Iconic On-screen Ladies (Vote!) - Page 2

Originally posted by: Relda

None of Kajol's performances were better than Shilpa in Phir Milenge? Really? I have never ever heard of anyone speak of her performance in any form whatsoever from this movie.

Edited by stars4u - 13 years ago

Shilpa Shetty in Phir Milenge was great and did really well, but Iconic? i don't think so  Edited by AbbiePrivate - 13 years ago

Kareena for JWM definitely because she really made it iconic I mean she performed powerfully I loved it :)

Fab list !! I was thinking they nailed it till I saw Shilpa's name 😆..She never appealed to me as an actress..Nor do I think to the aam junta..Phir Milenga was a hugee flop and never won any accolades..How can u call a perfomance "iconic" unless it is acknwoldged by critcs or a wider audiewnce?:S 😕..like say Tabu in astitva loved by critics or Kareena in JWM appreciated by both critics and junta

Karisma in Shakti,Fida/Kajol in Fanaa,U me aur hum anyday over Shilpa in PM..heck! even Ash in Chokerbali,Kareena in Chameli,PC in Fashion..!

From the list I loved Vidya in Paa,Kareena in JWM,Anu in BBB(though i wont call it iconic but refreshing compared to the current standards of bolly),Gayatri in Swades(one of the best potrayal of an Indian woman) also Tabu
Edited by kattyluv - 13 years ago

Originally posted by: koolchick

Vidya Balan except I never saw Paa

She looked iconic in Parineeta though

I'm surprised that Kajol isn't in the list whereas Shilpa is because Kajol clearly is the better actress :D

^^ same here, but I don't really trust this list as I'v seen better.. 

i dunt think the list refers to "actors" as such...it refers to their characters....and im pretty sure its referring to this particular decade..and acc to me, none of kajol's characters were memorable as such...they were the same old ones...k3g, u me aur hum, fanaa, mnik, waf....they weren't anything memorable, refreshing or path breaking ... Edited by smartie_pants - 13 years ago

wutever happend to gayatri joshi

Yeah right Kajol's blind girl act in Fanaa or alzheimer's patient role in UMAH gets called  ghista pista 😛 (so not suprising) while Rani's in black was the most incredible character ever see in the history of Indian cinema.. totaally new nothing repetetive 😆..Then again this is the same forum where DDLJ is labelled as a meaningless cliched and the likes of Biwi no:1 are touted as EPICs 😆..to each his own ,everyone is biased against their non favourite and fans obviously love whatever their favorite does
Edited by kattyluv - 13 years ago