Pratigya

India-Forums

   
Pratigya
Pratigya

Viewer's Review's, Previews..29th March pg 148 (Page 102)

corvette IF-Rockerz
corvette
corvette

Joined: 06 June 2006
Posts: 5266

Posted: 18 March 2011 at 7:31am | IP Logged
The only reason we have these discussions is because of the loopholes left by the CVs, the lack of time and consideration put into plots and developing good stories and the stagnant characters themeselves who are shown making mistakes whichis fine, but notlearning from them- which is not.
 
Sometimes I wonder if this show would be better off not being shown 5 times a week.....maybe if it was less, the POPs could actually concentrate on quality rather than compromised drivel
 
                            

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

AlwayshopefulhussainramsoMERARAI

HamiSky IF-Sizzlerz
HamiSky
HamiSky

Joined: 07 June 2010
Posts: 10194

Posted: 18 March 2011 at 7:33am | IP Logged
Originally posted by Madmadgirl

The only reason we have these discussions is because of the loopholes left by the CVs, the lack of time and consideration put into plots and developing good stories and the stagnant characters themeselves who are shown making mistakes whichis fine, but notlearning from them- which is not.
 
Sometimes I wonder if this show would be better off not being shown 5 times a week.....maybe if it was less, the POPs could actually concentrate on quality rather than compromised drivel
 
                            

 
MMG :-)))))
there are people who are asking for MKAP seven days a week :-)))))))

serious note...one day show is very good next day it falters badly...
i mean i understand its very difficult to give very good episodes daily but y not at least watchable ones....average ones...interesting fillers...

The following 5 member(s) liked the above post:

AlwayshopefulhussainramsoMERARAI-Sheena-babithaj

-Sheena- IF-Sizzlerz
-Sheena-
-Sheena-

Joined: 06 July 2010
Posts: 17603

Posted: 18 March 2011 at 7:34am | IP Logged
Originally posted by tanthya

Originally posted by Madmadgirl

Cant  believe I wasted a precious 20 mins of my life watching this drivel....

First off this Kesar ki mai - what a wasted opportunity! 

You know there was real scope here; Kesar's character, that of a quiet, cultured albeit obedient bahu could have had a mai just like her, someone with an air of dignified serenity, a mai overwhelmed to see her daughter who she hadnt seen for ages, a tender, loving character...

instead we get this excuse for a comedian.....rubbish!

Would it have done the show any harm if the mai was a decent character? 
Or is it the case that this would have detracted from the most important characters in the show......like the Saxena family!Dead Give me a break!

Finally Krishna.....this character is being compromised seriously

Yeah we all know he is a lazy scumbag, but you know when difficult situations come up, situations of conflict, more often than not he always goes on his walks on that bloody dusty windy road and  takes his time to think about stuff.....before reaching conclusions

What we are seeing now though is not right...he clearly has a troubled conscience, is struggling to maintain any poise because he is aware of his wrongdoings but rather than introspect, take some time out to consider his next steps, he is shown in the pre-cap to tell P she has to be a homemaker and not an earner

Not good, for many reasons, but most because it defies the Krishna that always sides with what is right. P kept to her side of the bargain, but K appears to be going back on it. I really dont like this Krishna, because this zidd on his part of P needing to be home doing chores makes him weak and feeble in my eyes, when we know he is strong and has been a real dhaal for P, whenever P speaks sense, he backs her, supports her

But this Krishna is a wimp and not very likeable at all...

The balance at the TNs needs to be redressed - too many idiots and grey-shaded characters, not enough good guys or neutrals.....

I'm cool with K and P being at loggerheads, but I also want to see characters develop and K has done more than P in this regard, so please stop K going backwards again....


Join The club , MMG ...

@ Bold..agree


I think for the CVs it is easier to compromise K's character than to work on P's character...It takes less effort on their part....

As for development of characters, it wont happen because it is a story based on a strong woman...I am still wondering what is  the definition of strong woman though??? Because P is not woman's right advocate, nor does she stand for right or wrong at all cost...


The following 5 member(s) liked the above post:

corvettea_umaMERARAIhussainramsotanthya

tanthya IF-Addictz
tanthya
tanthya

Joined: 24 July 2009
Posts: 52575

Posted: 18 March 2011 at 7:37am | IP Logged
Originally posted by Madmadgirl

The only reason we have these discussions is because of the loopholes left by the CVs, the lack of time and consideration put into plots and developing good stories and the stagnant characters themeselves who are shown making mistakes whichis fine, but notlearning from them- which is not.
 
Sometimes I wonder if this show would be better off not being shown 5 times a week.....maybe if it was less, the POPs could actually concentrate on quality rather than compromised drivel
 
                            


I prefer 3 day ..with content and standard...

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

corvette-Sheena-

-Sheena- IF-Sizzlerz
-Sheena-
-Sheena-

Joined: 06 July 2010
Posts: 17603

Posted: 18 March 2011 at 7:39am | IP Logged
Originally posted by Madmadgirl

The only reason we have these discussions is because of the loopholes left by the CVs, the lack of time and consideration put into plots and developing good stories and the stagnant characters themeselves who are shown making mistakes whichis fine, but notlearning from them- which is not.
 
Sometimes I wonder if this show would be better off not being shown 5 times a week.....maybe if it was less, the POPs could actually concentrate on quality rather than compromised drivel
 
                            


I think as much as it is the CVs responsibility it is up to the actors themselves to try and hide the loopholes left by the CVs...Each character can gather some sympathy from their POV but because they fail to engage the audience we criticise them more...

I seriously think we are meant to look through Saxes POV as they were meant to be every middle class family but the lack of acting has not helped in the storytelling..

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

babithaj

tanthya IF-Addictz
tanthya
tanthya

Joined: 24 July 2009
Posts: 52575

Posted: 18 March 2011 at 7:40am | IP Logged
Originally posted by starlight123

Originally posted by tanthya

Originally posted by Madmadgirl

Cant  believe I wasted a precious 20 mins of my life watching this drivel....

First off this Kesar ki mai - what a wasted opportunity! 

You know there was real scope here; Kesar's character, that of a quiet, cultured albeit obedient bahu could have had a mai just like her, someone with an air of dignified serenity, a mai overwhelmed to see her daughter who she hadnt seen for ages, a tender, loving character...

instead we get this excuse for a comedian.....rubbish!

Would it have done the show any harm if the mai was a decent character? 
Or is it the case that this would have detracted from the most important characters in the show......like the Saxena family!Dead Give me a break!

Finally Krishna.....this character is being compromised seriously

Yeah we all know he is a lazy scumbag, but you know when difficult situations come up, situations of conflict, more often than not he always goes on his walks on that bloody dusty windy road and  takes his time to think about stuff.....before reaching conclusions

What we are seeing now though is not right...he clearly has a troubled conscience, is struggling to maintain any poise because he is aware of his wrongdoings but rather than introspect, take some time out to consider his next steps, he is shown in the pre-cap to tell P she has to be a homemaker and not an earner

Not good, for many reasons, but most because it defies the Krishna that always sides with what is right. P kept to her side of the bargain, but K appears to be going back on it. I really dont like this Krishna, because this zidd on his part of P needing to be home doing chores makes him weak and feeble in my eyes, when we know he is strong and has been a real dhaal for P, whenever P speaks sense, he backs her, supports her

But this Krishna is a wimp and not very likeable at all...

The balance at the TNs needs to be redressed - too many idiots and grey-shaded characters, not enough good guys or neutrals.....

I'm cool with K and P being at loggerheads, but I also want to see characters develop and K has done more than P in this regard, so please stop K going backwards again....


Join The club , MMG ...

@ Bold..agree


I think for the CVs it is easier to compromise K's character than to work on P's character...It takes less effort on their part....

As for development of characters, it wont happen because it is a story based on a strong woman...I am still wondering what is  the definition of strong woman though??? Because P is not woman's right advocate, nor does she stand for right or wrong at all cost...





We can break our heads over this , Star ...but we will never get an answer..

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

-Sheena-

corvette IF-Rockerz
corvette
corvette

Joined: 06 June 2006
Posts: 5266

Posted: 18 March 2011 at 7:47am | IP Logged
Originally posted by tanthya

Originally posted by Madmadgirl

The only reason we have these discussions is because of the loopholes left by the CVs, the lack of time and consideration put into plots and developing good stories and the stagnant characters themeselves who are shown making mistakes whichis fine, but notlearning from them- which is not.
 
Sometimes I wonder if this show would be better off not being shown 5 times a week.....maybe if it was less, the POPs could actually concentrate on quality rather than compromised drivel
 
                            


I prefer 3 day ..with content and standard...
 
wahi to.....lubb this show too much to see it drivel-ised!!!
As you can see, it is a currently favourite word!Big smile

The following 4 member(s) liked the above post:

AlwayshopefulhussainramsoMERARAI-Sheena-

dhakarn IF-Sizzlerz
dhakarn
dhakarn

Joined: 16 May 2010
Posts: 15504

Posted: 18 March 2011 at 7:47am | IP Logged
Originally posted by starlight123

Originally posted by dhakarn

Originally posted by tanthya


Absolutely....It would have been better had they shown what happens to  Adarsh or the growing nexus between SS n  Adarsh ..instead we  are saddled with a bigoted Dadi  ..who  without any second thoughts  spits venom ...If Komal had to beg forgiveness for pushing Aarushi..then by the same token , would it be inappropriate of Amma , in expecting P to fall at her feet..Looking   From Amma's POV..here was her BD ..all broken down ..and nursing her wounds quietly , when a young woman , who has no business in meddling in other people's life  ,

Pratigya is not meddling in other peoples business..........she is doing what is right...........correcting a wrong.........if every individual will be selfish and don't care what's happening around him in the world and to the mankind , then what would become of the world............if every person just pass along when an accident happens or when he sees someone hitting his wife brutally, or a girl being raped, or someone being murdered be it whatever reason, where stands the humanity............what is the value of  human life if u can't help the needy at the right place and time...........oh, u must wait till the man/women/child begs for ur help, and most importantly u must ask them whether they need ur help or not before making urself a fool , is that the philosophy of mankind?...............if mother Teressa chooses to ignore every child thrown in a dustbin, what would have happened?  why r we repeatedly seeing court meddling in some cases ? can't the court leave the victims alone? why r we hearing of many persons who complains  against atrocities happening in their colony or locality or even in their neighbors house......why can't they leave the society to whatever is happening and be selfish and mind ones own business........? no, bec good men/women can't sit back and relax when wrong is happening in front of their eyes........they will react in a way which seems appropriate to them otherwise the whole point of mankind is lost goes about and brings a police to  arrest ..what was essentially a Ghar ka mamla , has turned to Ghar ka beizzat ..and Amma would be having a hissy fit ///quite natural for her to expect Pratigya to apologize  ofcourse and we saw pratigya doing as she was told even though she didn't do anything wrong on calling the police .. amma killed a child in a women's womb ! ! !  since it is her hubby's food that she is eating, her huuby's money that clothes her, her hubby's house that shelters her ... 

And pratigya going against the one who is feeding and dressing her......we all see how many cases r registered with parents torturing/abusing their children and owners their maid servants......so what should these people do......? Children should not open their mouth bec its ur parents who r torturing u ........they have every right to do so , bec they brought u into the world, they give u food shelter ........and ofcourse the servants r not to raise a voice in protest to whatever atrocities they r subjected to , why bec they r ue masters, they provide u food and shelter ............Ouch




and again Why should Komal beg forgiveness..as she correctly pointed out..it takes 2 hands to clap...It was Aarushi who first got physical and Komal retaliated ...  and as Komal said it quite succintly, it does hurt when ppl say u r uneducated and bumpkin..when Aarushi said that , I actually wanter Komal to come up with the Shakthi blunder and ask how did education help her in her decision making in this instance...but then we do know that Sax are the fav's of CV's...

As for arushi , she only tried to stop komal when she was literally dragging a child by hand .........wouldn't anyone do it? Arushi didn't attack komal when komal was sleeping or was having fun..................komal should ask for forgiveness from the children for ruining their books and manhandling them

                                                                       



 Will Adarsh remain the golden boy or will he turn the protector of Komal ....hope they deal with him and not Dadi...


Dhakarn,

There is something in correcting the wrong but there is also showing to be responsible in correcting the wrong...You never, and I mean never take the abused back to the abuser after a complaint is made......This is not showing the right way but highlighting the wrong...For women to take a stand they should be aware of the various options available to them...Here they showed nothing in helping women but made them as clueless as before...






there is also a need to get the story move forward with a lot of drama....................for drama purpose kesar should be at TN, there is no other way.............we should blame it on CVs..........but why r we blaming Pratigya when all she does is trying to correct a wrong............in that case P brought Kesar back to TN bec that's her sasuraal and also there is SS to take care of her.........P doesn't know that SS is also included in the plan.............and its his responsibility to take care of his DIL who is illtreated by his son ans wife............so P bringing kesar back to TN is perfectly logical...........she can help kesar fight for her rights, but she can't decide on her fate.........its up to either kesar or up to SS who is the parent and guardian of kesar at the moment...............we saw P protesting SS's forceful decision to keep kesar at TN when she wanted to go away from there........if SS had decided to make kesar stay with her consent then P wouldn't have protested........ also she would have supported SS if kesar wanted to stay at TN...............

Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Author Replies Views Last Post
u me aur tv replies to d viewers mails

Author: monika.   Replies: 9   Views: 1354

monika. 9 1354 23 April 2010 at 2:00am by monika.
Pratigya Celebration - 17th march

Author: luv_kriya   Replies: 0   Views: 615

luv_kriya 0 615 02 April 2010 at 4:35am by luv_kriya
Pratigya written Update 31st March 2010

2

Author: --Anna--   Replies: 14   Views: 3887

--Anna-- 14 3887 31 March 2010 at 10:39pm by Heerbeauty
31st March

2 3 4

Author: Xxxjrae   Replies: 26   Views: 1567

Xxxjrae 26 1567 31 March 2010 at 4:22pm by daisyluv

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Pratigya Topic Index

  • Please login to check your Last 10 Topics posted

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index