[QUOTE=akhilha]Thanks Bani.....Please keep posting...You are truly amazing in perceiving things and also u back up ur reasoning with your knowledge,,V enlightening!! Nowadays i come to the forum just to read your views....so please dont disappoint me!!
Thanks for your kind words! Actually, I like the way you are trying to analyse the characters, instead of arbitrarily following favourites.
Love and hate both are dangerous emotions when they are very intense......Hate sometimes springs up from love...Dejected love!!
Hate roots from some unexpected events from a very loved one. Like the person who might have been very close to her, if that person does not meet our expectations, that results in disappointment and can turn into hate gradually. Very often, we find best of best stop talking and if the problem is not solved, they dont talk ever after and that becomes a feud.
I feel Viren Loved Sid very much when they were young ....
You have got a point, and thats the reason he is so mad at him. His love for his elder brother turned into hatred, as he did not stand up for him.
And Sid never reciprocated coz he was so attached to Putul....
And may be even if Nivi is not directly involved....Sids involvement with Nivi might have created some insecurities in him as achild..
Sid and Putul wre childhood best friends.
and Sid could have stopped him from being sent away and he didnt!!.And i also feel From a young age Viren was a rebel and always voiced out his displeasure whereas Sid kept quite and saw His mom being illtreated etc without showing his anger...even when growing up!!!
Sid's and Viren's nature are very different. One is calm and quiet and another rebellious, like a typical elder and younger brother.
I think Viren started hating Sid coz he would never stand up for any one he loved....Be it Viren.Vandana and now Nivi.....So Viren feels utter disgust and hatred Coz he feels Sid just stands and sees the tamasha...Though he knows that such horrible things are happening in front of his eyes,,,he does not have the courage to voice out!!
Yeh, true. He failed to act miserably at places, sometime circumstance is against him and sometime he lets circumstance rule him. Thats his biggest flaw. But about Nivi, I feel sometimes, husband wife have worst fights, that does not mean they would leave each other or divorce each other after one fight.
This is from Virens point of view!!!Becoz the way he utters''Nivi bolegi...TU KItna kamina hai..Siddharth Sood!!!!
This also shows like you said that his expectations were hurt by Sid and then Nivi supported Sid, not Viren. These are childhood incidents, when they were 6 or 7 years old, but still he remembers that.
He also gave lots of opportunities For Sid to really speak out his mind...But Sid didnt....Atleast in Nivis case .....
I feel Sid if could not talk to DS about JW, at least could do something for Keshav, just as a token of "rectifying the family's mistake".
So i think He started planning all this ..So that Sid will burst open ..If u observe..He is trying to put Sid down In Nivis eyes First,.....And then others thru her!!No property is involved here...no other motives also!! It is to prove..... that he stalked Nivi.....Why????Coz he loved her..Almost married her And left her ,,,For what????Coz his family wanted...Coz nivi wanted....Whatever the reason..I think Viren wants Him to repent For that!!Not that VIren LOves Nivi...He does not..But becoz of sids attitude towards his loved ones....that is what he hates!!
There is no question of Viren loving Nivi or Viren being after the property. He wants to see Sid lose everything and he wants Sid to be blamed by Nivi only, Sid's one time biggest friend and admirer.
It is his whole attitude which Viren hates more than the person himself.....What he gains if his plan succeeds????He gains the satisfaction of Seeing Sid falling from his Throne to the ground and face the wrath of his so called wife....His mother and Loss of respect from dadaji...Yd..
Viren derives mental satisfaction.
IN this whole process..Viren might end up losing Nivi ....He is ready even for that..NOW!! But what he doesnt know is he will suffer the most when Nivi and Sid are suffering...Seeing their lives were totally ruined coz of him and his parents!! He will repent!!
till this moment, he does not care, whether Nivi stays or goes. But when Nivi leaves, he will feel her absence. In the process of hurting Sid, he is actually hurting himself also.
Sids love for Nivi is strong and pure,,,And Nivi too cannot hurt Him !! So this is where His plan will start failing...Coz once Nivi starts suspecting that Viren might be involved.....It will all go haywire!! In the whole process ..A Guy who never believed in love will start believing in that emotion......He will become a whole new person who will start having faith..faith in good things!!
I think while digging the past, he himself will see that Nivi actually can never go against Sid, if she finds out Sid is innocent. Nivi many years back also, if she supported Sid, it could be that Sid was not at fault. But they were kids, who knows, could be it was Sid's fault, as Viren is thinking. Also, he will see that actually just like him, Sid and Vandana, Nivi and Keshav had suffered at the hands of his parents. He will try to rectify that and will transform into a good human.
excellent analysis! a pleasure to read and discuss with you
Edited by Omshanti1111 - 21 January 2011 at 12:31pm