Originally posted by Mllu.N
Originally posted by Mllu.N'Jealousy
!' you shock me he is her husband, she claimed & accepted him as
her child's father what has he to be jealous or insecured of a Rapist.
The relationship that Geet & Dev share is of a Rapist & a
was jealous to see geet and dev together and trusting an outsider and
seeing a photo of devgeet was an extreme step was'nt expecting this from
maan but thankgod he realized his mistake he said"geet did so much for
me bring happiness in my life,give me a new life and what i did in
return broke her heart"he said"my hatred will snatch everything from me
one day" he admitted he went blind in his hatred for geet (sorry its my mistake he went blind in hatred for dev-just a writing mistake that he fogot everything and what geet went through when he was fighting for his life.
Maan jealous of this ?
he was jealous and that's what i say and will remain stick to it
remember what he once said to geet i cannot see anyone coming closer to
you geet, maan witnessed geet with dev in the photo, in the outhouse yes
if not too much yes it was a little bit of jealousy.
your POV sure i expect u to stick to it ..as do to my POV that Maan has
nothing to be jealous of a loser who is now sheltered under his roof
...whose debt he cleared to save him from death even before knowing that
he too had saved his life.
Jealous means painful desire for another's advantages - what is it here that Dev has achieved that can make want .....
to the example u gave..well Maan said it out of love but as Geet was
given dialogue 'Dev ki galti' were as the word should be gunhah.....
i stick to Maan being possessive for Geet ..which loving husband isn't.
i found was angry at seeing her there when he had made it clear to Dadi
too to not allow Dev in Geet's sight but here Geet was standing infront
of Dev ...Geet too had thought more than once before stepping out ..she
knew it was doomed to go & stop Dev...
I stick to it Maan
has no reason to be jealous of Dev were Geet is concerned..as i said Dev
& Geet share only the relationship of being Rapist & Victim
..& that sure is not a relationship that can make Maan jealous at
not having to call his own
realized that he was blinded by his hatred for Dev...u wrote Geet...the
episode i catched i dint find him saying he hated Geet.
He rather kill himself than hate Geet.
its my mistake a writing mistake so dont want to say anything yes at
this point coz of my stupid writing mistake i will have to agree with
you he will die rather than to hate geet-silly me.
wasn't sorry for his hatred towards Dev nor his anger. He was sorry that
he could not console her from her pain rather went on with his anger.
disagree if he was angry that he cannot console her in her pain and
than there was no sense of maan saying"geet you knew you were wrong"Of
course its you pov to me Maan said Geet you are wrong ..with that he
meant Geet you are wrong in thinking that such a life could be
acceptable to me that is begged at Dev's mercyand if he went on with his anger it means that he will keep this pain in his heart forever ofcourse
he will keep it in his heart forever..can Geet ever forgive dev totally
..did she now ..then why not Maan at his brother for doing it to a
innocent girl, now his wife.that he cannot console geet it means that nothing is ever going to be allright between him and geet?out of question.Sure
out of question since both lack communication ..why should Maan be
consoling & assuring always ...& Geet always at need at it..now
she is his wife ....not anymore a victim at mercy of society he helping
He was sorry for having her fear his anger & keep the truth from him & suffer alone.
maan was sorry that geet suffered alot because of his anger she kept
the truth hidden from him and maan admitted too that yes because of my
anger geet did'nt tell me the truth.
Originally posted by Mllu.N
is so particular about his principles that's why it happened to him he
was both blinded by hatred and his prinicples but for prinicples in a
wrong way that made him forget geet and the baby and he went
aggressive.Geet had no chice left except for seeking help from dev and
geet explained it to maan and after that his expressions were remorseful
and he realized how much pain he has caused geet when he himself
realized that his words has hurt geet to no limit
his principles that made him punish his own blood, its his principles
that made him fight for this woman against all, his family too & its
his love for her.
Mallu why is Maan hating Dev - for what he did
to Geet & the baby. Both Geet & Baby could not have been alive
thanks to Dev if Maan had not been there for them.
And its this that makes him hate Dev. He does not hate Dev for himself or his principles alone .
Only coz of Geet & the Baby he hates Dev.
if it was'nt his principle than he could'nt he maan singh khurana this
is what makes him maan that for his principles he can even go against
his love ones and geet was right msk also told geet if you were'nt on
the right side i never would've supported you.Maan was angry because of
many reasons one of them was that too that geet went against his
principles thats what infuriates him but!!!!Geet
went against her own principles too by letting Dadi's pledding come b/w
Maan & her & not telling him such a big truth ..hiding which
she was constantly pleading guilty when alone, when with his pic &
when she tells Dadi at how much wrong they are doing to Maan.
Its two sided coin..we cannot ignore one to praise the otherthis
situation of maan and geet was never about principles.Yes maan hates
dev for what he did to geet and baby because he loves her to no limit.
he was remorseful when he see her relive the pain yet again ..he was
sorry that she had to suffer it again to make him see it.
It was not Geet alone who was hurt, her hiding the truth hurt him & his reaction to it made her get hurt
Newton's law - its applicable here too
its not the question that who was more hurt, yes maan was hurt because he did'nt know the whole situation.
knew maan would be angry but she did'nt expect maan would say without
thinking about her and baby that you should have let me die.
seriously disagree... Geet knew it ....when heard Dadi that Dev is the
guy to help her now she went to his hospital room door & looking
through there she herself said that i know u will detest it hate urself
knowing its Dev's blood that saved u....she knew he will hurt himself
if he knows that..what does hurting/hating himself mean in such
Originally posted by Mllu.NWhy
couldn't Maan believe that Geet begged to Dev when he too could have
done the same if he were to be in her shoes, He knows her love for him
as much as he knows his own.
could'nt believe that geet begged dev to save maan he thinks that death
would be better but he must have put himself in geet's shoe and than
think what if it was geet fighting for her life and maan had no other
choice except for seeking help from dev , would maan have left geet in
the jaws of death????no never esp when geet was too getting
worse???Whenm geet was sitting in the hospital helpless it was like each
moment is passing like an year
If Geet faced this moment now Maan
too has seen her in hospital bed fighting for 2 lives & he helpless
left only to pray..so he knows what she went through seeing him near
there is no need to say anything here you have answered your own question.
begged to Dev her sinner its this thought that made him want to die. Do
Dev & Maan not share the same blood in the first place as brothers
& family. Yet now why he hates this blood in his veins - Only becoz
Geet had to beg for it from Dev.
blood in his veins gives him the reason to say you should have let me
die no!!! he said this because he was only seeing the one side of the
truth and if maan was concerned about geet that it was better to see
geet begging in front of her sinner that this thing will get wrong
i.e."geet you know you are wrong" if he is concerned in this way that
geet begging in front of her sinner that was infuriating maan, than he
cannot say geet is wrong.
said Geet you are wrong again i repeat ..to her thinking that such a
life could be acceptable to him..it was to simple to notice that he
And his hating his brothers blood is coz its Geet's
sinners blood & now it flowing in his veins will never let him be in
the very sight of dev had made geet faint ...now her husband carrying that blood ...ahh!!!!
the conference room when geet had come to say him sorry for horrible
friday Maan said i want you to stay away from me coz i don't want to any
ways be mirror that will remind u of Dev ..coz Dev is my bro & he
also said he hated being Khurana as he shares that name with Dev
man who hates sharing his name with a man coz that man had cozed Geet
grief now he sharing his blood....!!! and u want him to accept it ..he
also knows it was so difficult for Geet..when he knows it difficult for
her to see face ..to get him to save maan..sure it cannot be easy..he
knew it but he dint voice it & so he was sorry
I will have to write more, there is more to add.....
to be continued.Have some work to do.(incomplete analysis)
Originally posted by Mllu.NShe
dint confront Maan about the pics coz she knew Maan did not suspect her
about having an affair or any such with Dev. Maan himself did not
question her about the picture but dropped it at his feet & left,
not believing or needing the picture but what his eyes showed him. Geet
stopping Dev, were as he believed Geet had nothing to do with Dev other
off to geet that she did'nt even ask or confront maan about the photo,
she did'nt ask him that how could you prefer an outsider on me and well
there is in another point although the photo was taken and it was a
reality but photo manipulating is a game now, maan did'nt think for a
moment that this photo can be made..
you got me wrong, she in her
dreams cant imagine maan suspecting her it was not about suspecting it
was about trust geet have every right to confront maan that how can he
just believe in a picture which was given to him by a third person.
lolz...nor can he in his dream suspect Geet who is
a open book to him that made him literary drop the blackmailers call 3
times ..untill pic arrived of geet..then too for geet's safety sake he
left to meet that guy & even before going there he did call her but
she was not available so he dint wait fearing with dev there geet might
be trouble ..and
he dint believe the pic...unlike geet who had trusted dev & cozed
the horrible friday maan has never reacted to other person's word
against geet but geet herself
..he believed what he saw at the outhouse ..not the pic but geet
stopping dev even after being told to stay away by maan & to dadi
Whoa ! Mallu ...the pic with the hospital in bg & 2
people in conversation not in any such state that can be questionable
.....the picture pointed Geet met Dev & Maan has no idea of it ..why
could a simple pic with 2 people in public spot talking have him
question its authenticity
its not about
authenticity its about trust!!!that's it.Too people talking and public
in background that's what all photo manipulation is about well that's a
different thing, esp when geet admits that its the truth but maan
does'nt know the whole other side of it.
yes its about trust but trust questioned not
broken..!!!! .... enlighten me any dialogue that i missed may be u saw
where maan said he trusted the pic....i'll be glad to know that then we
can discuss on it or its point less talking on what was not even
considered to be shown & we blasting our head out on it
With the first pic received dint he voice that Dev
blackmailing Geet & she unable to tell him..he never doubted Geet
Did u see Maan think that the pic was more than them meeting ? Then why accuse him for not doubting its authenticity
so did i
offense i'm sorry if i sounded rude of defensive here are my thoughts
to what you blamed of to Maan...Yes me too respect your pov but
seriously failed to agree that its only Maan at fault
you got me wrong i never said that maan is wrong, i said that he is taking the things in a wrong manner.
thats ur pov not mine ..i stick to that he had
100% right to know about what was happening around him..isn't thats what
was making Geet too feel guilty to have hidden from him..coz in their
relationship they had promised of truth always ..but Maan got the raw
deal here as all were keeping the truth from him..his own good or not
thats again a diff question..but he was lied to..so he no way is wrong
in accusing her for having not trusted him with truth
There is a fine line between a person being completely wrong and taking the things wrong completely.
and that line is same b/w trust broken & trust questioned...
Relationship is a mutual affair....its never one at mistake here,
its both of them...if Maan is at fault at some places , so is Geet...
I don't think in my post I blamed Geet anywhere at being wrong.
i never said that you are blaming geet-did i?
well i am sorry if i too sound rude.Again i have written what i
have felt and sorry this time cant agree with you 100% like you i too
have a different point of view.
sure i respect it as i too could not get myself to agree with u
forget to pm me for your next awesome post.Its not about maaneet only i
too wanna see how much writing potential do i have in me.
i always pm u dear..as i said i love reading diff perspective & ofcourse the debate it brings