Originally posted by: melody1570
I think it was Adhesh for Himani
I wouldn't say Himesh was good for Vinit. He did more of a damage to
him, he ruined all his chances.
Agree to some extent. HR did a good job as a promotor but as a musical
guru, I don't think he did a good job. Unlike everyone else, Vinit did NOT
improve as a singer. His voice matured as a function of time but his
technical skills if anything went down. I feel like HR himself is not a
trained singer and thus could not properly guide Vinit. Now while ID is
clearly not a singer, he has such a good classical foundation that all of his
singers improved greatly even Nihira who was already good. JL did an
incredible job too with Sanchali, Swananda, Manjeera, Sharib, and Ujjaini.
Saptak was the victim of bad song choice and judge's taste on the
selection. I am shocked that the survey does not really acknowledge JL's
excellent training skills bad luck notwithstanding.
comment:
p_commentcount