Posted: 05 May 2011 at 7:41am | IP Logged
You know something. I agree with you on many of the of the character's analysis, except for Jhilmil, Pranali and Maya.
I would give Jhilmil a 9/10 because almost every time he says something that either helps KD solve the case or gives KD an idea of what he needs to do to solve the case.
For Pranali, I would be a bit more lenient and give her a 8/10 because she is a much better lawyer than Maya. I feel she looks much more like a lawyer and acts like one too. While she does jump to conclusions once in a while, she isn't narrow-minded and sees the bigger picture many times. Like in the 2-hour Gumnaam special, when KD was trying to explain to her that the murderer was someone else, she did see the bigger picture and was almost about ready to accept KD's theory except for the fact that she was his opposition at that point.
I think you're being too nice by giving Maya a 7/10. I would give her 5/10. Her acting is mundane and she says almost the same lines every episode. "Iss baar toh tum paka haaroge KD." and things like that. Also she has the same format of trying to solve the case. She never looks at the bigger picture and if she gets some new evidence against the accused, she doesn't think twice about when and how to present it due to which KD always gives her "check" (chess check, I mean) with each new piece of evidence.
Edited by luv_cid_shreya - 05 May 2011 at 7:43am