Sasural Genda Phool

India-Forums

   
Sasural Genda Phool
Sasural Genda Phool

Is it ALL her fault?Regarding the recent portrayal (Page 5)

mjtruelegend IF-Rockerz
mjtruelegend
mjtruelegend

Joined: 24 January 2009
Posts: 8921

Posted: 16 September 2011 at 2:16pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by madhu_d

Sheemu...I feel that there is no fault of her..its the fault of director and script writer..
An actor will perform according to the choice of director and the story line..and the dialogues given to her/him...

when performing in the team there is nothing to show more of her as its not focus on the individual..so taking that a base and feeling that she is unable to deliver is a wrong notion according to me..When the performance is with the team look at the whole team not an Individual..

C.V's are involving suhana even though she is not needed...Ex: there was no need of convo between BM-Suhana when there are so many elders in the house..it would have been apt if they show BM-Rajni scene instead of  suhana..Like-wise many or there..when there is no room for her making her to involve with unnecessary dialogues is effecting personality of ragini..

 EVen after BM fisco..i found very odd that they dint show any mature convo between Sushaan..if would have given both of them a chance to perform and be in limelight at the same time giving importance to other characters..

So its upto to the C.v's how to utilize N exploit the talent of the actors..as everyone are truly dedicated professionals




Absolutely Madhu, I agree totally. You see they know what kind of artists they have, so they should plan scenes accordingly, of course keeping in mind "the authenticity of the character" and the situation. Everyone responds differently but at times they give such random dialogues to them that it's insulting to one's intelligence to be watching it! Anyways, it's been better recently so I am just staying positive, not expecting anything in particular.

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

jshree_ram

infinity00 IF-Rockerz
infinity00
infinity00

Joined: 24 April 2010
Posts: 7695

Posted: 16 September 2011 at 4:24pm | IP Logged
I agree with all of you, as all your points makes sense, except I find it difficult to agree that Suhana could have been played better by someone else as Disha,s replacement is doing a better job, I dont agree as the old Disha did not portrayed the actual character of Disha which was naturally sweet and understanding , she had her flaws too but her sweetness were natural, and that natural sweetness was big time missing in old Disha as it looked forced in some places, she was not all bad but yes the beauty of Disha,s character was not seen then . Now come to Ragini being replaced IF, then I don't think that who ever will take it would be able to portray the spontaneity of Suhana, Ragini looked natural in that , who ever will take over might not be able to convincingly portray that, Suhana is pure at heart, as Ragini brought that purity through her eyes, especially when they get wet and sparkle, it might be glycerine but the expression with that sparkle are hard to beat, the voice modulation is hard to beat. I agree with Tejesh that sometime when working in a team you need to forget who you are and should be part of that team , this is the only area where Ragini needs to learn just like Supriya jee, Suraj , Sudhir Panaday jee, Sadia , they are experienced , they know when to do what and how much, Ragini will InshaAllah learn that in good time as she is fairly new in the field and acting is always about learning and maturing, she is on the right path , with right attitude and with great actors around her, I am sure she will learn it . after being part of 400 plus episode day in and day out is difficult  and one should be allowed to go off colour, bigger actors then Ragini rust a bit after doing so much work constantly, the senior actors of SGP are use to of it. I dont think there is a need to panic , she just gave few episode below her own standard we should give her benefit of doubt.
If you know where you are going wrong then its easier to rectify your mistakes so I hope Ragini reads all our honest comments which are made only to help her to achieve the best.

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

mjtruelegend111192_Procrastinator

mjtruelegend IF-Rockerz
mjtruelegend
mjtruelegend

Joined: 24 January 2009
Posts: 8921

Posted: 17 September 2011 at 6:04am | IP Logged
Originally posted by MadameX

To those saying that Ragini is the only who can portray Suhana really well...I don't think it's fair to make a statement like that when no one has ever before played Suhana's role (not talking about Lolita). If someone else were to come in the place of Ragini and did an even better job as in Disha's case, then what? It's just we're so used to seeing Ragini as Suhana that it feels only she can portray the character well.


We're merely expressing our opinions as many of us have seen her acting for a good few years now. I've seen Ragini in 4 very different roles and I have watched many others in lead/side roles and I confidently say that I believe that no one would be able to play Suhana the way Ragini does. Yes they may do well too, but not like Ragini.

Usually, female leads are always doing something mahaan and is seen sacrificing and in return they are hated by in-laws/families, etc. They are  very conventional roles, like an "adarsh" bahu/beti. It's much easier to play roles that are "traditionally" accepted withing the parameters of what's considered as a "good role model" who very rarely make mistakes and are almost always right.

Suhana is a complex character with many facets. She's has many shades and can be very enigmatic. Someone like her could have easily been turned into a less likable character if it hadn't been for the nuances that Ragini's added. Ritabhari was wonderful as Lolita but she too wouldn't be able to essay Suhana. Lolita was lovable but she didn't have the charm or that X factor that Suhana has.  Suhana is based on Lolita, but she is stronger and has a far more striking personality. Many duplicated scenes of OBS were more enjoyable in SGP due to Ragini's portrayal.

Again I mean no offense as this is my personal view based on what I have seen on television and movies (bollywood&hollywood)throughout my life so far.

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

jshree_ram

MadameX IF-Sizzlerz
MadameX
MadameX

Joined: 07 June 2011
Posts: 12238

Posted: 17 September 2011 at 6:35am | IP Logged
MJ, you're missing my point. Other female actresses act like other characters because that's their defined role. Suhana is a completely different character from all those other characters because of how the CVs have directed and characterized her as. If CVs wanted Suhana to be like ardarsh bahus with mahaan acting, even Ragini could essay that role but she doesn't choose to when signing on shows. She preferred roles with minimal rhona dhona and quite unlike other characters usually portrayed. Directors were also able to see Suhana in her during casting as well. But the thing is, what if there's another actress who can portray Suhana just as well if not better? We haven't given a chance to this unknown being if she exists and have already written her off as being impossible to do the role of Suhana. Of course this actress's portrayal of Suhana may be a bit different but what matters most is that the character can touch our hearts and convey the desired message clearly.
Look at Disha's situation. Disha 1 (aka Pooja) couldn't properly convey certain things really well that instantly should touch the viewers' hearts when it should have but Disha 2 did it instantly. The character Disha is the same but the actresses have changed. Directors saw Disha in first actress but when second actress came along as mere replacement, she was the better choice for audience. Because we saw two sides of the coin, we can judge better. But in Suhana/Ragini's situation, we haven't seen the other side of the coin so why pass on a judgement that only Ragini is capable of bringing out the character of Suhana really well? Maybe she is but how do we know without seeing it first?

The following 5 member(s) liked the above post:

sooraj_Nfantejeshecmjtruelegend111192iViews

MadameX IF-Sizzlerz
MadameX
MadameX

Joined: 07 June 2011
Posts: 12238

Posted: 17 September 2011 at 6:38am | IP Logged
And I had already put out a disclaimer that Suhana should not be compared to Lolita even though the characters are essentially the same because the background of the story is a little different in that one has Bengali background so her mannerisms and behavior will be different from that of the other who has Delhi background.
 
Basically, I want to bring out that comparisons have to be made properly...there has has to be an equal base before a comparison can be made otherwise it's unnecessary.

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

sooraj_Nfan111192iViews

asad.shah Senior Member
asad.shah
asad.shah

Joined: 13 June 2011
Posts: 343

Posted: 17 September 2011 at 6:50am | IP Logged
Ragini is a great actress and no doubt and questions on her acting. If she is not so talented y would she got a chance to host R.A One's music launch while there are a lot of actresses in star plus. She is a great actress and every one knows abt her talent

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

mjtruelegend

111192 IF-Rockerz
111192
111192

Joined: 02 April 2009
Posts: 6633

Posted: 17 September 2011 at 7:06am | IP Logged
Originally posted by MadameX

MJ, you're missing my point. Other female actresses act like other characters because that's their defined role. Suhana is a completely different character from all those other characters because of how the CVs have directed and characterized her as. If CVs wanted Suhana to be like ardarsh bahus with mahaan acting, even Ragini could essay that role but she doesn't choose to when signing on shows. She preferred roles with minimal rhona dhona and quite unlike other characters usually portrayed. Directors were also able to see Suhana in her during casting as well. But the thing is, what if there's another actress who can portray Suhana just as well if not better? We haven't given a chance to this unknown being if she exists and have already written her off as being impossible to do the role of Suhana. Of course this actress's portrayal of Suhana may be a bit different but what matters most is that the character can touch our hearts and convey the desired message clearly.
Look at Disha's situation. Disha 1 (aka Pooja) couldn't properly convey certain things really well that instantly should touch the viewers' hearts when it should have but Disha 2 did it instantly. The character Disha is the same but the actresses have changed. Directors saw Disha in first actress but when second actress came along as mere replacement, she was the better choice for audience. Because we saw two sides of the coin, we can judge better. But in Suhana/Ragini's situation, we haven't seen the other side of the coin so why pass on a judgement that only Ragini is capable of bringing out the character of Suhana really well? Maybe she is but how do we know without seeing it first?

Clap

ekta mai i am amazed ...you can write such a long write up that too a sensible oneWinkLOL

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

iViewsMadameX

MadameX IF-Sizzlerz
MadameX
MadameX

Joined: 07 June 2011
Posts: 12238

Posted: 17 September 2011 at 7:12am | IP Logged
Originally posted by 111192

Originally posted by MadameX

MJ, you're missing my point. Other female actresses act like other characters because that's their defined role. Suhana is a completely different character from all those other characters because of how the CVs have directed and characterized her as. If CVs wanted Suhana to be like ardarsh bahus with mahaan acting, even Ragini could essay that role but she doesn't choose to when signing on shows. She preferred roles with minimal rhona dhona and quite unlike other characters usually portrayed. Directors were also able to see Suhana in her during casting as well. But the thing is, what if there's another actress who can portray Suhana just as well if not better? We haven't given a chance to this unknown being if she exists and have already written her off as being impossible to do the role of Suhana. Of course this actress's portrayal of Suhana may be a bit different but what matters most is that the character can touch our hearts and convey the desired message clearly.
Look at Disha's situation. Disha 1 (aka Pooja) couldn't properly convey certain things really well that instantly should touch the viewers' hearts when it should have but Disha 2 did it instantly. The character Disha is the same but the actresses have changed. Directors saw Disha in first actress but when second actress came along as mere replacement, she was the better choice for audience. Because we saw two sides of the coin, we can judge better. But in Suhana/Ragini's situation, we haven't seen the other side of the coin so why pass on a judgement that only Ragini is capable of bringing out the character of Suhana really well? Maybe she is but how do we know without seeing it first?

Clap

ekta mai i am amazed ...you can write such a long write up that too a sensible oneWinkLOL
 
Now that I have been issued a restraining order, I have to channel my bak bak in other ways. Cry CryROFL

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

mjtruelegend111192

Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Author Replies Views Last Post
ATTENTION: Regarding OBS

Author: Angelic_A   Replies: 8   Views: 3689

Angelic_A 8 3689 08 September 2010 at 9:39am by k33a
Regarding Radha Bua

Author: shruthiR   Replies: 6   Views: 1008

shruthiR 6 1008 24 June 2010 at 11:50am by ankita.sushant
What is the fault of Suhana?

2

Author: SomerholicGirl   Replies: 11   Views: 1835

SomerholicGirl 11 1835 23 June 2010 at 5:28am by Manasi_16
Whose fault was it?

2 3 4 5 6 7

Author: Ambrosia   Replies: 48   Views: 4016

Ambrosia 48 4016 09 June 2010 at 1:00pm by infinity00
Is It My Fault???

2 3

Author: XSilentPrayersX   Replies: 17   Views: 1620

XSilentPrayersX 17 1620 04 June 2010 at 7:30pm by Sanayaa

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Sasural Genda Phool Topic Index

  • Please login to check your Last 10 Topics posted

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index