Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee

India-Forums

   
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee

One Question-Looking for Honest & sincere Answer (Page 7)

jshaila IF-Dazzler

Joined: 01 June 2005
Posts: 2957

Posted: 14 January 2011 at 6:21am | IP Logged
THE ACCOUNT OF THE MEMBER WHO POSTED THIS MESSAGE HAS BEEN TEMPORARILY BANNED.

If you think this is an error please Contact us.

rickks IF-Sizzlerz
rickks
rickks

Joined: 26 December 2007
Posts: 23819

Posted: 14 January 2011 at 7:45am | IP Logged
Originally posted by --Nargis--

I feel that there such a STARK difference between yesterday's (1/12) episode and today's episode.(1/13)Ouch
I agree.....The Change was very Much PalpableOuch

Yesterday was a LOT content wise...but if was delivered FLAWLESSLY...a very COHESIVE delivery.....made me want to watch the show with the same enthusiasm again.....so of course i was so thrilled to watch the episode today.....but what a let down.
I assume you are talking about 12th January as the more Flawlessly delivered Episode to which i agree wholeheartedly and 13th January which was the Major Let Down

Today's episode was missing the DHASU delivery that i was looking for.   Haldi scene was good....but not GREAT as I had expected it to be.  I don't think its the actor's fault...i blame the DIRECTOR.  It his job to demand...and persuade the best out of the actors.....and that is where the lack is.
Yes the scene was tanda...Not that Maaneet did not do their part well, there could have been differently and brilliantly portrayed and executed which was entirely Missing.....

This serial is missing a GRIPPING storyline....plz..isse jaldi waapis lao.  The MOMENTS have brought it this far....but it cannot continue for long.
Like the age old say.....one major aspect that adds to the success of the show is when there are moments in a story and not moments which are created for a story....what happens with the latter is it eventually dies outDead

Phele yeh moments Nissar package karke brilliantly deliver karta tha....and that was enough to keep us temped and attached to the screen.  But now, without Nissar, these moments are but a TEPID rendition of the same moments again and again.....causing me excessive BOREDOM!!

Nags i agree the Midas Touch one could see in the scenes/Seq which screamed out that it was Nissar's work is Missing....But at last the show is a team work and 1 person should not be held responsible for what happens.....I just wish that a story and screenplay had something to offer so that even if the direction went for a Toss WE COULD IGNORE IT

Recently ...the episodes are missing the NISSAR charm...and today was definitely not a  Nissar delivery at all.

NT was good....but again the delivery of the content was lacking....it should have made more of an impact....and it did not.
NT is one of the most classiest Vamp i have ever seen in Tellyworld....A mind-boggling character to be created ever in recent times, but what she did yesterday did nothing....i could not believe that this was the same character whom we used to rave about and consider an almost perfect Opponent to MAAN

Her threat to Geet on killing Maan.....that should have chilled my bones...but it didn't...it felt blah!!
Ouch




Nags my editions in Green and sweets you know that i feel the same, and this si the very reason i had to vent it out....The Post being a source

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

sindu_gurti

sksg Goldie
sksg
sksg

Joined: 06 August 2010
Posts: 2245

Posted: 14 January 2011 at 12:36pm | IP Logged
My answers in blue.

Originally posted by rickks

Hey Guys.....Today i am making an unusual Post....Its a Question thats been in my head for the last few days....and what better place to share this thought other than the Geet ForumSmile

Do you feel the show is losing its Charm??? Yes, compared to the episodes of June/July 2010

Do you feel that a Gripping Story/Screenplay is Missing??? Som
etimes it comes back for a day or two, sometimes a minute or 2, but it is not present consistently.

Do you feel all the Maaneet moments that have been shown recently looks lifeless and repetitive in terms of Direction and Execution??? There are few moments that are unique and magical, but their magic is often depleted due to poor editing or stopping for the day at the wrong moment.

Guys as loyal Viewers of GHSP, who has been watching this show religiously..... honestly batao do u still see that Spark, that Magic, that Brilliance which has always been associated with GHSP??? Yes

Hope you guys will pour in your Answers....Do Comment Smile

Note: Please do not take this as an offensive post.....I have no intentions of hurting the sentiments any of the viewers/audience/fans.



 

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

--Nargis--

-Yaz- IF-Rockerz
-Yaz-
-Yaz-

Joined: 06 May 2007
Posts: 5049

Posted: 14 January 2011 at 1:04pm | IP Logged
I agree with PrithviSanyo1, sometimes it really drags and the other times i really like it, it isn't like before where each episode was worth waiting for, now we can hardly tell what the upcoming episodes will be like, good/bad, boring/interesting Ouch 
 
I still like the acting of the main leads and the other side roles (except for Nikunj), i still like the direction, i still like the dialouges, it's just the story i think that is going bit up and down Confused they should also make sure not to be too repetitive, some scenes are nice to watch again like the lap scene, or even the bath tub scene, but the whole staring off into eachothers eyes is getting bit boring, sometimes i feel as if that's the only thing they ever do Ouch
 
The other thing i dislike is how some of the other characters are not getting a good screen space, in the initial days every character had good scenes on every episode, be it Adi, Pinky, Sasha, Tasha, but now it's as if they all have been sidelined, isn't that why Dev and Meera left, because they saw their characters going nowhere Disapprove I don't understand why the CVs are bringing in so many Actors in, if they are not give them a good meaty role, like Romeo, Manisha, and Pandey Ji Confused
 
Why have they bought Annie in? she wasn't ever mentioned and all of a sudden she pops up out of nowhere, why couldn't they bring in Vicky instead, which is logical and to be honest would have been much more interesting.
 
What happened to Dev and Meera? What happened to the case, did they close it or is it still on? Will Dev get his punishment or not.
 
What happened to Sasha? where is she?
 
They are so many things the CVs have left unanswered, and it seems as if they have totally forgotton about it.
 
And another thing like PrithviSanyo1 said, theres too much negitivity, first Arjun, then Brij, then NT, and now the whole thing about Maan going to Jail, it's getting bit too much to handle, they should learn how to balance it out.
 
This is a story about Geet and Maan, but these days it seems as if they are getting overshadowed by Annie and Arjun, which quite frankly is getting really annoying Dead and then theres the whole illogical thing, it's one thing having a small blooper and another to make a stupid mistake, (i'm talking about the hospital scene, where Maan had to choose between the child and the mother)
 
The CVs are doing a great job with other things like the direction and the dialouges, but they should stop and think about where the story is heading Confused I still love Geet, and i am still going to watch it, but the CVs really have to sort some things out.
 
 


Edited by iqbal-pallavi - 14 January 2011 at 1:05pm

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

--Nargis---PoisonIvy-

ibelieveinpink IF-Stunnerz
ibelieveinpink
ibelieveinpink

Joined: 25 September 2006
Posts: 34004

Posted: 14 January 2011 at 1:14pm | IP Logged
Awesome POST!!! So thought-provoking...well done!!! 


Do you feel the show is losing its Charm???
I don't think Maneet are losing their magic, charm, or chemistry, but YES I do think the show is losing it's original charm!! The scenes aren't as gripping as they were in HP, the characters aren't as strong (excluding Maneet) and the storyline lacks the appeal that it once had!! I don't know if it's the writers of the channel, but I'm getting disappointed! 

Do you feel that a Gripping Story/Screenplay is Missing???
Yep!!!! Barring from the Maneet the scenes, the rest is disappointing! AA scenes are just horrible! Brij and NT scenes are really good b/c the actors are top-notch! Even today, I didn't think it was a bad episode, but the guy who plays Arjun isn't as powerful as the actor who plays Brij! Arjun (from my understanding) is suppose to be like Maan in principles and attitude...a little bit of a flawed MSK, but very MSK-esque in terms of personality and aura, but the actor is pulling off character completely wrong! And the whole one will go to jail....sounds too stupid! I don't mind giving the CVs a chance b/c I'm sure the courtroom drama will be nicely written! But this idea isn't appealing! The show def ins't as interesting as it used to be from May-September....post GC's sickness the show has either been a miss or HIT....before it always used to be a HIT!

Do you feel all the Maaneet moments that have been shown recently looks lifeless and repetitive in terms of Direction and Execution???
NOPE! Def not!! The hugs..the whole chin to head is getting old! I think the Disco hug was the best b/c there seemed to be more passion! But the scenes are so mind blowing and fantastic! IMO the maneet scenes are the best part of the show! I love them!! Direction is really good, especially the Mahi mahi dance and the recently haldi scene! Personally, the nok jhoks are getting better and better!

Guys as loyal Viewers of GHSP, who has been watching this show religiously..... honestly batao do u still see that Spark, that Magic, that Brilliance which has always been associated with GHSP???
Nope....the spark is def disappearing! I think bring back the gripping storyline and maybe the original writers b/c these new writers are giving us fantastic Maneet moments, but dull everyone else moments! AA scenes are such a drag! And def hire better actors! I also think this whole wedding thing has been going on for over a month and both are still not married....NOT GOOD! I loved how fast pace the story used to be, and now it's slowed down like no one's business! Also, I think it's time to re-explore HP, Sameera, Vicky, Dev-Maan's actually relationship and the whole Canada family! Plus, how many months preggers is geet and maan's BG and family history! Maybe the story should also explore Maneet in the work environment post-marriage! I would love to see the balance of professional and personal!


The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

-Yaz---Nargis--

ishpreet Goldie
ishpreet
ishpreet

Joined: 20 October 2008
Posts: 1038

Posted: 14 January 2011 at 1:19pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by rickks

Hey Guys.....Today i am making an unusual Post....Its a Question thats been in my head for the last few days....and what better place to share this thought other than the Geet ForumSmile

Do you feel the show is losing its Charm???

Do you feel that a Gripping Story/Screenplay is Missing???

Do you feel all the Maaneet moments that have been shown recently looks lifeless and repetitive in terms of Direction and Execution???

Guys as loyal Viewers of GHSP, who has been watching this show religiously..... honestly batao do u still see that Spark, that Magic, that Brilliance which has always been associated with GHSP???

Hope you guys will pour in your Answers....Do Comment Smile

Note: Please do not take this as an offensive post.....I have no intentions of hurting the sentiments any of the viewers/audience/fans.



 
@rickks
i m telling u this very sincerely
i miss the old geet days when everything and anything was around maan and geet
their tiffs,falling in love and the fresh scenes. but now annie and arjun bakwaas lifeless scesn too much dragging is talking away the charm.
pehle the story changed every single days 2 to 3 promos were released in a single week
it was so much fun
but i have still faith in godBig smile
--Nargis-- IF-Sizzlerz
--Nargis--
--Nargis--

Joined: 17 July 2008
Posts: 13178

Posted: 14 January 2011 at 1:49pm | IP Logged
Nihu...if it is still Nissar....then why such a dichotomy from the earlier deliveries?   What in him has changes that his presentation and delivery have diminished so badly??

Originally posted by -honeydew-

nani, Nissar is brilliant at his work, but i personally feel if things are going bad, its also reflects badly on the fact that the entire team is pinning their hopes on one person, who by the way another human being ...
yes, he owes something to this show, and he needs to give his bit as well, but if Nissar does everything, what the hell are others doing?
i cant feel GC emote anymore the way he did ...
DD is the only other person who has been consistent right from day one ...
last night when NT spoke i was like .. oh shut up you woman ...
Annie and Arjun are just about okay at the moment ...
the show Geet was not made just by Nissar right ? there were so many others ... now suddenly whats going so wrong that, we cant feel the same way about the show ..
and what if Nissar is actually doing his bit, and we expect too much outta him ..LOLLOL


Originally posted by --Nargis--

Originally posted by -pixie-

Do you feel the show is losing its Charm???
>> Yup, the show has been losing its charm for me. For quite some time I have been feeling that something has been amiss. The story has been meandering- its almost as if the writers also dont know what to do with the show.

Do you feel that a Gripping Story/Screenplay is Missing???
>> The biggest problem is that the story/screenplay just went haywire after the engagement fiasco...They do have decent threads of a story running now...but the execution is seriously flawed. If I were to forget the scene and think of it from a story PoV- many of the recent twists sound really interesting- but the execution on screen has absolutely no dum! The only grouse I have with the writers is that they clearly have not watched the old episodes of GHSP- and hence we have new unanncounced tracks rather than closing out of old loops. The twists are interesting from a drama perspective- but the strongest point of the show was the Maan and Geet chemistry. Even their funny scenes come out looking unfunny. I don't know who is to blame-but something is missing.

Do you feel all the Maaneet moments that have been shown recently looks lifeless and repetitive in terms of Direction and Execution???
>>For that I think the blame rests with the director- who despite excellent actors, makings of a half decent story and loyal viewers- is failing to deliver again and again. Romance is not all about eyelocks and caresses. Even the actors look bored in some of the scenes. They can do so much more.All they have to do is read some of the OS/FF posted on the forum- the writers are far more original/innovative and creative in portraying romance than the current set of writers that the PH has hired.


The SOMETHING that is missing is NISSAR!!  Maan Singh (the director) cannot deliver like Nissar can...its the plain ugly truth!!

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

sindu_gurti

--Nargis-- IF-Sizzlerz
--Nargis--
--Nargis--

Joined: 17 July 2008
Posts: 13178

Posted: 14 January 2011 at 1:52pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by ruslana

the think is we  know what is happening tomorrow like yesterday we knew last night what is going to happen thats y


Ruslana...If this is the ONLY problem...then i think there is rather quick FIX...no?  Stop SBB abd SBS....and then all will be golden?  I don't think so!!  I agree that this is one factor contributing to the diminishing TRPs...but certainly not the only problem.

Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Author Replies Views Last Post
Male ego....please answer if you can.

2 3

Author: --dolphin--   Replies: 16   Views: 2722

--dolphin-- 16 2722 24 August 2010 at 12:12pm by --dolphin--
Answer this question Maneetians?

2 3

Author: SweetSanny   Replies: 16   Views: 1725

SweetSanny 16 1725 12 August 2010 at 2:34am by pureluv
A sincere Request

2

Author: kyphfanz   Replies: 14   Views: 1049

kyphfanz 14 1049 10 August 2010 at 7:09am by kyphfanz
1 question every MAANEET Fan should answer-Do read

2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 10 11

Author: rickks   Replies: 87   Views: 5921

rickks 87 5921 26 July 2010 at 3:31pm by rickks
Every Geet fan plz answer this.

2 3

Author: lock_n_key   Replies: 20   Views: 1493

lock_n_key 20 1493 23 July 2010 at 7:49am by ManishaRox

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Topic Index

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index