Posted: 17 January 2011 at 3:32am | IP Logged
Originally posted by Chill_OutRes!
First of all lovely topic!! I do beg to differ on certain points but mostly, it was a much needed topic so thanks a bunch for making it!!
So coming to Abhay humiliating Pia, I didn't really have an 'issue issue' with it, I just didn't get the point. Abhay was asking Pia to stay away from him when that was exactly what she was doing! So it was just ironical, that's all.
Coming to Pia acting as Maithili, I won't say I approve of it because come on, Maithili did mean a lot to Abhay and tricking him even for a bit is a little...I don't know....mean?? But then again, Pia does have no choice! She has to do this for the sake of everything going on around them and this was the last resort! She did try other things, didn't she?? It's not like she straightaway did something like this! So keeping everything in mind, even I really don't see an issue in this. I seriously feel that people are overreacting! I mean, with due respects, I know what AM went through and Pia does deserve criticism but now what she's getting is much more than deserves these days. I mean come on, we've known ever since the Danish track that maturity is not one of Pia's strengths! She's always been the kinds who doesn't think before acting and she's a Curious Connie and we accepted her with that, right?? So what happened now?
People have gone on to question her love to the extent of that it can NEVER be as much as Maithili's! Firstly, it's totally wrong to even compare!! That's an insult to both of them! Secondly, if they'd said that so far it's not like Maithili's, I would've understood. Right now, it's not the selfless love of Maithili but the obsessive love of a teenager so I can understand that Maithili's love was stronger as of now. But being futuristic and saying it can 'never' even match up to Maithili's love is plain wrong! I have not seen this in one but numerous posts and almost the entire forum saying so. And it's saddening! Since everyone's done it, so I might as well be futuristic too! We all know that Pia will accept Abhay even after knowing his truth right? Obviously! That's what the show is about! So seriously, how can people even question the love of the firefly who'll willingly get burnt by the fire just so that she can be with him??! I've only raised this argument because the word 'never' had been used. And if people still doubt whether Pia will ever love Abhay the way Maithili did, then I have nothing more to say to them!
So, even I love how this track has been handled. Keeping everything aside, it is interesting and intriguing!!
Off topic: Quite a few of my pretty close friends who are AbhIya fans are sad because they feel that AM are being portrayed as some kind of an epic and AbhIya will never be able to surpass them. I will just like to say that AbhIya need not surpass them because they'll be an epic in their own way! Don't be sad by the way AM are portrayed. They were an amazing couple and their love was great and the same thing will happen with AbhIya. Though I still have my doubts about Abhay being able to love Pia the way he loved Maithili specially because her face resembles Maithili's but still, AbhIya will create history just like AM did. I trust Ekta that much! So chill people and stop making mountains out of molehills!
Whew!! Forgive me if I sounded too frustrated but then, I was frustrated!
Thnx for the great reply
well,as for Piya maturity act...i beg to differ.....thats exactly one other point i dont get eaither...among the charcters on the show she is on of the most mature ones alongside Abhay.
she handled the 'mission expose Danish' really well, whit each step and suspect she had alongside the way, the signs her sharp eyes concluded that maybe noone else would notice that fats....in the end of it , itcould have been better but to drag the track and make everyone againts Piya, mainly to develop the abhiya track the creatives made some twists, no so good ones in all aspects in my oppinion....like how the 'phone issue' was easily
solved by misha and that guy....while the same way could been taken care of by Abhay and Piya...ok lets say Piya didnt know anyone to go to, but Abhay??..how did it not occur to his mind with all his contacts and stuff
....and at the end Maya all of a sudden just bumped in...'i have decided to talk' after all she let AbhahPiya go through....it was kind of weird in some aspects....however, its over now, so all good
...and Piya never keept agony of anyone inside even if their suspison and humiliation of her gave her right to do.....hence another sign of her maturity.
true, the way its going is not the best way.....but then again this ups and downs are the imp intresting aspects of Abhay Piya.....no other way is left from creatives POV.....so be it...
reason of overacting
is .....we as girls are the 'other' Piya's sitting on the other side of the screen not able to handle this lonliness and pain of Abhay mainly, thus....the frustration results in attacking anything thats close to the H of Hurt when it comes to him....so its natural....we expect Piya doing all she does in the most correct way possible as a saint....since she is kind of 'our' representerswho wants the best for the our guy
....and who are 'we'?......viewers knowing all the truth....and hidden sides of Abhay....that Piya hasnt been able or got the chance to see yet....
this results that we to some extent forget to see the actuall pain even Piya is in of this deep confusion, lonliness and strong connection.
and well, abt the AM and AP oppionons....dont put much thaught on it....whit time and developmnet in their story we will clearly see the creatives point of all this.....its however really great too see that both the aspect of AM and AP are growing to a strong extent in viewers eyes....its not always that happens...well guess we have to thank ViSu for that....i love both sides
and that 'Never'...will real fast be replaced by 'she will always Love him' as the truth comes out and he gives in:).....its instant reaction based on momentary storyline:).....exaclty as one day ppl were....does Abhay really love her?....and the other day....'He loves her so much'
Edited by ..Mari.. - 17 January 2011 at 3:35am