Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee


Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee

One Question-Looking for Honest & sincere Answer (Page 4)

--Nargis-- IF-Sizzlerz

Joined: 17 July 2008
Posts: 13479

Posted: 14 January 2011 at 1:46am | IP Logged
Originally posted by -pixie-

Do you feel the show is losing its Charm???
>> Yup, the show has been losing its charm for me. For quite some time I have been feeling that something has been amiss. The story has been meandering- its almost as if the writers also dont know what to do with the show.

Do you feel that a Gripping Story/Screenplay is Missing???
>> The biggest problem is that the story/screenplay just went haywire after the engagement fiasco...They do have decent threads of a story running now...but the execution is seriously flawed. If I were to forget the scene and think of it from a story PoV- many of the recent twists sound really interesting- but the execution on screen has absolutely no dum! The only grouse I have with the writers is that they clearly have not watched the old episodes of GHSP- and hence we have new unanncounced tracks rather than closing out of old loops. The twists are interesting from a drama perspective- but the strongest point of the show was the Maan and Geet chemistry. Even their funny scenes come out looking unfunny. I don't know who is to blame-but something is missing.

Do you feel all the Maaneet moments that have been shown recently looks lifeless and repetitive in terms of Direction and Execution???
>>For that I think the blame rests with the director- who despite excellent actors, makings of a half decent story and loyal viewers- is failing to deliver again and again. Romance is not all about eyelocks and caresses. Even the actors look bored in some of the scenes. They can do so much more.All they have to do is read some of the OS/FF posted on the forum- the writers are far more original/innovative and creative in portraying romance than the current set of writers that the PH has hired.

The SOMETHING that is missing is NISSAR!!  Maan Singh (the director) cannot deliver like Nissar can...its the plain ugly truth!!

The following 4 member(s) liked the above post:


-pixie- IF-Rockerz

Joined: 21 September 2009
Posts: 6571

Posted: 14 January 2011 at 1:49am | IP Logged
Nargis: I wasnt sure about the time Nissar is spending on Geet vis-a-vis his other commitments hence did not take his name directly...but the execution of the story is so linear that it ends up looking illogical/stupid. Earlier also we have had tracks which required suspension of disbelief but execution was so good that we overlooked the logical inconsistencies. Now since logic and execution are both bad...everyone is gunning after the Creative team  

The following 6 member(s) liked the above post:


--Nargis-- IF-Sizzlerz

Joined: 17 July 2008
Posts: 13479

Posted: 14 January 2011 at 2:01am | IP Logged
Originally posted by -pixie-

Nargis: I wasnt sure about the time Nissar is spending on Geet vis-a-vis his other commitments hence did not take his name directly...but the execution of the story is so linear that it ends up looking illogical/stupid. Earlier also we have had tracks which required suspension of disbelief but execution was so good that we overlooked the logical inconsistencies. Now since logic and execution are both bad...everyone is gunning after the Creative team  

Exactly Pixie...jab execution acha toha hain to we the fans are very forgiving from the logic perspective....but when the execution and delivery is poor...then we have the snowballing effect....and we notice and nit pick on all the blunders, and inconsistencies...this is just human nature.   I am sure the makers and the producers are aware of this  If it was my money invested in this venture...i for one would damn well know and prevent this phenomenon.  So where is the PRODUCTION house in all the end its their

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:


eminent IF-Dazzler

Joined: 10 March 2008
Posts: 3600

Posted: 14 January 2011 at 2:02am | IP Logged
Hey Viji Good post...

I've actually thought about this as well, but the more I think about it, the more confused I get.  When the show first started, obviously it was new and had a gripping story line-which made it interesting.

After HP phase, we use to anxiously wait for Dev and Geet's confrontation, and then it became Maan & Dev's confrontation. (which I thought was handled really well!)
Now coming to Maaneet's part of the story- well Maan and Geet's chemistry being the "X" factor made it all the more interesting to watch. The audience knew from the beginning that Maan and Geet are destined for each other, but HOW will they end up together was the question.

So since the main story line/conflict has been resolved, there's not much of a gripping plot left. The only thing left as of right now is Maaneet 's chemistry! It's no longer mysterious like it use to be during HP days. It's super sizzling yet adorable-I love them. And this is why I still watch the show-as of right now.

The fact that I've been watching this show since the beginning, and haven't missed one episode since I've discovered the show- says it all. When a time comes in which I miss 2 or 3 episodes and never go back and bother to watch them-that is when the show as a whole would officially have lost it's charm for me! Let's just hope it's not anytime soon!

And like they say "good things always come to an end" I'm sure a time will come where GHSP will have it's end too, but I 'm hoping it will end on a good note.

(Viji- I don't even think this answered your question...but it gave me the chance to ponder on why I still love this show! LOL)

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:


meravigiliso IF-Rockerz

Joined: 31 July 2010
Posts: 5940

Posted: 14 January 2011 at 2:06am | IP Logged
hai,i second your thoughts 50:50.yes somewhere we are missing the charm .personally i startedwatching the serial becoz of geet and maan chemistry and  how the story will take a shape after maan comes to know about his bro hand in ruining geet's life. earlier i used to wait how both are going to fall in love then pregnancy revealation,then outcome of dev fiasco. everything was brialliantly handled by c.v . but coming to dev fiasco i expectedmore but o.k. but now what will be the next move by c.v.we r not knowing.neither they r completing any track.coming to maann and geet chemistry they r awesome still i blush after i see them. but yes they have to add story to make gripping story.

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:


rickks IF-Sizzlerz

Joined: 26 December 2007
Posts: 23819

Posted: 14 January 2011 at 2:26am | IP Logged
Whoaaaa...i seriously did not expect to garner this many responses.....I am yet to read every comment......But let the responses keep Flowing

Edited by rickks - 14 January 2011 at 2:27am

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:


adoremevirgo IF-Sizzlerz

Joined: 15 June 2006
Posts: 10882

Posted: 14 January 2011 at 2:31am | IP Logged
i think the show still has its charm...i agree some maneet scenes seem to be similar to old ones....but the essence is different because they were shown in different stages of their relationship....also execution by the actors r always fresh...kudos to nissar for that....
as for the story...i dont think anything is wrong....with 6-day telecast...other characters will get importance even if we like or not...
but in this case....the negative characters form the story...and its very obvious that a serial cant run widout twists and turns...
but yes...marriage must not be delayed...NT or brij must not win too....yes...they may create probs and trouble may occur between maneet...but they must not be dragged....
and also....MC track must be absolutely cancelled...if at all they want to show someone getting severely injured...then let it be maan...that will be a change...because geet falling in trouble and maan taking care of her has been shown umpteenth for a change we want to see geet taking care of maan...

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:


-honeydew- IF-Sizzlerz

Joined: 23 September 2008
Posts: 19036

Posted: 14 January 2011 at 3:16am | IP Logged
Originally posted by rickks

Hey Guys.....Today i am making an unusual Post....Its a Question thats been in my head for the last few days....and what better place to share this thought other than the Geet ForumSmile

Do you feel the show is losing its Charm???
i feel the show is where it was when it started, its just that we now want more than what we get, and thats why we are unhappy .. this is what happens ..when you had no expectations whatever you saw appealed to you, now that the standard has been set, whatever we see looks less !!! galti bas waqt ki hai ...having said that if they infused a new flavor into the existing story, i would certainly think people would complain less.. 

Do you feel that a Gripping Story/Screenplay is Missing???

it has been for a while, but then again whats Geets story been anyway .. the whole broad story was what we all knew and the screenplay and direction is what made the show what it was .. both of which have taken a major toll... the lesser we talk about this the better !!! sometimes there is no link between episodes ... there is no continuity .. and when two actors emote, you dont feel the emotion ... even playing maahi doesnt help!!!

Do you feel all the Maaneet moments that have been shown recently looks lifeless and repetitive in terms of Direction and Execution???

yes they feel very been there done that !!! its not about touching .. it never was .. even when Maan and Geet look into each others eyes the situations and emotions can be different, sometimes that changes the scenario..Maan doesnt always have to get hold of Geet to tell her he has her on his mind .. remember the sequence during kehna hi kya, when he tells her it doesnt matter what their personal equation is, but he cant take another person humiliating her .. he doesnt hold her by her shoulders or touch her, but he has still touched her by his gesture .. where is that Maan Singh Khurana .. today he has geared up security and he wants to protect her, he jumps the window ( something that most ppl swore he wud never do) .. just for her, but it evoked a thanda response .. are we getting too much of Maaneet ? have we had enough? having said this, if there is any lesser people will stick daggers at the makers so that option is ruled out as well...

Guys as loyal Viewers of GHSP, who has been watching this show religiously..... honestly batao do u still see that Spark, that Magic, that Brilliance which has always been associated with GHSP???

what i feel about GEET is only the connect i first established with the show and the characters that evolved over a period of time.. i cried when Geet broke down after she first realised her feelings for Maan in the courtyard, i wanted her to live for herself .. and give her life a chance, when she broke the news of her marriage to Maan, i wanted to slap Maan for giving the most human man like answer ..i had goosebumps during peeloon, i felt Geet's pain when she came face to face with Dev on her engagement day .. and cursed fate along with her about how a person never can get what he/she wants no matter how much he is true to herself at times .. and then i eventually was happy when she stood up for herself after the so called MU and decided to do something for herself, and later when she slapped Maan galti se i knew she was not wrong .. and then i dont know what happened, i dont remember which other emotion of Geet's i could sense or feel, cos she became his subservient better half all ready to get married to him ... the romance took over, it was all good, but when i looked back after a month there is nothing that i could say happened .. infact even when NT tried to attack her, i was sitting there blank in my room without a reaction ... the moments occasionally brought a smile on my face, but i knew this was not what i had first started watching the show for .. but so much time had passed, i didnt even remember what it once felt like when i first fell in love with GEET .. you could call me crazy for being this passionate about a television show, when i myself have been on the other side of the fence ... but thats what the show was .. it was real .. and it was so true to life .. and then one day i woke up and i had to say ... oh! so after much ado, it is a television show after all.. that trust me doesnt feel good !!Smile

Hope you guys will pour in your Answers....Do Comment Smile

i have tried to justify every action of the maker cos i have tried and thought about different scenarios from their side, whether it was the actors falling sick or the change in the creative team, ignoring of certain technical errors ... it has always been a two sided story .. and i have also tried to tell most people around me why certain things could be the way they are sometimes .. but there then comes a point when you sit to think, are you a viewer or more than that? then you realise, you are another viewer like million others, its just that you have a computer and the access to internet and you get to share what you feel with another ... at times that has gone over board as well, with my expectations taking a unrealistic turn .. but then i have been disappointed when i have asked for nothing as well... i had to break .. and that time has perhaps come .. from now, i am numb and it doesnt matter .. i only hope things get better .. what else can i say but that?

Note: Please do not take this as an offensive post.....I have no intentions of hurting the sentiments any of the viewers/audience/fans.

baby i am glad you made this post, and like always proved to be my JKB-PKS partner ... Hug
honestly i dont know what it is like right now .. but there is perhaps still a flicker of hope that things will get better, and i would be happy if they did ... but then i guess at times, its better to let go than hang on ... the makers and the audience have done equal amount of damage to the show, though it may not have been intentional, and any effort for either side now would mean having unrealistic expectations .. Maan and Geet are almost getting married, Arjun and Annie may not be able to pull the story forward, wonder what the deal with the baby is .. and NT and Brij cant run the show .. where is the scope unless they are planning to bring in newer people and open an all new angle to the storyline .. i am ready to welcome changes .. and embrace them .. you dont abandon something you love just cos it is crippled ... you know how you and i watched DMG till the last day !! haha !! we are mad ... but thats why we never give up dont we ...



Edited by -honeydew- - 14 January 2011 at 3:26am

The following 6 member(s) liked the above post:


Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Author Replies Views Last Post
Male ego....please answer if you can.

2 3

Author: --dolphin--   Replies: 16   Views: 2892

--dolphin-- 16 2892 24 August 2010 at 12:12pm by --dolphin--
Answer this question Maneetians?

2 3

Author: SweetSanny   Replies: 16   Views: 1765

SweetSanny 16 1765 12 August 2010 at 2:34am by pureluv
A sincere Request


Author: kyphfanz   Replies: 14   Views: 1080

kyphfanz 14 1080 10 August 2010 at 7:09am by kyphfanz
1 question every MAANEET Fan should answer-Do read

2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 10 11

Author: rickks   Replies: 87   Views: 6029

rickks 87 6029 26 July 2010 at 3:31pm by rickks
Every Geet fan plz answer this.

2 3

Author: lock_n_key   Replies: 20   Views: 1525

lock_n_key 20 1525 23 July 2010 at 7:49am by ManishaRox

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Topic Index

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index