Critics Corner #6 - Page 13 | Rang Badalti Odhani

142958

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

@Krish,

Thanks for catching that totally inappropriate remark "defective piece"

Khanak has NEVER really cried!😲

where did THAT come from?😕

Yep, it was a totally lame attempt to make Shaan seem spontaneous and introduce some nok-jhok CV style

Very poor!

3

Reply

Quote

142958

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

Thanks Krish, Yumna, Doc D and Jess for responding to my Qs

Will read again and respond carefully.

My next question is:

If Shanak are present

Show's being shot in "Dhulwadi"

Mangal is there

Rock on is gone

WHAT is MISSING?

Why do we feel this void then?

Edited by aditee - 13 years ago

3

Reply

Quote

142958

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

Simi,

Good to see you on CC

Please keep posting

There is a lot of matching of minds here!😃

I love your writing!

2

Reply

Quote

142958

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

This content was originally posted by: kubare
@ Good night ladies...Dyo, Yumna, Jess *muwah* sweet dreams all...will be leaving too for the night...

@Simi darling...*hugs* its great to see you here...loved all that you said

Khanak having long painted nails bothers me too alot....unatural

Here wearing her golden high heels in village bothers me even more...

Khanak with short nails ...flat sandles, mojri/khusa what ever you call them, real hair, decent clothes...disappeared with the introduction of RO

And yes that defective piece dialgue was supposed to be funny...but CV's just couldn't bring that old touch and..it fell flat...

👏👏in Blue

Khanak's whole entire appearance.......... the less said the better!

YM has been very honest and upfront in inviting constructive criticism👏

I havent once seen a note like that from KT

I wonder why our feedback continues to fall on deaf ears😲

3

Reply

Quote

Simi

@simikr

IF-Rockerz

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

This content was originally posted by: aditee
Simi,
Good to see you on CC

Please keep posting

There is a lot of matching of minds here!😃

I love your writing!

Thanks dear, same here!!😃

I somehow don't see all epis on a regular basis..but did the last 2..curiosity factor!😆

But feel that there's a lot of artificiality here, a lot of disconnect, a lot of sweeping under the carpet and it'll disappear...!!😡

Wish the Cvs could read the comments here at CC and know that we are not dumb, nor blind..we want quality and not quantity!!😊

Edited by simiv - 13 years ago

4

Reply

Quote

Simi

@simikr

IF-Rockerz

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

This content was originally posted by: aditee
Thanks Krish, Yumna, Doc D and Jess for responding to my Qs
Will read again and respond carefully.

My next question is:

If Shanak are present

Show's being shot in "Dhulwadi"

Mangal is there

Rock on is gone

WHAT is MISSING?

Why do we feel this void then?

</div>
<div>

The essence is missing, the subtlety is missing, the thought behind each scene is missing, the story is missing!!😡

They think that they'll give us anything and we'll lap it up..no we are like elephants there...long memories ( we'll always compare the new with the old!)😆

Why are serious issues being raised and given such casual treatment? Don't get it..

Edited by simiv - 13 years ago

3

Reply

Quote

142958

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

This content was originally posted by: simiv

</div>
<div>

The essence is missing, the subtlety is missing, the thought behind each scene is missing, the story is missing!!😡

They think that they'll give us anything and we'll lap it up..no we are like elephants there...long memories ( we'll always compare the new with the old!)😆

Why are serious issues being raised and given such casual treatment? Don't get it..

Tomorrow if they decide to give Rahul and Jenny more footage, and they decide to move the story to Mumbai, we cant do a thing abt it

We will have TWO things to wonder abt then.............

First the MMS issue that brought them to Dhulwadi

Next the unfinished factory and the bandoned school and when they return to Mumbai

Its almost like, they must come in to work everyday and wonder "Aaj raat ko kya screen karna hai?"

"Chalo aaj yeh shoot karte hain"

3

Reply

Quote

vaish_123

@vaish_123

Goldie

Posted: 13 years ago

This content was originally posted by: aditee
Thanks Krish, Yumna, Doc D and Jess for responding to my Qs
Will read again and respond carefully.

My next question is:

If Shanak are present

Show's being shot in "Dhulwadi"

Mangal is there

Rock on is gone

WHAT is MISSING?

Why do we feel this void then?

The treatment is missing. In daily soaps sometimes we don't find logic. But given proper treatment to the storyline and the characters they can convince the viewers.

Edited by rbofan1 - 13 years ago

2

Reply

Quote

Simi

@simikr

IF-Rockerz

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

@ Aditee!😆

You made me laugh but so true, exactly what I was thinking, I think the main story was over lets say before the prolonged ILU part?...after that it has been just like you said..they toss a few ideas in the air and pick one and make a mess of it!! 😆

You'd wonder why they keep coming here asking for ideas? is this interactive television?...😕

1

Reply

Quote

Simi

@simikr

IF-Rockerz

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

This content was originally posted by: rbofan1

The treatment is missing. In daily soaps sometimes we don't find logic. But given proper treatment to the storyline and the characters they can convince the viewers.

Well said!!👏👏👏

2

Reply

Quote