Hey guys,
A few hours back there was a topic called 'jassi the man' which mystica closed to prevent arguments, possibly. Thanks Mysti.
I agree that we shouldn't be making fun of people's looks and if anyone found any of my comments offensive I am extremely sorry and I apologise.
But I also have a few things to say. Throughout my time in IF I have seen lots of posts where characters have been given names which I really think did need some degree of attention when they were written.
According to Deli, by chance if Mona Singh came here, how would she feel..... Well, with all the 'Purab uncle' and 'grandad' names going around, if Samir Soni ever came to this site, what would he feel? And mind you these names have gone around far more than jassi's or armaan's.
Purab has been called 'uncle' and 'grandad' because of the fact that he looks old in the show and in reality 'is and looks' 36 years old. So his "gift from God" has been critisized. Why didn't any mod raise an eye-brow then? It was taken lightly or too unimportant to comment on perhaps, by both the mods and the purab supporters. (Thank God for that, or else there wud have been a big row over it)
When the topic 'jassi the man' was started, ppl were critisizing the way jessica looked. Okay, jessica is played by mona singh. But didn't a few ppl also say that jassi looked better with her hair tied and salwar kameez? So it wasn't like she was being butchered completely for her makeover.
Even Armaan was either praised or critisized for his looks, wasn't he? Although the better part of his controversy favored his looks.
I agree that an actor's looks are God's contribution to making that person. But just like not every actor fits a particular role, not every actor looks good in every shot of a show. I'm sure a lot of you will agree that every actor in JJKN didn't look good in all their parts.
Now a few people feel jessica doesn't look that good as jessica. That includes me too. If you can praise someone's sharp features and looks, which actually form a part, but never the whole of an actor, why can't you critisize someone's looks?? After all, praising and critisizing are all discussions, be it looks or acting ability.
Maybe that topic wasn't really an intelligent discussion. But in my opinion, an actor isn't just acting ability or looks and moves. S/he has to fit an entire package tailored to the requirement of the show. And it's not neccessary that the actor playing the role has completely fit that package.
I am not replying back to deli or anyone for any matter. I respect her comments. Nor am I trying get an argument started. I felt that this issue needed to be pointed out to everyone. And anyone who wishes to start a row over this, please don't do it here.
comment:
p_commentcount