Critics Corner #6 - Page 32

Posted: 13 years ago
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2fJ2moP5c6w&feature=related
What an outstanding scene! SUBTLE and UNDERSTATED
πŸ‘πŸ‘
 
Gaayu, this one will be on my "list"πŸ˜‰
 
Question for my milk booth friends:
 
 
Why are they both not like THIS anymore?
 
The talking, the crying the emotions are SO OTT.
Khanak's crying on seeing him get injured was pure hamming
Shaan's lip was torn, but HT said "sambhalke" "sambhalke"πŸ˜•
Shaan kept massaging his ARM!
Itna strong hai physically........
 
Its not only the lines, the acting is pretty mediocre these days......... unfortunately.
 
They themselves have set themselves to fail
By their own yardstick it doesnt measure up
 
Enjoy the brilliant scene
I will see you all manana
 
 
 
Posted: 13 years ago
Originally posted by aditee


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2fJ2moP5c6w&feature=related
What an outstanding scene! SUBTLE and UNDERSTATED
πŸ‘πŸ‘
 
Gaayu, this one will be on my "list"πŸ˜‰
 
Question for my milk booth friends:
 
 
Why are they both not like THIS anymore?
 
The talking, the crying the emotions are SO OTT.
Khanak's crying on seeing him get injured was pure hamming
Shaan's lip was torn, but HT said "sambhalke" "sambhalke"πŸ˜•
Shaan kept massaging his ARM!
Itna strong hai physically........
 
Its not only the lines, the acting is pretty mediocre these days......... unfortunately.
 
They themselves have set themselves to fail
By their own yardstick it doesnt measure up
 
Enjoy the brilliant scene
I will see you all manana
 
 
 





I think every scene they do we are comparing with the Golden RBO which is in my POV would never come back.

As I earlier said even though actors are sincere in their effort, the treatment and the storyline is not impressive.

It happens in many of the daily soaps. RBO is far better than so many of them by sticking to SHANAK.
No reincarnations,no 20yr or 30 yr leaps like Kekta's serials.πŸ˜†Yes, definitely the quality is reduced but not lost fully.

At the end of the day it is the  director's cut.  






 
Edited by rbofan1 - 13 years ago
Posted: 13 years ago
Hey Vaishu,
How goes it?
I miss that kinda acting yaar
Posted: 13 years ago
 OK......... This is what I sent to my friend last nite....
 
Its about last week's show
It felt like HT WAS THE LEAD and KT was basically doing what was being told
KT just followed him around
It irritated me no end
HT talking to the kids, doing the naarebaazi, stealing the keys, opening the gates
Inciting the kids to distract Khanak on Monday
Canvassing for KT, talking to the gaanv waale, fighting with Mangal
KT just STOOD THERE
 
KT's expressions left a lot to be desired........ during the injury and afterwards 
He seems very self conscious suddenly
He flutters his eye lashes and has a very overly emotional expression on his face
The naturalness and spontaneity is not permanent
It comes and goes
It was there when he spoke to his parents
But when he is around HT, he has a very affected way of acting, talking and walking
Almost as if he is self conscious or thinks he is better than HT
One or the other
 
With Rahul he did good, even with Sam and Duck
But with HT.......... its just not the same KT


 
Posted: 13 years ago
Originally posted by aditee


 OK......... This is what I sent to my friend last nite....
 
Its about last week's show
It felt like HT WAS THE LEAD and KT was basically doing what was being told
KT just followed him around
It irritated me no end
HT talking to the kids, doing the naarebaazi, stealing the keys, opening the gates
Inciting the kids to distract Khanak on Monday
Canvassing for KT, talking to the gaanv waale, fighting with Mangal
KT just STOOD THERE
 
KT's expressions left a lot to be desired........ during the injury and afterwards 
He seems very self conscious suddenly
He flutters his eye lashes and has a very overly emotional expression on his face
The naturalness and spontaneity is not permanent
It comes and goes
It was there when he spoke to his parents
But when he is around HT, he has a very affected way of acting, talking and walking
Almost as if he is self conscious or thinks he is better than HT
One or the other
 
With Rahul he did good, even with Sam and Duck
But with HT.......... its just not the same KT

 

Actually Ad...I completely disagree, it has been my contention that KT takes a loooong time to get comfortable with his co-stars in terms of 'reacting' or even evoke a 'reaction' from his co-actors. KT was never good with any of the suck brigade. The only time I could even watch a scene with any one of the suck brigade in it was when YM shared the screen space with them. In fact, KT is fantastic with boo, akki, mad , sunil and daadi...fabulous that chemistry and those scenes are hajaar watchable ....but the suck brigade and KT IMO  nah!!!! In fact the only scenes that were watchable were ones where music played a key role....gosh dont even remember..thats how memorable that was....πŸ˜†

As for your thing on HT hogging over KT. I would not really put it down as that honestly...of course, I must admit have missed quite a few episodes but I liked the scene where Shaan hits and gets hit up while Anand is being held by the villagers, IMO, the CVs were trying to show the demarcation in their 'roles' in this track...as for overshining, well I shall keep my eyes peeled for that...from now...

I am a bit disturbed with the constant marriage references with regard to Anand....frankly I am in NO MOOD for another love entry for Anand...rather show me Pankaj Dheer  than some woman for Anand ....seriously!!!!!
Edited by saaaz - 13 years ago
Posted: 13 years ago
No worries saaz
 
Just MO Really!
 
There is something missing some where
 
I see it, I dont expect everyone to!πŸ˜ƒ
Posted: 13 years ago
Of course Ad...I know that ...just saying your MO and my MO deephrence.....πŸ˜‰πŸ˜ƒ

See the thing is it is now standard MO with the CVS of this show after two disjointed episodes, they  bring us one decent one....

I want to now check out whether the decent episode can at least be related back to the disjointed ones...in the sense, do they have to go through disjointedness to come to some semblence of direction with respect to story...

I have now officially given up on looking for golden RBO in this RBO....the CV team is not the same, its obvious...
Posted: 13 years ago
Not sure if it was just sound bytes or if she meant it but YM had said in her interview that "Its been a long time since ShaNak had a song shoot, so they should have one"
 
I FULLY agree!
 
The last one was the SR nite and then ofcourse there was Tera Ziqr
 
But it was quite forgettable, actually
 
I am ready for one, I hope SWJ gives in to us and shoots one to commemorate 250 episodes
Posted: 13 years ago
did they do any celebrations for 250? i mean on the sets or something?
Posted: 13 years ago
Guys don reminisce abt d Golden Rbo days...it was BENCHMARK nt only 4 d show Bt aso fr d Actors....nd i song dat cmes 2 my mind 4 all dis "chod aaye hum woh galiya"frm Maachis...

Related Topics

No Related topics found

Topic Info

30 Participants 1177 Replies 41311Views

Topic started by -Veena-

Last replied by -Veena-

loader
loader
up-open TOP