Originally posted by nureat01
@Elysia: So basically all your arguments about Madhu are based on that one single scene when she fed him....what about all that came before that? The way her character entered the show and overnight started planning DN's second wedding?
Lol. When did she plan his second wedding? That was already in the works. All she did was say that she didn't get why Nakku called him Saab and AS intervened, planning to call the pandit and everything.
No, all my arguments aren't based on that one scene, but it was an essential scene regarding their relationship. In fact, it was the most essential scene between them, in my opinion.
Is there no such thing as ESTABLISHMENT of character in a GRADUAL form? That too for such a supposedly important character. Overnight she's in love with everyone and expects everyone to love her.....
That's your interpretation of her. I don't see it as her wanting everyone to love her overnight. That's a bit extreme, don't you think?
Maybe it's just me but that doesn't quite cut it when it comes to "caring" in my books....
Rushed emotions without a sense of establishment are superficial in my books.
How was there no sense of establishment? When Dutta found out who his real father was, there were emotions that awakened inside of him. Just like there were emotions awakening inside of him when Madhu came in and AS established the fact that she was his sister.
Secondly, your other criteria for judging Madhu is strictly based on comparing her to the evil trio? So just cuz she's not "evil" like the other three, she automatically becomes genuine?
Gosh. My conclusion is also based on her actions, like I've mentioned already
Why is this "genuineness" to her only being seen in comparison to K-L-R? Why are they the only benchmark to judge? Why not look at her character with individual standing? What does Madhu have to offer as an INDIVIDUAL among these characters in the show? Please mention something OTHER than the fact that she cares for Dutta....we've been beaten over the head with that great thought by Madhu herself announcing it 24/7.
Um, how about that she's honest and respectful without having any bad intentions?
As for your question....what makes me think that she keeps childishly demanding for Dutta's love? LOL now if only I had the time to dig through the last 3 months of episodes and find every moment when she's been running after Dutta crying "bhaiyya bhaiyya" or running after AS crying "mumma mumma".....
That's an exaggeration, but okay. Let's say that she's been doing that a lot. Is that so weird? Considering the fact that she's been alone for years and now suddenly she has a whole family from which only three or four people actually want to communicate with her?
.... I don't see anything in her character.
Your loss. Well, okay, all depending on how you look at it
And btw for Roops....in that moment, the storyline was at a different place.....but anyways, the general consensus in this forum does not want to consider Roops as a character from a redemption angle....redemption is only reserved for Dutta since he has a pure soul inside....Roops is a spoilt, evil brat....she doesn't deserve anything in this show.....Madhu is "genuine", "positive", "deserving" all cuz of ONE scene....hmmm
Again with this "one scene" thing. Lol. Like I said, let's just agree to disagree on this one