||Episode Discussion thread: 19th-22nd Dec|| - Page 58

Posted: 12 years ago
Originally posted by Nandalala



@bold: I don't think her ma or baa would have encouraged her to stay in a marriage where she was emotionally abused by the family and with a husband who was not committed to her or in building a life together for them.  What was said yesterday was pure Kastur...her intentions were noble, but she never once put herself in Reena's place to truly understand the pain behind the facade of the marriage...instead, she approached it in a stereotypical, cliched, filmi way...& thats my problem with it...

Kastur's maa and baa didn't really said directly that no matter how bad the husband is, you should stay with him and all these stuffs...but they did teach Kastur that, for a wife, her husband is everything and in-laws are her family after marriage, didn't they? They gave her all the advices of being a good dharampatni...but yes, it's different that Kastur didn't understand that at some situations, even these advices and teachings of marriage doesn't work...and here comes her immaturity...she needs to understand some stuffs!
Posted: 12 years ago
Originally posted by likarsh


Thanks Bidzy, I appreciate the explanation.  🤗  And I got your PM. I'll read it soon. I just finished watching the episode, and I also can't let what I find bothersome about this episode go without putting it all down.  So I'll get to it, but it might take a bit of time.

Put it soon. Would like to know what you think.
Posted: 12 years ago
Rani, agreed about Saroj's not even registering that that's exactly what she's doing to Kastur.

And also about Baapji, after all his bad decisions he still tried to force a marriage on to Mohan (though in the end Mohan agreed).  
Posted: 12 years ago
Originally posted by likarsh


Rani, agreed about Saroj's not even registering that that's exactly what she's doing to Kastur.

And also about Baapji, after all his bad decisions he still tried to force a marriage on to Mohan (though in the end Mohan agreed).  

Saroj acts all nonsense when it comes to Kastur because her hate for Kastur is so blind that she doesn't know what she's doing...she needs to get a reality check!

About Baapji...no comments but on a funny note, would like to thank him for getting Mohan and Kastur married because they are magical together 😍 On a serious note, Baapji knew how sanskari Kastur is...there's a hell lot of difference between Kastur and Reena's husband!
Posted: 12 years ago
Originally posted by Bidz_cutegal



Kastur's maa and baa didn't really said directly that no matter how bad the husband is, you should stay with him and all these stuffs...but they did teach Kastur that, for a wife, her husband is everything and in-laws are her family after marriage, didn't they? They gave her all the advices of being a good dharampatni...but yes, it's different that Kastur didn't understand that at some situations, even these advices and teachings of marriage doesn't work...and here comes her immaturity...she needs to understand some stuffs!

@bold:   We see it as immaturity, but it seems to always work with Baapji...this is extremely concerning to me...🤢
Posted: 12 years ago
[QUOTE=likarsh]Anj, Shradha has given advice which had bothered me long back.  I'll try to find that post, but for me within where the episode stood--what was being told to Kastur was worrisome for me. And that's when I knew for sure that this show would bother me a LOT when it comes to the whole..."duty of a wife" issues.[/QUO

To be honest, I skipped thru most of her & Baa's sermons on marriage...🥱🥱...but I got the general gist of it...@bold: same pinch...I can't stand it...🤢😡
Posted: 12 years ago
Originally posted by Nandalala



Kastur's maa and baa didn't really said directly that no matter how bad the husband is, you should stay with him and all these stuffs...but they did teach Kastur that, for a wife, her husband is everything and in-laws are her family after marriage, didn't they? They gave her all the advices of being a good dharampatni...but yes, it's different that Kastur didn't understand that at some situations, even these advices and teachings of marriage doesn't work...and here comes her immaturity...she needs to understand some stuffs!

@bold:   We see it as immaturity, but it seems to always work with Baapji...this is extremely concerning to me...🤢
[/QUOTE]
I don't expect anything else from Baapji...woh toh hai hi 1947 se 🤢
Posted: 12 years ago
Originally posted by Nandalala



@bold: I don't think her ma or baa would have encouraged her to stay in a marriage where she was emotionally abused by the family and with a husband who was not committed to her or in building a life together for them.  What was said yesterday was pure Kastur...her intentions were noble, but she never once put herself in Reena's place to truly understand the pain behind the facade of the marriage...instead, she approached it in a stereotypical, cliched, filmi way, keeping Baapji in mind..& thats my problem with it...


Yeah but Reena didn't say her husband wasn't committed to her cause from her words they were happy but from what I gather he had no self esteem probably due to the fact his family didn't think he'll amount or want him to be anything in life. Why would Kastur put herself in Reena place when that isn't the case with her husband Mohan is nothing like Jatin. Reena has love marriage where as Kastur doesn't, Mohan like working and be something in life Jatin doesn't want to tried so in what place will Kastur put herself in Reena shoes?

The only thing those two have in common is the fact they have tyrant for MIL. I don't see why her answer cliched or however it you called it has to do with baapji 😕. Her replied had nothing to do with baapji but based on Reena own response of wanting to be with her husband and what her mother told her. This isn't Kastur first time saying this she even told Mohan her mother taught her house after marriage is her husband so where in that interpret back to baapji.

I also think some here have Saroj syndrome that due to her blind hate can't see anything beyond it and is the same thing people can't see beyond the blind hate for baapji so something that has nothing to do with him is not being shown as another alliance round.
Edited by pyar-ishk - 12 years ago
Posted: 12 years ago
Rani, it wasn't a love marriage.  Right? Today's episode clarified that.  Plus as Anj said, Baapji's allowing her back makes sense if you take in what she said Tuesday. That after Reena came back, they tried to take her back but the family refused.

I have issues with it.  But I'm too tired right now to write about it.

I just want to point out that while kastur was going on, the "mahan bhashan" bg was playing.  

Let me just end with in no way do I think divorce is a cake walk.  And that marriages shouldn't be given a chance.  But consistently there have been some bothersome things that i've had problems with.  Baa and Shradha's DP lessons. Shradha's tellign Kastur that she's a good wife for lying for her husband and keeping the problems to herself.  While the next episode fixed that situation with MohUr, on the face of it, what Shradha told Kastur was and is worrisome advice.  

And so many other instances I can't even remember anymore.  


Posted: 12 years ago
I'm going to sleep now.  It's been a tiring day.  I'll reply to whatever needs replying later. 😃

Related Topics

No Related topics found

Topic Info

25 Participants 809 Replies 28509Views

Topic started by KhatamKahani

Last replied by pyar-ishk

loader
loader
up-open TOP