Indian Idol 6

India-Forums

   
Indian Idol 6
Indian Idol 6

Gala Round Performances (Page 2)

Mishtimoni Groupbie
Mishtimoni
Mishtimoni

Joined: 09 January 2006
Posts: 185

Posted: 13 March 2006 at 5:44pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by sonyaee

I think Karyuna picked the right song. At this point in the competition, it might have been risky for him to pick a romantic song like Saathiya. Ramta Jogi is a more difficult song but Saathiya would require more feel and emotion. Didn't Amit Sana sing it in II1 last year or was it Abhijeet?

Yes, connecting w/the audience is important. I think that's why Meenal didn't receive enough votes despite being a good singer.


I agree about Meenal..

I don't rememeber Amit or Abhi singing Saathiya.. but I remember Abhi made an extremely smart choice in the Dosti round by choosing Dil Chahta Hai.. it was a difficult song, popular song and it played to his strength..FEEL and EXPRESSION.. he always says this and I too firmly believe that one of the major  reasons he won was his song choices.. he always played to his strengths, but also kept enough variety..

abhi_fan Senior Member
abhi_fan
abhi_fan

Joined: 26 July 2005
Posts: 391

Posted: 13 March 2006 at 10:58pm | IP Logged
choosing the right songs is very important...especially in the gala round where the competition is so tough. I think the choice of songs in II1 gala was much better than that in II2. Amit, Rahul and Abhijeet always chose songs that are popular and melodious and at the same type suit their individual styles. This was missing in II2.
suneal Groupbie
suneal
suneal

Joined: 05 December 2005
Posts: 118

Posted: 13 March 2006 at 11:42pm | IP Logged
Agreed very well said very good Clap
ajanta Groupbie
ajanta
ajanta

Joined: 18 November 2005
Posts: 127

Posted: 14 March 2006 at 12:35am | IP Logged
I think Karu is par excellent in both songs..next comes Amey and then sandeep ,Anuj...No need to compare SRGMP artists performance with II2 songs.....there is no point in this kind of comparisions...why dont u compare FG songs also??
syrene Goldie
syrene
syrene

Joined: 08 October 2005
Posts: 1648

Posted: 14 March 2006 at 12:39am | IP Logged
Originally posted by Mishtimoni

Let me first say that my analysis is based on watching the videos posted by Nomi, where Karu's holi song was missing. Here is what I thought...

Amey.. He impressed me the most. I think his holy song choice was superb in terms of entertainment value, and he connected to the camera/audience really well..singing wise too he was flawless as usual.

Amey's Satrangi Re was very good, though at some points he sounded a bit strained.. but still very good.

Sandeep.. I am amazed! His Holi Khele was a brave attempt..but I really liked his Ruth Aa Gayi Re.. I could never imagine him singing a Sukhwinder song, but he just bowled me over! He sang in perfect sur and also with a lot of feeling!!Kudos! But on the other hand, if his fan base expect him to sing like Udit, and they are disappointed, then he might be in trouble!! I think the main reason Panna got out was that his core fan base probably didn't like his 'lack of performance'.Wink

Anuj.. He wasn't really upto the mark in my opinion.. his Rang Barse was a very risky choice, because of the iconic status of the song, and I don't think he pulled it off that well! With these songs, there is a catch, if you can pull it off, even decently, you are through, but if you are even slightly disappointing, then it may be catastrophic..

His Chaiya Chaiya I didn't like at all.. sorry I disagree completely with the judges..he wasn't besura or anything, but he completelely lacked the 'junoon'..one other thing I have noticed with this song is that it doesn't sound nice if you lower the scale..  Anuj's natural scale is lower than Sukhwinder's (who is comfortable in D/D sharp), that's why I think he shouldn't have chosen this song.

Now to my favourite Karunya.. this is difficult for me to say, but I am not very sure how the audience is going to react to his Ramta Jogi.. it is a difficult song, yes, but it is not really as popular a song as Satrangi Re or many other ARR songs.. Karu is in danger of being typecast as a qwaali/light classical singer.. my personal opinion would be that he should have chosen a romantic song which is also demanding (eg. Saathiya), which, while showing his prowess, could also eliminate the blame that he cannot pull of mainstream romantic songs very well..moreover, Ramta Jogi was sung brilliantly by Hemachandra in SRGMP very recently, and many people would compare the two (and to be honest I personally would rate Hema's version higher)..and finally, I felt something while listening to him, the same thing that I felt while listening to Lagaan Lagi, and that is, while he sang both with amazing technical virtuosity,he sang both these songs with a very mellow style of voice throw and expression,
 whereas both required a lot more passion.. remember connecting to the audience is very important here ..

Sorry for boring you with a long post.. I would love to hear your comments!!!

I am waiting to see Karu's holi song, (someone please post it), but again that is a classical based song, I am sure he must have done well.

PS: Just watched Karu's holi song!!! WOW!! PERFECT!! I LOVE IT!!!




honest, unbiased analysisThumbs Up
anonmember IF-Sizzlerz
anonmember
anonmember

Joined: 13 December 2004
Posts: 15143

Posted: 14 March 2006 at 12:43am | IP Logged
Mishti, I liked your point on Anuj singing Chaiyya Chaiyya at a lower scale. I think that could be one of the reasons his performance paled in comparison to the others. Another would be he lacked the right enegry level needed for that song (same for Rang Barse). I wonder how Amey's RDB would have sounded had it lowered the scale, like Anu and Sonu suggested in the results episode. If Anuj's chaiyya chaiyya is anything to go by, maybe Amey was right in his decision to sing the song at the original scale.

Edited by sonyaee - 14 March 2006 at 12:45am
datspreets Goldie
datspreets
datspreets

I-F Crazy Creatives
Joined: 10 April 2005
Posts: 1741

Posted: 14 March 2006 at 12:48am | IP Logged
Very well analysed !

Totally unbiased and ypou are right with whatever you said !

datspreets Goldie
datspreets
datspreets

I-F Crazy Creatives
Joined: 10 April 2005
Posts: 1741

Posted: 14 March 2006 at 12:50am | IP Logged

Originally posted by sonyaee

Mishti, I liked your point on Anuj singing Chaiyya Chaiyya at a lower scale. I think that could be one of the reasons his performance paled in comparison to the others. Another would be he lacked the right enegry level needed for that song (same for Rang Barse). I wonder how Amey's RDB would have sounded had it lowered the scale, like Anu and Sonu suggested in the results episode. If Anuj's chaiyya chaiyya is anything to go by, maybe Amey was right in his decision to sing the song at the original scale.

 

I think, lower scale never pale your performance, infact you shoudl always ing in the pitch that you are comfortable with!

I think teh whoel masti was missing from his rang barse..and the whole spirit of chaiya chaiya was no wher to see!

Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Author Replies Views Last Post
Rank top4 Performances .... 13 Feb 2009

2 3

Author: risingsun   Replies: 16   Views: 2013

risingsun 16 2013 14 February 2009 at 8:48am by -Ashoo-
**GALA 10 is last GALA for PRASHANTH...**

2

Author: fun4india   Replies: 13   Views: 2378

fun4india 13 2378 30 August 2007 at 11:21am by buttercup
**GALA 10 >>Last GALA for PRASHANTH.!?**

2 3 4 5

Author: fun4india   Replies: 34   Views: 4478

fun4india 34 4478 28 August 2007 at 8:13am by seiza
Judges Vs Judges - Round 7 (Final Round)

2 3 4 5 6

Author: mango-frost   Replies: 41   Views: 5142

mango-frost 41 5142 29 June 2007 at 12:46am by mango-frost
Compare GALA 1 & GALA 2 & rate GALA 2

2

Author: sumesh   Replies: 11   Views: 1544

sumesh 11 1544 24 January 2006 at 7:37am by lashy

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Indian Idol 6 Topic Index

  • Please login to check your Last 10 Topics posted

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index