Indira more than just "Hitler" (Page 4)

.SilentPrincess

IF-Rockerz

BollyCurry Buzzer

Joined: 31 March 2009

Posts: 7350

Posted: 08 November 2011 at 4:06am | IP Logged

Originally posted by Princess_Khushi

Loeved reading it. From now on, try to post such things in weekly discussions thread. thank you! It will help this forum stay clean until we get a Mod. :)

Thank you. :)
Thats for reviews? I get it that you shouldn't post such things before updaters do.. But I really don't think you can post "reviews" there. Its good for discussions etc.. reviews will only be ignored. (my thought) And I myself wouldn't got in that thread to read reviews for one incident or oen special episode.. Yes for the over all serial yes, but not one single episode...
And the forum won't get messy with reviews... a bit more active yes. Yes repeated topics etc... are annoying.. But a completly different post/review should be allowed. I'm sorry if I'm rude... I just don't see any sense in it. Sorry.
Anyways... i won't be writing another one... this was just an one time thing.. And I haven't seen anyone else post anything regarding this so I posted it. Unless some interesting observation comes up, I won't be posting more. :)

Shilpa.Agarwal

IF-Dazzler

Joined: 27 April 2008

Posts: 4995

Posted: 08 November 2011 at 5:58am | IP Logged

thank god they didn't overdo the hitlergiri...a gal is a gal at d end of the day...n i thot it was a beautiful start to the charecter...poor girl does not enjoy this at all but she has no choice...n d hitler thing doesn't mean she is insensitive no way! its jus dat being d caretaker of d house she demands respect...her dad leavin was such a shock to her that she thought dat her life has changed...she thought she must take on responsibilities...though i m frm a well-to-do family i can really relate to indira...i've seen a lotta ppl, actually most lower middle class ppl r like dat...many of dem r really struggling but still everyone has to live life so they try to be happy also...but d thing with indira i think is she cant pretend...that's d biggest thing...she'll be happy only when she's really happy...not dat there r sooo many problems but still adjusting n trying to laugh n be happy wid wtvr u have...n as for d title, dat to me is more ov a comment on d society and the family than indira. it's d way ppl percieve a blunt woman, working in a decent job, running a family and giving them a decent lifestyle all by herself...not blushing, n smiling n being dolled up...instead taking no crap

Edited by Shilpa.Agarwal - 08 November 2011 at 6:21am

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

.SilentPrincess,

9staroneserials

IF-Dazzler

Joined: 15 October 2010

Posts: 3340

Posted: 08 November 2011 at 7:21am | IP Logged

I just lovd ur analysis man Hug

...though i hav 2 still catch the episode hav not seen it yet... Ouch

due to sum exam stress & personal probs too...thanks...for ur post...i hope i get time 2 watch the episode instead of reading it Ouch

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

.SilentPrincess,

Roopal_TiaRa

IF-Sizzlerz

Joined: 08 January 2011

Posts: 22429

Posted: 08 November 2011 at 9:42am | IP Logged

great post
full on agree with u
she is not just a hitler but an idol too
love her

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

.SilentPrincess,

*Khushii*

Cool Viewbie

IF Crazy Baby, BollyCurry Buzzer

Joined: 15 December 2010

Posts: 31941

Posted: 08 November 2011 at 12:13pm | IP Logged

Originally posted by .SilentPrincess

Originally posted by Princess_Khushi

Loeved reading it. From now on, try to post such things in weekly discussions thread. thank you! It will help this forum stay clean until we get a Mod. :)

Thank you. :)
Thats for reviews? I get it that you shouldn't post such things before updaters do.. But I really don't think you can post "reviews" there. Its good for discussions etc.. reviews will only be ignored. (my thought) And I myself wouldn't got in that thread to read reviews for one incident or oen special episode.. Yes for the over all serial yes, but not one single episode...
And the forum won't get messy with reviews... a bit more active yes. Yes repeated topics etc... are annoying.. But a completly different post/review should be allowed. I'm sorry if I'm rude... I just don't see any sense in it. Sorry.
Anyways... i won't be writing another one... this was just an one time thing.. And I haven't seen anyone else post anything regarding this so I posted it. Unless some interesting observation comes up, I won't be posting more. :)

Yes. You can discuss and do review of episodes there. No. Updaters do the official update for the day. But Live updates are while the show is going on and people put there. Because obviously the assigned Updater won't be posting it as soon as the show is aired. It helps others.

No. You are not rude. I do get what you are saying but I found it more logical to be posted there. There are people who check that thread regularly. And posting there does make the rank go up most of the times.

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

.SilentPrincess,

supercool3

Viewbie

IF Crazy Baby

Joined: 17 February 2010

Posts: 9769

Posted: 08 November 2011 at 12:21pm | IP Logged

Beautiful post :)

Now that I think about it, the promos were quite misleading too regarding the character of our beloved Hitler Didi

I mean when I first saw them, I was like WHOA, she's tough, strict, and all and it immediately reminded me of a family member ... who at the age of Ishaan, I also viewed as a Hitler but then again, thought I may as well watch the show for Rati

but after seeing the first two episodes now, Indira Sharma is rubbing onto me ... Like you said, she had a very realistic approach towards life ... and it's not like she's purposely doing what she does, but she doesn't have another option ...

And I think there are a lot of people, especially girls, like that in reality, who are forced to change their ways once all the responsibilities fall on them ..

Indira's such a complex character, and now I'm really interested to see how Rati's going to portray the character throughout the show no doubt, she'll do a fabulous job

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

.SilentPrincess, MyInspirationz,

MyInspirationz

IF-Sizzlerz

Joined: 30 October 2009

Posts: 14899

Posted: 08 November 2011 at 2:16pm | IP Logged

Originally posted by .SilentPrincess

Okay so after watching the first episode... I had to make this post. My view on Hitler Didi.

Indira Sharma... From the promos that have been aired till now. We got the image of a very strict and reserved and no-nonsense type of girl. And we or I at least expected her too be very bossy, and strict 24/7. A real "Hitler".

But what I've just saw just shook that image. She's just can't be labeled "Hitler". Yes she is strict, a bit bossy, and she's very sensible... overall a "Hitler". But she's just so much more than that, even in the first episode itself we got to know this whole new side of her. I expected it to happen but so soon. But I'm happy they showed it early, so we don't get a nnegative vibe of her, what she does and why she does it. It all explained, her behaviour towards her family, life or anything else for that matter.
And I loved her character.. truly. Looking aside the "hitler giri" part. She was sweetheart. Embarrassed

Beggining with the first scene...

The way she behaved with Ishaan, taking care of everything. I was so shocked that this girl is called Hitler. She was so sweet to him. With butter and milk and checking his homework... everything associated with him. I would say its wouldn't be wrong of me to say that she's Ishaan's 2nd mother & father. :) They showed that bond so beautifully, but also taking care of the fact that Ishaan's real parents don't get sidelined.. they showed loving and caring parents along with Indira. Smile

Then came the duty as a daughter... She has a realistic approach towards life, that something very sensible about her. She doesn't drown in memories or sit and cry for what they got and what not. What happened it happened. Time to move forward. And she at least tries to make her familiy understand that. (I did feel a little odd about indira's mother, praying for her husband... Confused

)

Anf then her relation as a sister. Her behaviour with her sister was reasonable... Trying to show her the right way, and trying to protect her from going to the wrong one.
And then her elder brother... That was needed. He is a father and husband and the house only son. He should at least take care of somethign in the house. If not the economy then he can at least be there for his son. And Indira giving him that lesson was exactly what he needed. I think the only reason she did so was to stop him from following their fathers steps.

And the father-son scene proved she did right. Smile

Then I think come one of the best parts of the whole episode... They showed Indira through Ishaan's eyes. He is innocent, and he has an honest view on his bua. And then Indira herself answered some of his questions silently. Beautifully potrayed. In simple words she didn't become "Hitler Didi" by choice, but it was forcefully given to her. And she had no other option but take it. But still that little innocent girl we saw for few seconds live inside her. But that little girl is so deeply buried inside "Hitler Didi" that anyone around her or Indira herself doesn't know she exists.

All in all I would sat HD could not have gotten any better start than this. Mindblowing. Clap

And not just HD but every character in it. :)

Coming to Indira aka Rati... The main reason for this post.
After playing the role of "Nupur" I really thought there was no way Rati could over do that role. Because she proved herself as an actor throug that character. And after viewing the promos, I wasn't very very impressed. But after watchign the first episode. I'm just speechless. The role of Indira has so much depth in it... It definetly stands on the same level as Nupur... Rati has surely choosen the "right" role. And her acting just leaves you speechless... Embarrassed

Hitler Didi... Its definitely something. And I'm hooked up after watching the first episode. I can't wait too see Indira, and how her characters unfold as the story progresses. I was going to watch it for Rati. But now I only watch it for "Indira". Smile

Okay... So this is just my review of Indira in the first episode... Indira is just so much more than just "Hitler Didi" And thats one of the reason HD attracts you. Even though her character isn't really all about "Hitler" but still the charcater of Indira keeps you hooked to the serial. Its supposed to be a very common role, and you do associate with her. But she's much much more unique than just that girl who bosses around and goes around with the burden of the house. Indira is a really unique character. Smile

Do feel free to comment/critizie or reply back or even disagree...This was just my view on the characater of HD. :)

-SilentPrincess-

Laiba, BANG ON!!! My exact views... I am seeing HD only for Rati.. shez an AMAZING Powerhouse of Talent!!!

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

.SilentPrincess,

.SilentPrincess

IF-Rockerz

BollyCurry Buzzer

Joined: 31 March 2009

Posts: 7350

Posted: 08 November 2011 at 4:03pm | IP Logged

Originally posted by Shilpa.Agarwal

thank god they didn't overdo the hitlergiri...a gal is a gal at d end of the day...n i thot it was a beautiful start to the charecter...poor girl does not enjoy this at all but she has no choice...n d hitler thing doesn't mean she is insensitive no way! its jus dat being d caretaker of d house she demands respect...her dad leavin was such a shock to her that she thought dat her life has changed...she thought she must take on responsibilities...though i m frm a well-to-do family i can really relate to indira...i've seen a lotta ppl, actually most lower middle class ppl r like dat...many of dem r really struggling but still everyone has to live life so they try to be happy also...but d thing with indira i think is she cant pretend...that's d biggest thing...she'll be happy only when she's really happy...not dat there r sooo many problems but still adjusting n trying to laugh n be happy wid wtvr u have...n as for d title, dat to me is more ov a comment on d society and the family than indira. it's d way ppl percieve a blunt woman, working in a decent job, running a family and giving them a decent lifestyle all by herself...not blushing, n smiling n being dolled up...instead taking no crap

Completly agree.. From the promos it looked like there would be alot of "hitler giri" thank god it wasn't. They balanced everything well. I agree she's vey strong. Taking care of her family and then dealing with crap on the streets its demands alot psysically toughness. & In the end of the day if she given a little respect from her family.. is she demanding too much?
I felt really bad after watching todays episode...in the end. She comes home tired and no one bothers to open thee door. The mother I got but her siblings.. its shameful... And in such incidents she needs to be "Hitler". Looking forwards to tomorrow's episode and how she handels this.

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

Shilpa.Agarwal,

Page 4 of 6

Posted: 08 November 2011 at 4:06am | IP Logged

Posted: 08 November 2011 at 5:58am | IP Logged

Posted: 08 November 2011 at 7:21am | IP Logged

Posted: 08 November 2011 at 9:42am | IP Logged

Posted: 08 November 2011 at 12:13pm | IP Logged

Posted: 08 November 2011 at 12:21pm | IP Logged

Posted: 08 November 2011 at 2:16pm | IP Logged

Posted: 08 November 2011 at 4:03pm | IP Logged

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Search

Check these Celebrity also

Join India-forums Today!

Here's why members would love to be a part of India-Forums.com:

Join Us Close