Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee

India-Forums

   
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee

One Question-Looking for Honest & sincere Answer (Page 12)

rickks IF-Sizzlerz
rickks
rickks

Joined: 26 December 2007
Posts: 23787

Posted: 16 January 2011 at 11:05am | IP Logged
Thankyou for openly pointing it out that the actors have also had their share of Flaws, blame them or the director....Its affecting the show big timeCry

Originally posted by -honeydew-

nani, Nissar is brilliant at his work, but i personally feel if things are going bad, its also reflects badly on the fact that the entire team is pinning their hopes on one person, who by the way another human being ...
yes, he owes something to this show, and he needs to give his bit as well, but if Nissar does everything, what the hell are others doing?
i cant feel GC emote anymore the way he did ...
DD is the only other person who has been consistent right from day one ...
last night when NT spoke i was like .. oh shut up you woman ...
Annie and Arjun are just about okay at the moment ...
the show Geet was not made just by Nissar right ? there were so many others ... now suddenly whats going so wrong that, we cant feel the same way about the show ..
and what if Nissar is actually doing his bit, and we expect too much outta him ..LOLLOL


Originally posted by --Nargis--

Originally posted by -pixie-

Do you feel the show is losing its Charm???
>> Yup, the show has been losing its charm for me. For quite some time I have been feeling that something has been amiss. The story has been meandering- its almost as if the writers also dont know what to do with the show.

Do you feel that a Gripping Story/Screenplay is Missing???
>> The biggest problem is that the story/screenplay just went haywire after the engagement fiasco...They do have decent threads of a story running now...but the execution is seriously flawed. If I were to forget the scene and think of it from a story PoV- many of the recent twists sound really interesting- but the execution on screen has absolutely no dum! The only grouse I have with the writers is that they clearly have not watched the old episodes of GHSP- and hence we have new unanncounced tracks rather than closing out of old loops. The twists are interesting from a drama perspective- but the strongest point of the show was the Maan and Geet chemistry. Even their funny scenes come out looking unfunny. I don't know who is to blame-but something is missing.

Do you feel all the Maaneet moments that have been shown recently looks lifeless and repetitive in terms of Direction and Execution???
>>For that I think the blame rests with the director- who despite excellent actors, makings of a half decent story and loyal viewers- is failing to deliver again and again. Romance is not all about eyelocks and caresses. Even the actors look bored in some of the scenes. They can do so much more.All they have to do is read some of the OS/FF posted on the forum- the writers are far more original/innovative and creative in portraying romance than the current set of writers that the PH has hired.


The SOMETHING that is missing is NISSAR!!  Maan Singh (the director) cannot deliver like Nissar can...its the plain ugly truth!!

rickks IF-Sizzlerz
rickks
rickks

Joined: 26 December 2007
Posts: 23787

Posted: 16 January 2011 at 11:07am | IP Logged
Originally posted by -honeydew-

i totally agree with you ... even a bag of crap gift wrapped well is taken in nicely when presented well .. today there are so many things that are missing on the show, we cant help but blaming makers ...cos we dont know what could actually be wrong ...

Originally posted by -pixie-

Nargis: I wasnt sure about the time Nissar is spending on Geet vis-a-vis his other commitments hence did not take his name directly...but the execution of the story is so linear that it ends up looking illogical/stupid. Earlier also we have had tracks which required suspension of disbelief but execution was so good that we overlooked the logical inconsistencies. Now since logic and execution are both bad...everyone is gunning after the Creative team  


Nihu Its a team work Babes....everybody has to do their share of work else it would show in the show, glaringly looking at usOuch
rickks IF-Sizzlerz
rickks
rickks

Joined: 26 December 2007
Posts: 23787

Posted: 16 January 2011 at 11:55am | IP Logged
Originally posted by lovetheserial

TongueViji, love you for the post that made my brain work overtime.

Thanks Yaar.....Har koi mujhse yehi kehtha hai.....Looks like i am the culprit??? do u think i should stop making the brains work over timeWink

Do you feel the show is losing its Charm???

Personally, the Charm has always been Maan and Geet.

To each their own...For me its always been the way the Director had a Vision to showcase a social Issue(the plight of a woman/her journey) interspersed with a passionate Lovestory....

The story telling was amazing...

The symbolism's glaring at us from within the screen....

To add to  the Beauty, the way Maan and Geet the two poignant characters that was sketched were so much detailed and a treat to watch as the story unfoldedSmile

Because of their superb acting skills and pat on expressive faces, the story of their love spoke volumes.  Starting with Geets innocence to Maan's underlying aggressive nature, Geet's tremendous strength and will to survive with Maan's underlying confidence to be her protector;  all expressed thru their eyes, lips, smiles, toned face muscles aggravating or subtly playing the expressions, his body language, not stumbling or guessing his way, the story line clinched top rating.  This was a telling story of an aspiring Indian woman who hunted for safety & justice, and there were these two lead stunners, and their versatility created magic.  And if either of them disappeared the show lost life.

THE PART UNDERLINED FOR ME AS OF NOW SEEMS TO HAVE DISAPPEARED FROM THE SHOW, FOR GOOD OR NOT IS YET ANOTHER FACTOR, FOR WHICH WE WILL HAVE TO WAIT i GUESS (Caps only for emphasis)Smile


Do you feel that a Gripping Story/Screenplay is Missing???
There are the spell binding episodes and the lesser intensity ones.  I have this time of day where I watch Geet from pre-Maan time to his first encounter with Geet, to her journey to Delhi and her Maan encounters and then the hillarious and heart-warming office nok-jhoks to teary clientele episodes.  They used to fascinate me and do so even now.

Tell me about it......Those episodes are examples of Classic Story Telling and sheer acting Brilliance and flawless executionOuch

Then on came the much-hyped engagement, the misunderstanding episodes to Maan buying off the paint co. to his farm house ranting, to forgiveness in the office and then  hot-on romance all leading to the upcoming marriage.  These really have been gripping story lines.  But what is really missing is coordination of a month's episodes to later episodes.

I really feel that even during the engagement time and the Hospital seq....were quite nicely done....But then on that is from the Dev-Maan-Geet confrontation to the MU(Which i like but only qualm was about execution) and there on hell broke looseAngry Ouch Confused

Fusion of characters in episodes should allow a connecting factor of one episode with the other.  Characters sidelined are to be given a good story to leave the serial for good.  When something new is being created by way of a new direction to the story, the old and redundant ones need to be taken off the shelf very carefully without reducing the subtle embossment it has created in the hearts and minds of viewers. 

Driving and directing episodes to make sense with characters and story that seem rather loosely woven and are diverted from actual facts or core theme of the story - Geet, her struggles, Maan empowering her for the challenges ahead, need to be dealt with cohesive intelligence. -Geet becoming a woman of the world with her modest power and trained acumen and how she aids Maan to build a better and futuristic empire (after all she wanted a strong and intelligent baby) and through all this should be woven the hot scenes, the romantic interludes frequently and the gripping mystery occasionally.  After all, we have seen Geet take over projects, fight clients for Maan and step in his shoes in a way when she had to run the paint co.  Through all this she knows her subservient place in Maan's life and she adds a lovely freshness into his life.  She becomes the sherni for Maan.

The part underlined well saidClap This is one thing Missing now...Where is the Tigress????

Do you feel all the Maaneet moments that have been shown recently looks lifeless and repetitive in terms of Direction and Execution???

Yes.  There seem to be less flavor in the ingredients used in enacting scenes.  Gurti movements, even repetitive ones are worth a lifetimes watch, but somehow they are becoming monotonous. There is a subtle interplay of action, romance, aggression, shrewd abilities, and a worldly chess game of sorts for achievements and power that can be experimented with.  The Director and his team have to ensure that for a serial that has done tremendously well at the ratings game, the intoxicating thought of being able to create limitless realities should stand afront. 

 

The principle for a successful fusion of storyline/concept, acting and the projection of reality,   is that one must have a good knowledge of its ingredients, their flavor and taste.  It must hit people's intellect and mind.  The concept must look good and intelligent fans need to savour it well.  For this an important ingredient is consistency in the work of Director, Producer and CVs, the flavor and taste to be provided by the actors. This is a modern story set in the reality of the world today, unjust marriages for buying a girls security, to honor killings, forced abortions to infanticide, are rampant in India.

U have put it so well that i dont think i should spoil it by adding anything moreClap

As loyal Viewers of GHSP, who has been watching this show religiously..... honestly batao do u still see that Spark, that Magic, that Brilliance which has always been associated with GHSP???

Yes, the magic and that brilliance are missing because of the monotonous action and replay. Today, one has to touch the hearts of a young generation who have to intelligently focus on changing history and excess baggage in tradition.

Exactly, the audience have grown Intelligent, they dont take anything and everything that comes their way, and when such a Scenario Prevails anything less than the already set standard becomes unacceptableConfused

These should be stories of ambitious young Indians who struggle and sacrifice to chase their dreams in the new age. Geet is one such character.  And Maan another.  There are also sidies who leave lasting impressions. 

But I won't speak much, because we have been promised a completely mind-blowing storyline after marriage, So reservation till then.

 

Cheers.LOL

 


I just loved your write-up and always enjoy reading them.....I dont think there was anything for me to add....Yet i have given my additions in PinkSmile

rickks IF-Sizzlerz
rickks
rickks

Joined: 26 December 2007
Posts: 23787

Posted: 16 January 2011 at 12:01pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by k_anjali12

Firstly Let Me Wish U Yaar ... Belated Happy Birthday ... I Was Not Around On IF Thts Why Not WIshed U At The Right TimeEmbarrassed

Thanku thanku thankuBig smile

Hmmm Yeah A Perfect Post ... As A Regular Viewer Can Definetely Say .. The Show Lost Its Charm ... At The Start It Always Reg. The Story Which The Creatives Showed ... But These Days .. They Left The Story Aside ... Though Its A Regular Show ... A 0.1 Logic Has To Be There Na' .. Esp. Showing Geet As A Pregnant Woman n Not Showing Dev Presence .. He HAS 2 Be Shown In The Story More Thn Nayantara N All Other PPL .

I so agreeClap


I Even Remember The 1st Episode Of The Show 2Day ... They Showed Like Geet Is  A Woman ... Who Stood As An Example To All The Ppl Of Present Socitey N In Their Village ... But By The Way The Show Is Going On ... I Almost Lost Interest To Wait For Tht Moment.

Today we have only Moments, and who better than us to know that when there is simply moments with no proper track that it will lose its charm and stand in the raceSmile



I Wish The Show Gets It Charm Back .

P:S:Thnks For The PM.



Anytime yaar....Thanks for your Inputs
Harpreet.M IF-Dazzler
Harpreet.M
Harpreet.M

Joined: 23 March 2006
Posts: 4675

Posted: 16 January 2011 at 10:18pm | IP Logged
To be completely honest i have not watched the show since 2 months because it dragged too much... i just can believe the directors made such a good show into crap.. everytime i try to catch up i feel like the show is just plain annoying..and i swear this was my favorite show a couple months ago
stylish_VJ IF-Dazzler
stylish_VJ
stylish_VJ

Joined: 22 May 2010
Posts: 2684

Posted: 19 January 2011 at 2:56am | IP Logged
Originally posted by rickks

Hey Guys.....Today i am making an unusual Post....Its a Question thats been in my head for the last few days....and what better place to share this thought other than the Geet ForumSmile

Do you feel the show is losing its Charm???
Yes, but it can be regained if the CV's want to....Get Nissar Back, he is the only person who can resurrect GHSP now.......He is one of the original visionary of this show, infact the only one left i guess.....Just get him back and the show will be a roaring success againSmile

Do you feel that a Gripping Story/Screenplay is Missing???
Yes it is, missing Big time....But rather than blaming the new set of writers, i would request them to watch the previous episodes, read the previous scripts which was tastefully and majestically done by Mrinal Jha, Swati pandey and Priya  RamanathanSmile


Do you feel all the Maaneet moments that have been shown recently looks lifeless and repetitive in terms of Direction and Execution???
This is the directors fault.....Hence i repeat get Nissar Parvez...if somebody can wok wonders on MAANEET its himSmile

Guys as loyal Viewers of GHSP, who has been watching this show religiously..... honestly batao do u still see that Spark, that Magic, that Brilliance which has always been associated with GHSP???
I wouldn't say its missing, but its definitely inconsistent, and the CV's does not seem to be able to sustain it .....We get 1 Brilliant episode then 3 episodes which make u wonder are they a part of the same seriesConfused then again 2 days of brilliance onscreen and the pattern continues.....5 days of brilliance and 1 day of Crap...or 4 days of brilliance and 2 days of inconsistent is acceptable....after that audience lose their interest.....and thats where the CV's shud work....

 


Thanks Viji
Smile

Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Author Replies Views Last Post
Male ego....please answer if you can.

2 3

Author: --dolphin--   Replies: 16   Views: 3273

--dolphin-- 16 3273 24 August 2010 at 12:12pm by --dolphin--
Answer this question Maneetians?

2

Author: SweetSanny   Replies: 15   Views: 1847

SweetSanny 15 1847 12 August 2010 at 2:34am by pureluv
A sincere Request

2

Author: kyphfanz   Replies: 14   Views: 1142

kyphfanz 14 1142 10 August 2010 at 7:09am by kyphfanz
1 question every MAANEET Fan should answer-Do read

2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 10 11

Author: rickks   Replies: 87   Views: 6344

rickks 87 6344 26 July 2010 at 3:31pm by rickks
Every Geet fan plz answer this.

2 3

Author: lock_n_key   Replies: 20   Views: 1660

lock_n_key 20 1660 23 July 2010 at 7:49am by ManishaRox

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Topic Index

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index