Pyaar Kii Ye Ek Kahaani

India-Forums

   
Pyaar Kii Ye Ek Kahaani
Pyaar Kii Ye Ek Kahaani

Piya: Is Abhay Raichand her OCD? (Page 4)

carisma2 IF-Stunnerz
carisma2
carisma2

Joined: 25 January 2007
Posts: 29741

Posted: 09 May 2011 at 11:07am | IP Logged
Originally posted by Pocahontas

Originally posted by sdoll

Awesome  post dear. Clapu've told everything so nicely.Thumbs Up
 

Thank you. And thank you for not hitting me even though i might seem anti-Piya in my take . ShockedLOL
 
Pocahontas... I dunt cum here too often, but I have attended a few of thy seminars.. and I generally like thy posts. I think.. you give  a balanced layout. You do a fantastic job.
U do not have to conform.. to other people's views as we all are different...
But you do do a fantastic job and are dedicated... If critics of your hard effort(Which you give to this forum in goodwill)  could have done better, then I'm sure they would have tried.
It is important to have double POV's in a forum ... Even a single brain has two parts. As long as it is done in the right manner.
So well done u for keeping your spirits up. Thumbs Up

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

pyar-ishk

TheBlackJaguar IF-Stunnerz
TheBlackJaguar
TheBlackJaguar

Joined: 15 January 2005
Posts: 47914

Posted: 09 May 2011 at 11:07am | IP Logged
Originally posted by Anamika1570

Well...I think Piya is Obsessed about Abhay. Everything about him affects her deeply and she goes to extremes for him or for finding his secrets. Even when she says that 'everything is over' she cannot leave him alone... If that is not Obsession... then what is it?
 

Ah, see. EmbarrassedYou summed up my thoughts bang-on in two lines. That is what i want to know as well. If this is not obsession , WHAT IS? Smile

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

AnamikaSJain

--sanchita-- IF-Sizzlerz
--sanchita--
--sanchita--

Joined: 08 May 2007
Posts: 13508

Posted: 09 May 2011 at 11:14am | IP Logged
I cant ever understand the char Piya. She is too complicated for me even more complicated than abhay. She loogled for abhay and was 90% sure abhay being vampire still shocked seeing his vampy avataar and bathing to wash away his touch. But the very next day she starts running behind him asking him why he allowed her to fall in love with him. Today she said she hated abhay but still she searching for abhay's bro. Reason unknown. Not blaming her. It's just that she is too complicated to me to understand. Is it obssession or love?Ouch

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

-rupa-

TheBlackJaguar IF-Stunnerz
TheBlackJaguar
TheBlackJaguar

Joined: 15 January 2005
Posts: 47914

Posted: 09 May 2011 at 11:16am | IP Logged
Originally posted by NIDIZ

Well Poca I knw u haven't left any point unsaid..like always I loved this...
  I believe Pia's Obsession was only due to her character sketch as a curious cat..
She is Obssessed Rite.. but not with Abhay..atleast not this time..She is obssessed with figuring out the very fact that distributes her mind more..Yes she was depressed with Abhay hiding the bite..n infecting her blood ..!! She was upset that she broke up with Abhay..She felt low, was going to sing the sad melody..
But, the Overcurious Behavior that she has always manages to over come everything..her priority is to seek knowledge about everything that has been hidden..!!
Abhay is her love..I have No Doubt abt her love..n her Obsession for him..
But she wants him to unfold every bit of his life's History..She wants him to open up..like she always has done..!! For Abhay ,Pia Is An Open Book..!!
But For Pia,Abhay Is The Mystery Continues..??
 Pia has always found it very hard to even find a bit of Abhay..He;s like rare element.. U can't get it, or if u can u don't wanna loose it..!!
Pia don't wanna loose Abhay n for that she'll wants to knw everything abt him..!!

Nidzie, my argument is not from today. It dates back to Piya's entire history with Abhay. Even when Abhay hated her , was not dating her and had categorically telling told her to mind her own business , her homework and life-stalking did not stop. And she told him that is she wants to be near him, he cannot stop her. I know she loves him but at the same time , her obsession with him also runs on parallel  tracks. 



As of the other character's Chaand - Abhay n Misha - Arnav stold the show away..
Chaand for understanding Abhay's feeling..for Pia..
Surprise ... I aways knew that Chaand has a soft feeling for Abhay like Haseena does have fo Sid..!! They r lucky enough, to hv The Raichaands as their Parents..!!
But yes Misha always will be Arnavs Princess..
Misha loves her dad n that was clearly visible as always...!! 

Oh I loved Arnab-Misha. They are each-other's anchors and Arnab is Misha's world. Chaand loves Abhay in his own twisted way and that is heartwarming. Embarrassed

P.s: I wanna Pia to atleast change her wardrobe now.. Common She's a Dobriyal abh toh achae dress lou..!! 

Lolz. The actors of this show , minus Sid, Kabir,Misha like looking hideous on screen. You wouldn't want to be caught dead in the bullcrap that they wear on screen in the name of clothes. Ouch

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

-rupa-

Ashtad. Senior Member
Ashtad.
Ashtad.

Joined: 26 January 2010
Posts: 287

Posted: 09 May 2011 at 11:17am | IP Logged
Originally posted by Pocahontas

Originally posted by -Hello-


 
Abhay loves Piya and his feelings are about Piya, her safe life and her happiness. He hasn't spent episodes trying to find out why Piya looks like Maithli nor did he ever show much interest in her personal life until she broke down. Abhay doesn't have a fixation with Piya as an individual entity , like Piya has with him and his past life. 
 
If we are talking Piyas investigation on Metz, even creatives suggested that Piya decided to do it cause she couldnt bear the pain she saw in Abhay , just as Abhay tried his best and cheated with 'mind-scanning' loool, abt her truth when he felt he had to cause of the pain he saw in her. And both Stopped after each showed a to emotional breakdown on it, Piya after falling down crying in collage, abhay after the cage talk. Also, Piya did put her full trust in Abhay postpone the Relation and even before she was not on his investigations, even whe he was 'we have to keep it a secret' she didt ask why? just nooded in happiness. and the list goes on on such blind fate moments. So expecting her to sit down silent after the broken trust, and that in a situation like this, is unfair, specially when it goes to a level of calling it a disease if it was another show,lol.
I guess i am just surprised why her investigations would be wrong while another in her place would come along as right.
 
 

I tell you what, Abhay just likes to wallow in misery because somewhere he truly believes that he is destined to be sad, brooding and melancholic. Ouch
 
yea, Well, at some point when it gets to repetitive that does just put off the audience, he needs to rather be the attack type than just the 'defender' , and funny is when the heroine is not supporting it she becomes the villanConfusedLOL. Although its been times where happiness have been shining on him with Piya, and hope to see more of it.
 
 
 


Edited by -Hello- - 09 May 2011 at 11:17am
abhina_roks Goldie
abhina_roks
abhina_roks

Joined: 17 March 2011
Posts: 1095

Posted: 09 May 2011 at 11:22am | IP Logged
wow i loved ur post...u put ur things in mind so beautifully...nobody can write as expressive as you write...
by the way i liked ur analysis as i too some what felt the same...but its just that creatives who are giving this shade to pia as you said...they are making her so desperate to be a detective and interfere in all things and other person's life...well i know its her nature from the very beginning...
so cant blame much...
but atleast this time its not irritating though cause if she finds out, its for abhiya's benefit...
i hope they dont drag this track where she finds out abt sid's mom...

ur lines cracked me up LOLdelivered 10-20 dukhi aatma part 2 dialogues about betrayal and stuff  with a dash of five spoons of tears , any other heroine would have been crying for 3.5 minutes on Film City road with dried leaves flying in blower fans. 

you rightly said she was Loggling only on Abhayendra, she needs to add more keywords lolsss...

Misha is definetely Arnav's princess no doubt...that is the reason misha was so hurt when she came to know the truth becoz she loves her dad to the core...

and i must say ur positive angle to this whole break up is good...abhay is talking abt his pain openly to his parents...chand's thinking and supportive nature to abhay is always pleasure to watch...

haseena went to the hospital to find out abt arnav...that was unexpected, but lols...it was good...she came to know abt arnav's approval of sid's marriage...

i dont understand why cant chandeena complain to superiors abt sid's marriage with a human...that is so simple...sid will get a warining from superiors as its against their laws...

TheBlackJaguar IF-Stunnerz
TheBlackJaguar
TheBlackJaguar

Joined: 15 January 2005
Posts: 47914

Posted: 09 May 2011 at 11:42am | IP Logged
Originally posted by Cute.Sadaf

Whole Episode was The mixture of cOnfusions ..
I'm too exasperate now why the hell Piya won't leave Abhay alone if she don't wanna keep any relation with him .. Neither Abhay leaves Piya his proteCtion is On the top level ..
Piya's dialgoue -
Kya humara relationship sirf jhoot & fareb tha,jo risha jhoot ki buniyad pe ho woh sahi kaise ho sakta hai,kya yeh sab fake tha?Acha hua mujhe aaj abhay k baare mai pata chal gaya.
Ufff .. In all Ekta's sOap , Heroine Changed so easily .. And the Hero tryin' to make her understand and Understand till the End .. ( But aadat hogayee hay ab tou iski . so i can survive ) LOL
Pia is now too near to find the truth , atleast , she found that Abhayendar's bro also luved Maitthli .. Great .. Luv the support Of Chand towards Abhay .. ( Yeh Vampires itne bure bhi nahin hain ) LOLLOL

 

I think for all BT heroines and sometimes the hero as well, one bad cancels out the 99 goods. Piya is still 17+ and i guess her maturity and POV of life and people needs to broaden . Perhaps that will make her understand that sometimes people are what they are - you cannot chisel and hammer everyone. LOL
NIDIZ IF-Sizzlerz
NIDIZ
NIDIZ

Joined: 02 March 2009
Posts: 19858

Posted: 09 May 2011 at 11:47am | IP Logged
Ouch
Originally posted by Pocahontas

Originally posted by NIDIZ

Well Poca I knw u haven't left any point unsaid..like always I loved this...
  I believe Pia's Obsession was only due to her character sketch as a curious cat..
She is Obssessed Rite.. but not with Abhay..atleast not this time..She is obssessed with figuring out the very fact that distributes her mind more..Yes she was depressed with Abhay hiding the bite..n infecting her blood ..!! She was upset that she broke up with Abhay..She felt low, was going to sing the sad melody..
But, the Overcurious Behavior that she has always manages to over come everything..her priority is to seek knowledge about everything that has been hidden..!!
Abhay is her love..I have No Doubt abt her love..n her Obsession for him..
But she wants him to unfold every bit of his life's History..She wants him to open up..like she always has done..!! For Abhay ,Pia Is An Open Book..!!
But For Pia,Abhay Is The Mystery Continues..??
 Pia has always found it very hard to even find a bit of Abhay..He;s like rare element.. U can't get it, or if u can u don't wanna loose it..!!
Pia don't wanna loose Abhay n for that she'll wants to knw everything abt him..!!

Nidzie, my argument is not from today. It dates back to Piya's entire history with Abhay. Even when Abhay hated her , was not dating her and had categorically telling told her to mind her own business , her homework and life-stalking did not stop. And she told him that is she wants to be near him, he cannot stop her. I know she loves him but at the same time , her obsession with him also runs on parallel  tracks. 

OoH I get it..I know what you mean..Well Pia stalking Abhay is of no different than she stalking any other character..LOL But, Abhay can make anyone go n join detective agency..!! 
She was curious to know why this guy wearing Black coming in Black BMW ..Talks n even  Feels Black ..?? 
 Why he behaves so rare , whats so Dark about him.. that still manages to affect me..Whats so fascinating about him..Who is Abhay Raichand..??
Pia always wants to explore everything..n that way she fell in for him.. Yes,Abhay is her Obsession..n she wants it that way..!!
  
As of the other character's Chaand - Abhay n Misha - Arnav stold the show away..
Chaand for understanding Abhay's feeling..for Pia..
Surprise ... I aways knew that Chaand has a soft feeling for Abhay like Haseena does have fo Sid..!! They r lucky enough, to hv The Raichaands as their Parents..!!
But yes Misha always will be Arnavs Princess..
Misha loves her dad n that was clearly visible as always...!! 

Oh I loved Arnab-Misha. They are each-other's anchors and Arnab is Misha's world. Chaand loves Abhay in his own twisted way and that is heartwarming. Embarrassed

P.s: I wanna Pia to atleast change her wardrobe now.. Common She's a Dobriyal abh toh achae dress lou..!! 

Lolz. The actors of this show , minus Sid, Kabir,Misha like looking hideous on screen. You wouldn't want to be caught dead in the bullcrap that they wear on screen in the name of clothes. Ouch
 Double Ouch..!! I shuld forget abt Besides I have better to think about..!! Let the fashion police deal with em,..!!

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

-rupa-

Go to top

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Pyaar Kii Ye Ek Kahaani Topic Index

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index