MSK Memory Loss- A Genuine Condition or A Mask - Page 4

since day1 ov this ML track i feel maan is just posing tat he has memory loss there is strong reason behind all dis ,i can see pain in msk's eyes wen he deliberately hurts geet

Edited by LavZ - 12 years ago

sumtyms i feel dat maan may be faking this ML thing to accomplosh his motive... bt then i feel dat he is MSK... he doesnt need to fake 4 anything... n besides all this ML thing is hurting geet d most... which maan can nvr do... u see in amritsar he promised her dat now onwards he ll nvr let her cry 4 anything... then y wud he break his promise... dat to made to geet😕

I have a feeling that Maan is faking amnesia and the reason is because he found out that there is something wrong with him i.e. he has a brain tumour, this would explain the headaches. I think he is doing this because he loves Geet so much that he can't bear for her to suffer seeing him dying... he is trying so hard to make her hate him. it's funny how he remembered her when he first woke up in the hospital after the accident... I bet that the doctors told him after she left that's why when she came back he had discharged himself gone home and then suddenly didn't remember anything.. I'm sure he will get cured and they will live happily until the next twist in the story.. Love Maan and Geet together so much love... :) 

This content was originally posted by: billie123

I have a feeling that Maan is faking amnesia and the reason is because he found out that there is something wrong with him i.e. he has a brain tumour, this would explain the headaches. I think he is doing this because he loves Geet so much that he can't bear for her to suffer seeing him dying... he is trying so hard to make her hate him. it's funny how he remembered her when he first woke up in the hospital after the accident... I bet that the doctors told him after she left that's why when she came back he had discharged himself gone home and then suddenly didn't remember anything.. I'm sure he will get cured and they will live happily until the next twist in the story.. Love Maan and Geet together so much love... :) 

The bolded part was Geet's dream not reality. Maan was still unconscious. Geet imagined that he hugged her. Maan is not faking his PA. If he was, why would he wonder to himself as to how the taveez landed on his neck? Why would he wonder about the shirt presented by Geet and ask himself when and how he got it?  Why would he be muttering to himself as to why Geet is arrogant and high handed? Remember all these self talks by Maan are done when there was no one to witness it. So why would he be saying all these things?  Most of all why would he insult Geet in front of his staff and family?  If he wanted her to hate him he can confine his harsh words when they are in private, couldn't he? By humiliating her in public and that too in front of his staff, is he not undermining her self respect?  If he thinks he is going to die in future, would Geet not be running the company?  What respect would the staff give her if he continuously derides her in their presence?  So it makes absolutely no sense for Maan to be faking his memory loss.  In fact if they show that he is at some point in future, then they would have massacred his character for good.  I'd rather that they dont do it and Maan really has PA.

Guys - This is a genuine condition.  Why do we like GHSP?  Because of the love that Maan and Geet share.  Why would Maan put Geet through this torture?  When you love someone unconditionally like they do, why would you think Maan has forgoten Geet, his soulmate.  No, this is a legit and Maan has partial amnesia.