Pyaar Kii Ye Ek Kahaani

India-Forums

   
Pyaar Kii Ye Ek Kahaani
Pyaar Kii Ye Ek Kahaani

Is it really fair to Jeh! (Page 3)

carisma2 IF-Stunnerz
carisma2
carisma2

Joined: 25 January 2007
Posts: 29741

Posted: 20 September 2011 at 12:26pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by syria2014

Originally posted by carisma2

Syria.

Jeh himself has compelled Abhiya to keep themselves a secret from Jeh. Is it Abhiya's fault - that they cannot steal two moments away from everyone and be together?
 
Jeh - you say loves Pia.. is actually trying to keep her away from her soulmate - is that fair.
 
Jeh tries to insult Abhay infront of Pia - and Abhay keeps quiet - is that Abhay's fault.
 
My dear.. His life has been ruined due to his family's doing - which is unfortunate. BUT if he is living in a fools paradise thinking that Pia will be his then that is his own fault.
 
Even at the dance he was more focused on making Abhay jelous rather than sharing any eye contact with Pia the girl he claims to love.
 
But I love your sentiments and genuineness and guts for this post.
 
Agree that, Jai has compelled for Abhiya to do that, I do not themf or that. I do want him to understand that karisma that it's better to have Pia in his life in some kind of form rather not having at her at all. At the same time,. it's not fair for a girl to be in relationship she is unhappy , and where she is lying behind his back. I mean sorry to say, Pia agree to be his g.f. , and this is a choice she made. She has to decide what she wants. I think it will be harder more for Jai that the girl he loved sneaked around his back rather than being upfront about it.!Ouch. baby, I do not care what people think of this forum anymore. People have called me double faced, and a bitch . I have tolerated all kind level of bashing against me, and backstabbing . but , still I held my head up high u know why, I am not afraid to be honest how I feel and to stand up for myself.!Approve
How did they even become a couple? The last of it was that she told him in the jungle she still has feelings for Abhay.. then all of a sudden after the reunion he comes to pick her up for college and starts kissing her hand.
Pia is not breaking his heart bec she kind of feels sorry for him - bec of his family situation.
 
But yes she should end it - and she will and thats when Ajeh will fight. So wait for it it will happen - it;s just poor creativity from the creatives side for not executing this well.

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

.Reshama.

chinniga Groupbie
chinniga
chinniga

Joined: 12 November 2009
Posts: 196

Posted: 20 September 2011 at 12:27pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by Puja_Nava

[

I completely understand you syria...it is just that the way werewolves are..u know they are such aggressive creature who cannot control their anger...I am just scared that jeh may not be able to control his anger and do something bad...of course piya's good nature can enlighten him as well...but here we are taking a risk and I do not think that abhay will ever risk piya's life...here the main person to judge would be abhay...he is the one who told piya to hide their relationship...and piya will never break her promise to abhay, so abhay is the one who needs to come up with idea to reveal their relationship to jehEmbarrassed

 
I dont expect abhay to set a plan so that jay know that abhiya are together because in abhay's pov jay warned him if thir will be slightest change in pia for jay she will have to loose her life.  at this point no lover will risk his love because one wrong step and u will loose her in big times. in fact abhay will think to rap the things up by finishing jay then only pia will be safe..

Mrs.Peanuts IF-Stunnerz
Mrs.Peanuts
Mrs.Peanuts

Joined: 02 November 2008
Posts: 35727

Posted: 20 September 2011 at 12:28pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by I-love-Roses

I do admit that keeping Jeh in dark is sort of a betrayal but don't you think Jeh is too violent to accept what's true? He's declared that he can kill pia if abhiya come together. So in this case, it's ok if pia's hiding the truth from him. He is not a guy who accepts a truth unagreeable to him.
 
 
I do agree Jai is too violent to accept it. Pia will reject. Fine, he will display his anger. But isn't worth finding out right now than later when his hopes bar have been raised up so high by Pia. Pia has to choose now what she wants.!Embarrassed
Mrs.Peanuts IF-Stunnerz
Mrs.Peanuts
Mrs.Peanuts

Joined: 02 November 2008
Posts: 35727

Posted: 20 September 2011 at 12:31pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by chinniga

Sorry but what i feel is its not unfair to jay because he is unfair to abhay and pia. he very well know the face that pia's heart beat for abhay even now. she openly said it to him in forest and she also said that it was nice to have him in her life as a friend. he knows it very well that when pia gets her memory back she will not be with him as the love of her life is abhay. jay just want to keep her in illusion. but my point is how long he can keep her in that state. if the illusion breaks he will kill her. for me jay is unfair to pia and to himself for an extent as he knows its typical one sided love. he is just pushing the limits as much as he can. okey lets take this way if he knows that abhay returned pia her memories back then what his next immediate step?? plain and simple kill her.

now jay started behaving like if she cant be love of my life. she doesn,t deserve to be love of someones life. the decision of his life is in his hands but he cant decide some others life and jay is now want to decide pia's life and main problem in his plans is abhay and he knows he cant beat abhay directly as he tried it already and he knows the result of it. the only way he can control him is pia.
 
 
I do agree that Jai is trying to desperatly hold on to something that he can never be his. Agree with that. Agree, he knows he can control Pia through Abhay, but look at it other way. trust me, i know what he is doing is not right. I agree with that, and i do not agree with some his actions there, but that does not mean u keeps his hopes high. Betrayal is stronger than rejection!Big smile
quarkinsen Senior Member
quarkinsen
quarkinsen

Joined: 19 January 2011
Posts: 645

Posted: 20 September 2011 at 12:35pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by carisma2

Syria.

Jeh himself has compelled Abhiya to keep themselves a secret from Jeh. Is it Abhiya's fault - that they cannot steal two moments away from everyone and be together?
 
Jeh - you say loves Pia.. is actually trying to keep her away from her soulmate - is that fair.
 
Jeh tries to insult Abhay infront of Pia - and Abhay keeps quiet - is that Abhay's fault.
 
My dear.. His life has been ruined due to his family's doing - which is unfortunate. BUT if he is living in a fools paradise thinking that Pia will be his then that is his own fault.
 
Even at the dance he was more focused on making Abhay jelous rather than sharing any eye contact with Pia the girl he claims to love.
 
But I love your sentiments and genuineness and guts for this post.
BINGO i ahve the same thought dear
if he was like the real jeh and not include piya inbetween him and abhay and also tht threat piya would have told him everything ... but he is plying dirty games in name of love so he deserve it

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

carisma2

Mrs.Peanuts IF-Stunnerz
Mrs.Peanuts
Mrs.Peanuts

Joined: 02 November 2008
Posts: 35727

Posted: 20 September 2011 at 12:35pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by @[email protected]@

Originally posted by syria2014

I know the entire forum is pissed at Jeh. Trust me , I am some level too, but it has melted away b/c my love for him is greater than my anger. Mine too but then I do understand his situation. True, I might have brust sometimes like a flame , and been harsh towards him? Who does not? I have done to the same to Damon, Abhay or any character I like. I have criticized them, but in the end I have calm down my temper, and still love them.  You know my feelings about Jeh. I am angry at him, yes but then I can never blame him. I dont know in how many posts have I mentioned it and here I go again -- He has just lost so much that he is just lost his rationality and sanity over it.

Ok enough of that
The real point is here? At first, I was pissed the way Jeh interrupted Abhiya moment, but later when my tempered faded way. Is it really his fault the way he comes charging tomorrow towards Abhiya? Is it really fair to him the girl he loves is sneaking around, and lying to him? Is it fair that he think they still have a shot? Is it fair that Abhiya keeping him in the dark? I know Jai's love has become obession, but is it really fair what Abhiya are doing? Not telling him their relationship. Pia can still break Jai's heart without knowing that they are together. IS it fair to him she is leading him on? Is it fair for him not to think he still thinks he does not have a chance? I do not think any guy would want to see his ex, and his gf romancing. I think any guy would interrupt. Is it fair really! nah! on this basis! 
 

Its not his fault at all here. I mean if I see my boyfriend with someone who he is still in love with -- that too in arms -- I would go raging in too. Pia is sneaking around with Abhay and still keeping her relationship with Jeh -- and knowing the extent that Jeh loves her -- she is plain wrong here. And I dont blame Abhay here also and that is because Abhay said that they need to hide their relationship from everyone -- he dint say to do that stay with Jeh and continue giving him false hopes. Pia should understand it herself and in a way try to make Jeh understand that she is still not over Abhay and she may need some time. But no -- she is giving him hopes which is very wrong!

As for Abhay he should have let Pia on on Jeh when they came together. This is where he is wrong. He could specifically asked Pia to remain friends with Jeh leading him onto believing Pia doesnt have anything to do with Abhay -- but this "hiding things from Pia" is lame in my opinion.


Agree Jai should not treat Alina so harshly
Agree Jai's some actions are wrong

But this I do not agree.! No matter what, Pia just giving him more hopes up. I do not think that fair?


p.s. all are welcome to comment!


 
Nupu, i know he is being rational and implusive.Nupu, Betrayal is stronger than rejection. Pia made the choice to date him, and I think she should face the consequences. Fine she wanted to move on when Abhay was treating her badly. But, she should have first thought is that what she wanted really? She should have listened to her heart.I think Abhay should have asked Pia, and Abhay to remain frens. Abhay should have been clear to Pia who Jai was, and I think he should. I think it's high time Piya knows the truth.it's a lame excuse to hide things from Pia, I am angry on that part with Abhay. It's time to face the music not listen to Jai's threat. I know he does not wanna drag Pia in to this, but dragging Pia is the only it looks will solve this feud!Ouch

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

--Anna--

Mrs.Peanuts IF-Stunnerz
Mrs.Peanuts
Mrs.Peanuts

Joined: 02 November 2008
Posts: 35727

Posted: 20 September 2011 at 12:38pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by PurpleFairy

Originally posted by syria2014

First, I think Pia should find out Jai's reality than clear her feelings for him. Neetz the more she leads him , the worse. True , he will come out charging at  any moment to kill Abhiya, but instead of Abhay taking this threat. I think it's time Abhiya fight !Big smile

Well, you have your views Syria, I have mine. I never said what Pia is doing is right. I just said that I don't feel it's unfair on Jeh because he knows how much Pia loves Abhay and that's the whole reason why he could use her against him. Plus, if he can be unfair on Abhay saying his love cannot match up to his and blah blah blah then he shouldn't expect fairness from life either. As far as the not taking the threat and fighting is concerned, if only the CVs thought on those lines, I wouldn't have been this bitter towards them (:
 
Well , i think neetz cvs needs to understand that.  I do agree it can be unfair to Abhay saying his love does not match blah blah. i wish he would not do that, u know bring Pia in every convo.! i hope we are good neetz!Embarrassed
Mrs.Peanuts IF-Stunnerz
Mrs.Peanuts
Mrs.Peanuts

Joined: 02 November 2008
Posts: 35727

Posted: 20 September 2011 at 12:40pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by Eowyn

Thinking from Piya's prospective she is wrong in leading Jeh on knowing that he loves her...
She should honestly tell him that everything between them is over
But then doing that will be going against Abhay right when he has specifically asked her to keep their relation secretConfused
Then again there is the matter of friendship between JiYa, as a friend Jeh deserves the truth from Piya
Jeh was not at fault for barging in because he was behaving like any normal lover, he still thinks Piya loves him...

 
Nidhi, yaay! was looking forward to hear from u!hugs! Exactly , she should tell him the truth even though he will not take it well. I know that, but don't u agree rejection is better than betryal? Maybe, it will give him time for his heart to heal. I think being honest is better than keeping him in the dark.!Embarrassed

Go to top

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Pyaar Kii Ye Ek Kahaani Topic Index

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index