whole credit to Gandhi. Can a single person bring freedom? No. its combination of both.
2. Do you think independence could have come faster if Indian National Congress had adopted Bhagat Singh's methods in addition to Gandhiji's?
yes i think that. Britishers couldnt get scare with so called Andolans & some march paas.at that time they needed some dhamaka which Bhagat Singh , Rajguru, Netaji, Azad & other did.ppl also started to adopt their method . but some Indians didnt like that & they tried to proove the way of Voilence wrong .If Andolans could affect Britishers 30% then Bhagat Singh's method could effect 70% .
there was so many things st that time, still we have which cant be solved only with Ahinsa.sometimes voilence is also becomes neccesory.
3. Many of Bhagat Singh's supporters also accuse Gandhiji of being responsible for Bhagat Singh's death. Some of them believe that Gandhiji could have stopped Bhagat Singh's execution if he desired.
yes I accuse Gandhi for this. thats why I never put "JI" after his name.bcz He was responsible for this.
I also want know Why politicians & some ppl think that its only Gandhi who brought freedom? ok some ppl like his non- voilent way. but Lala Lajpat Rai was also the supporter of Non- Voilence so why he didnt get his respect.He died in lathi chaarj while Andolan against Simon Commision. How many ppl know him? Did Gandhi ever been beaten while any Andolan? answer is No.Why ? was he someone special for Britishers? dont say that he went to jail several times.going to jail was not a big deal.so many other fighters went to jail but hardly few ppl know those freedom fighters.
everytime any Neta talks abt independence they always take Gandhi's name, Why? did Bhagat Singh & friends do nothing for countery?
2 Oct is a national holiday. why 23 March is not a national holiday ?( except Punjab, Punjab have state level holiday). I m not saying that its only Bhagat singh but give due respect to Netaji & others too. why we dont have national holyday on netaji's B'day? Why its only Gandhi - Gandhi everywhere.
few years back some members of Parliment ( they all were frm punjab ) struggled aby the issue that Bhagat Singh's photo should be hanged in parliment. after that I never heard that whether their demand approved or not. But I think its not.
so if politians cant allow to hang Bhagat Singh's photo what kind of respect they can give to him? another thing what the photos of Indira Gandhi, Rajiv Gandhi are doing in the parliment. what they did for countery & its freedom?
Edited by Rajeev Ki Heer - 17 years ago
1.Do you think India's independence was ultimately the result of Bhagat Singh's methods or Gandhiji's methods or a combination?
India got Independence bcz of both ways . Voilence & non- voilence. so Bhagat Singh, Rajguru, Sukhdev, Netaji, Azad & other freedom fighters , they choose the way of voilence . Gandhi choose non- voilent way.freedom fighters, whether they choose voilence or non- voilence but their aim was one- Independence.
but some ppl give whole credit to Gandhi. Can a single person bring freedom? No. its combination of both.
2. Do you think independence could have come faster if Indian National Congress had adopted Bhagat Singh's methods in addition to Gandhiji's?
yes i think that. Britishers couldnt get scare with so called Andolans & some march paas.at that time they needed some dhamaka which Bhagat Singh , Rajguru, Netaji, Azad & other did.ppl also started to adopt their method . but some Indians didnt like that & they tried to proove the way of Voilence wrong .If Andolans could affect Britishers 30% then Bhagat Singh's method could effect 70% .
there was so many things st that time, still we have which cant be solved only with Ahinsa.sometimes voilence is also becomes neccesory.
3. Many of Bhagat Singh's supporters also accuse Gandhiji of being responsible for Bhagat Singh's death. Some of them believe that Gandhiji could have stopped Bhagat Singh's execution if he desired.
yes I accuse Gandhi for this. thats why I never put "JI" after his name.bcz He was responsible for this.
I also want know Why politicians & some ppl think that its only Gandhi who brought freedom? ok some ppl like his non- voilent way. but Lala Lajpat Rai was also the supporter of Non- Voilence so why he didnt get his respect.He died in lathi chaarj while Andolan against Simon Commision. How many ppl know him? Did Gandhi ever been beaten while any Andolan? answer is No.Why ? was he someone special for Britishers? dont say that he went to jail several times.going to jail was not a big deal.so many other fighters went to jail but hardly few ppl know those freedom fighters.
everytime any Neta talks abt independence they always take Gandhi's name, Why? did Bhagat Singh & friends do nothing for countery?
2 Oct is a national holiday. why 23 March is not a national holiday ?( except Punjab, Punjab have state level holiday). I m not saying that its only Bhagat singh but give due respect to Netaji & others too. why we dont have national holyday on netaji's B'day? Why its only Gandhi - Gandhi everywhere.
few years back some members of Parliment ( they all were frm punjab ) struggled aby the issue that Bhagat Singh's photo should be hanged in parliment. after that I never heard that whether their demand approved or not. But I think its not.
so if politians cant hang Bhagat Singh's photo what kind of respect they will give to him. another thing what the photos of Indira Gandhi, Rajiv Gandhi are doing in the parliment. what they did for countery & its freedom?
Spot On!!! 👏
if peace dusnt work, then try other methods. and besides, Bhagat Singh and stuff never hurt anyone. except for killin the inspector cuz he was in charge of the Baagh Massacre...
other than that, wat violence did they indulge in? chuckin a smoke bomb in the middle of parliament so that no1 gets hurt...is that violence?
just like bhagat singh said You need a dhamaka to make the Deaf ppl of India listen
they went on the longest hunger strike etc etc. all of this was done to awaken the ppl of India, to get their courage up. morale needed a boost.
you always shud choose ur method on wat will work the best for that situation and that time
and anyways, it's always a combination of efforts. both ways show bravery.
and yeh, that is so true...why the hell was parliament so indecisive about hangin Bhagat Singh's photo?
and Indira Gandhi, pfft the lady who kills helpless citizens, gets her photo up there on the walls when others like Netaji and Bhagat Singh get shunned....
great