Posted: 24 March 2006 at 12:20am | IP Logged
Originally posted by mohinis
Soul soap , I was talking to priya, see what appra
wrote, he say bakwas, nonsense and all these words, do u think he
should say these words?
Mohinis, I am having some trouble replying to ur pm, so will send it to u a lil later.
Meantime, let us not go around stirring trouble unnecessarily.
In the thread, there was a perfectly valid discussion going on.
AD made a comment, his opinion on HR, that they should learn something
from the Masters of the earlier years. "omeone please tell that
to HR, V-S and the other such dumbos " - except the casual use of
the expression dumbos, nothing wrong with the post.
You replied there, saying HR songs are raaga based. YOu
personally targetted members, stating that they have no knowledge of
Originally posted by MOHINIS
but the persons who have no degree, no experience in music and call
these composers dumbo , himself is dumbo. They have lot of knowledge in
music and many songs of theirs are on Ragga based eg All tere naam
songs were raga based, So if any body will call them dumbo, Iis my
opinion that he is a dumbo..
Beyond stating that, you had nothing to really state about
HR. Instead you just made a personal attack on someone for just
airing their views in a non controversial manner.
Someone asked you to state the raaga behind a particular song of
HR. In reply, you googled and posted an article about the Raaga
in HR's songs. No harm done. But when you question another
members degree and experience in music, you need to be a maestro
Repeatedly, apparao told you that if you name the raaga of the
song (which was the subject of discussion in that thread). You
chose to instead pick on adjectives (mild, compared to some others
which have been found on the forum) and not answer that one
point. If you had put down the name of the raaga, that would have
been the end of the story.
Your only answer to soulsoup is that HR himself said that his songs are raaga based.
Every composer is going to say that about his songs. In fact, in Indian music, every song is based on a raaga.
Did you know that even for donkeys braying, there is a raaga (ketalodi raagam)
(thats just a lil joke to reduce the seriousness of the post)
There is no doubt that HR composes tunes which are on the lips of many
a youth in this generation today. If someone does not like him,
does that mean anything? Mohinis, in a forum it is not
necessary that everyone likes those people who you like. It is
also not necessary that the ones you like are the best for the others
I have seen many posts where you have used names and adjectives for ID,
another music director of this age and others too.
Pot cant be calling the kettle black. Please look into your posts again and see if you are without any fault.
PS:- Everyone please now calm down. Let us not turn a
perfectly good post into another battle ground. Chill guys, its
friday afternoon. Thoda toh reham khaao....