Gunahon Ka Devta

   

Case of the Mysterious Letter *Updated Pg 6* (Page 6)

Post Reply New Post

Page 6 of 14

Vistaa

IF-Rockerz

Vistaa

Joined: 23 October 2009

Posts: 6317

Posted: 08 April 2011 at 9:59am | IP Logged
Originally posted by chatterbox

yup pmd u Wink
 
Thaaaaaaaaank you, you are such a darlingBig smileBig smileBig smile

Dear Guest, Being an unregistered member you are missing out on participating in the lively discussions happening on the topic "Case of the Mysterious Letter *Updated Pg 6* (Page 6)" in Gunahon Ka Devta forum. In addition you lose out on the fun interactions with fellow members and other member exclusive features that India-Forums has to offer. Join India's most popular discussion portal on Indian Entertainment. It's FREE and registration is effortless so JOIN NOW!

chatterbox

IF-Sizzlerz

chatterbox

Joined: 01 May 2005

Posts: 22111

Posted: 08 April 2011 at 10:01am | IP Logged
u welcome and cleared  what u asked  

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

Vistaa

-Prashu-

IF-Sizzlerz

-Prashu-

Joined: 13 October 2010

Posts: 16970

Posted: 08 April 2011 at 12:14pm | IP Logged
Vista DiHugHug

Thank You fr the marvelous analysis!!ClapClap


GKD forum is full of superb detectivesLOL

Way to Go EveryoneWink

Arpita cant write the letter..! She must be still recovering!!

So..she is ruled out and plus....she trusted bahuji tht she wont reveal the truth to Avi.. During the time gap between Holi party and the confrontation..she just had doubt abt Avi being Angry on her fr some reason .!! .Or she may have written it long before and may be Lallanpur's Postal Service is very slow tht her letter reached its destination so lateLOLLOL

Juz kidding..Its cldnt be Arpi

Nd Bahuji....I think Yes..she may be.....Take a closer look at the handwriting and the handwriting of the letter tht bahuji wrote when Shikha gave flowers to Arpita!

Its almost Similar...! I knw guys its not enough proof to say Bahuji wrote it ( But it can be one of the proofs)

Bahuji has her own motive! To make everyone knw tht Arpita is at fault! She can be the writer

Shikha..since shikha came to knw abt it night before and tht too...she dsnt knw full truth not even half of it! She didnt wrote tht letter

Caz the words used in letter ...   "kalank " wldnt come to her mind ..caz she dsnt knw even hint of wht happnd with Arpi...  It was only used by Arpi before!

Panditji......Even he can be behind this.... caz of his motive of either he is involved with lal singh or he wants good of Haveli..( which bahuji cant do)


I dnt think so people who are taking care of Arpi did this ..caz they wont even knw wht happnd to Arpi unless they knw Arpi and Haveli's matters ..( this cld be only  in case of Haveli's insiders )

This was my logicLOLLOL


I may be wrong too ..but right now ..m so tired ..cant even think properlyOuch

This is a curious case of mysterious letterLOL


And Yeah!!! Everyone....... Fantastic PossiblitiesClap



Edited by prash_t - 08 April 2011 at 12:18pm

The following 6 member(s) liked the above post:

BenNevistalkie14Vistaajes_jadelonelyshadowyoga23priya

jes_jade

IF-Rockerz

jes_jade

Joined: 22 June 2010

Posts: 8046

Posted: 08 April 2011 at 1:18pm | IP Logged
Awesome analysis Vista Di!!!!ClapClap

OMG!!!!! Everyone has written such long-long posts!!!!!ShockedShockedClapClap

I am not an analysist or a writer...so will type out only few lines....LOLLOL

I can say only one thing.......I am confused..Confused

& I think Shikha had written the letter....EmbarrassedEmbarrassed

The following 4 member(s) liked the above post:

BenNevisVistaa-Prashu-yoga23priya

.Vrish.

Viewbie

.Vrish.

Joined: 25 October 2008

Posts: 20928

Posted: 08 April 2011 at 1:28pm | IP Logged
From Shikha's reaction today to RV burning it, looks like she hasn't, and she has no idea of what's in that letter.  Now I'm almost sure it's BJ!!!

The following 6 member(s) liked the above post:

BenNevistalkie14Vistaajes_jade-Prashu-yoga23priya

BenNevis

Goldie

BenNevis

Joined: 16 January 2011

Posts: 1174

Posted: 08 April 2011 at 2:11pm | IP Logged
Hey VistaBig smile
 
After watching today's epi i have changed my mind about the mysterious letter wrote by Avi to BJ.
I dont know why always expect the change in ppl like Bhainsbhudhi Avi.I should not expect that  instantly with one incident Avi gets his brains back.Me thought after watching Yesterday epi felt he really believes Arpi innocent and will try to find the truth soon .
Hooo!!!!Me always expect things in hurry as it seems nw.
Sorry dear , im sticked to BJ now.
 
 


Edited by BenNevis - 08 April 2011 at 3:22pm

The following 5 member(s) liked the above post:

talkie14Vistaajes_jade-Prashu-yoga23priya

yoga23priya

IF-Sizzlerz

yoga23priya

Joined: 06 November 2010

Posts: 10932

Posted: 08 April 2011 at 2:43pm | IP Logged
WOW just Awesome Vista di Clap Clap Clap

i loved the way to you write and i was waiting for your take on this letter..you show completely different meaning of it Clap Star Clap

to all my GKD'ians Detectives this was complete shock for me..WOW i didn't know that di's and friends were so intelligent like my aunty ROFL

i loved everyone views on it and it's not only Amazing but also mind blowing Clap Clap




okay this is my view about the letter...

Suspect  1 Shikha

After watching today's epi i think it was Shikha who wrote the letter and to check whether RV is involved or not...as she said that she had doubt on him before so i think  she was one..Cool Cool

Suspect 2 Arpitha

May be Arpi could send him letter whether to see he could help her in proving her innocence to Avi so she wrote a letter so may be he would change his mind and say truth to Avi Confused Confused


Suspect 3 My Uncle PJ

i think he is one who saved Arpi and i didn't like the expressions he was giving from past twol epi's Approve

i don't whether i am right or wrong so here are my views

Once Again thanks for this wonderful post vista di

love ya Hug 

The following 5 member(s) liked the above post:

BenNevistalkie14Vistaajes_jade-Prashu-

Vistaa

IF-Rockerz

Vistaa

Joined: 23 October 2009

Posts: 6317

Posted: 08 April 2011 at 8:11pm | IP Logged
OK people............ I am back, am not half asleep and have spent the last half hour going through each one's response.
 
 
Hats off to your sleuthing skills GKDians , you all should be proud of yourselves.    Such fabulous points and angles, me left open-mouthed. Bravo!!!
 
 
 
I will just list who each one of you thought was the most likely suspect and then discuss below:
 
 
Swamini:                     Shikha
CB                              PJ
Laxmi                         Shikha, Avi
Nandini                      Shikha
Sharan                       Arpi
Vrish                          BJ
Sonia                          Not BJ
Gauri                          PJ
TP                              Shikha
Rashi                          Shikha
Sowjanya                    BJ or Avi. Later, Avi cancelled.
Prash                          Could be any in the list, except Arpi
Jessi                          Shikha
Priya                          Shikha, Arpi, PJ
 
 
 
Nandini and Laxmi, thou art absolutely correctClapClap in saying that GKD is bloopers galore, and that we can write off the timeline issue as a blooper. CB, I will come to your theories and your Lal Singh in just a minute. And Laxmi, sorry....will have to consider Avi being the author as the fantasy of a love-crazed fan  Not that there is anything wrong in fantasies....me love fantasies  Lagi rahiye.....LOLLOLLOL
 
 
Sharan sweetie, there is only one way Arpi could have written this letter....it would have had to be before she first tried to commit suicide by jumping off the terrace. And as someone suggested jokingly, Lallanpur mail was so slow to deliver it, that RV received it only now.
 
 
Vrish: wow, fabulous bit of digging ...loved your line of argument. What you say about BJ's motivation could be true, except perhaps, in my mind, she can't really take that risk. Even though she has ultimately prevailed upon him and got him stripped of his title and position, she doesn't have a doubt in her mind that on any given day, he could turn the tables on her in a heartbeat. There is no love lost between them and she doesn't want to have to interact with him if she can possibly avoid it. Notice how curtly she told him over the phone that he need not come to Arpi's funeral. The fact that RV knows at least some of her moves against Arpi, would prevent her from needling RV. She would want to stay away from him. This point was made so pithily by Sonia. Thanks.
Will discuss to PJ's candidature as the letter writer in a bit
 
 
JustTP: you said it girl.....brilliant! Both your points about Shikha and PJ are spot on. After watching today's epi I too believe that Shikha is the author. And PJ's motivations have been summed up by you so succinctly. Rashi and Jessie, I agree with you dears. Sowjanya, Prash, and Priya: great points guys, lots of food for thought.
 
 
 
So to summarize, IMHO:
 
 
 
BJ would not have written it because she doesn't want to risk provoking RV into ratting out on her to Avi. Plus, there is very little she can hope to gain from it.....a rattled RV might be more dangerous to her than a contained one. All she wants to focus now on is to put this whole issue behind her and reduce Avi to being the Bhayyaji once more. She doesn't even want to be reminded of Arpi.....in today's epi, she goes around advising everyone to forget her. By writing the letter,she would have just kept the issue alive.
 
 
 
PJ could not have written. Even if we disregard the feminine writing, I am not sure PJ could have used the khadi boli (hindi) and the word "please" He too uses the thet avadhi dialect as BJ does....unlikely that he could have drafted the Hindi letter. Plus, if his motivation is to expose BJ, why would he try to unnerve RV, who is BJ's adversary ? Enemy of my enemy is my friend......? PJ did not write the letter, but his role in the ultimate expose of BJ (prob towards the end of the show) would probably be pivotal. I am still torn between his being loyal to the haveli and doing all the misdeeds for the sake of the family, and him really being BJ's man....true only to her. . I haven't really seen any particularly fond interaction between him and Ammaji. But then again, that could be a front.....now we are really going in the realms of counter-espionage!!! Ha ha haLOLLOLLOL
 Sorry CB, but Lal Singh doesn't seem likely to be directing PJ's revolt, if there is any.
 
 
Now to Shikha: IMHO she suspected RV not being the real deal ....remember how he screamed at her when she had come to their home after the wedding? So after hearing BJ's accusations the night before, she probably felt that  something was fishy.............I don't think she has reached the conclusion quite yet that BJ is the one against Arpi. So it is easier for her to suspect RV as being somehow involved. So she decides to go on a fishing expedition of her own and sends this letter, or as Nandini suggested, hands to the postman to deliver to RV, in order to see his reaction. And as Vrish & TP suggested, she plans to judge by RV's reaction to the letter, whether he is guilty or not. The fact that he burns the letter, tells her that her suspicions were correct and that he is involved in this sorry affair. That's when she decides to tell Avi, Mama Rai and Simple. She could have possibly told BJ too, if only she had not come of so strongly against the idea of a conspiracy against Arpi. I think BJ's firm reaction to the idea, probably puts Shikha on her guard and in search of a more sympathetic audience.
 
Another important point is the language of  the letter. Shikha has been to college and she speaks regular Hindi....as did Arpi....and she could have used the word "please" ,  unlike BJ and PJ.
 
 
 
So this is it....the saga of the mysterious letter.
 
 
Vista
 
Sorry for not having replied to your posts earlier.Embarrassed Thank you so much for all your fab posts.
 
Will wait to hear from you all.Big smile
 
Vista
 
 
 
 
 


Edited by Vistaa - 08 April 2011 at 8:12pm

The following 9 member(s) liked the above post:

-sia-Cuty16BenNevismsmarple.Vrish.talkie14jes_jade-Prashu-chatterbox

Post Reply New Post

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category

Active Forums

Gunahon Ka Devta Topic Index

Limit search to this Forum only.

 

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.