Bollywood News, Bollywood Movies, Bollywood Chat

India-Forums

   
Bollywood News, Bollywood Movies, Bollywood Chat
Bollywood News, Bollywood Movies, Bollywood Chat

Dhobi Ghat (Mumbai Diaries) - POST ALL REVIEWS HERE (Page 4)

BheegiBasanti IF-Sizzlerz
BheegiBasanti
BheegiBasanti

Joined: 06 October 2005
Posts: 11062

Posted: 19 January 2011 at 7:41pm | IP Logged
DHOBI GHAT (Mumbai Diaries)

http://community.compuserve.com/n/pfx/forum.aspx?tsn=1&nav=messages&webtag=ws-showbiz&tid=24392&redirCnt=1

UTV
Reviewed for CompuServe by Harvey Karten

Grade:  B+
Directed By:  Kiran Rao
Written By:  Kiran Rao
Cast:  Aamir Khan, Prateik Babbar, Monica Dogra, Kiti Malhotra
Screened at:  Review 1, NYC, 12/15/10
Opens:  January 21, 2010

If you're looking for a sit-comish, but well-done interpretation of romantic triangles, particularly if you want to be convinced that the fatherly types win out over the bad-boys, go to "How Do You Know." If you don't care for Hollywood treatments, seek out "Dhobi Ghat," straight from India, done indie style that in no way reflects the influence of Bollywood'never mind that it takes place in Mumbai (Bombay).  Music is sparingly used in the soundtrack, only when it benefits the drama, and the acting appears authentic even to the point that the film comes across almost as a documentary.  It's difficult to believe that this is writer-director Kiran Rao's merely freshman effort in a feature film.

"Dhobi Ghat" reflects the influence of class and caste in India, proving that even in that country's most populous city, there may be more flexibility in social relationships among the classes, but bottom line, there is little hope that a guy and a gal from different ranks can form a cemented union.  The story centers on three characters: rich American-Indian investment banker Shai (Monica Dogra), on sabbatical from her gig in New York's financial district to pursue her hobby in photography; Arun (Aamir Khan), a reclusive painter who has turned inward after a troubled marital past; and Munna (Prateik), a handsome launderer who delivers wash daily to his clients, determined to use his looks to get a job as a Bollywood actor.  A fourth personality, Yasmin (Kriti Malhotra), appears on a videotape as a former tenant in Arun's apartment who leaves visual letters to an unnamed person, letters that have a profound effect on the eavesdropping artist.

After Shai spends the night with the reclusive artist, she heads out on the town in the company of Munna, the artist's launderer, who agrees to show her the real Mumbai in return for her photographing him for a portfolio to accompany his rsum to the film studios.  Munna quickly falls in love with Shai, an impossible romance given their difference in class, wealth, sophistication and education, a point made clear by the dhobi's drug-dealing brother who laughs at Munna for even thinking of a relationship with the American woman.  Similarly, Shai, who might make a match with the artist, could be destined for disappointment as well given Arun's introverted nature, though some hope is held out for the couple at the conclusion of the tale. 

We in the audience get to see the two Mumbais, filmed by Tushar Kanti Ray in Super 16 and mini-DV.  The traffic jams are particularly impressive, almost an extra set of characters that include motorcycles, small cars, taxis and bicycles.  Artists' galleries contrast with slums, seedy drug pushers sell to patrons driving past with half-opened windows.  Special mention must be made of the Gustavo Snataolalla's score which never intrudes, and of the black-and-white pictures that Shai had allegedly taken for Munna's portfolio but which are a product of Jyotika Jain's lenses.

Unrated.  100 minutes.   2011 by Harvey Karten  Member: NY Film Critics Online



Edited by darlunia - 19 January 2011 at 7:43pm

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

noor_ayesha

BheegiBasanti IF-Sizzlerz
BheegiBasanti
BheegiBasanti

Joined: 06 October 2005
Posts: 11062

Posted: 19 January 2011 at 7:43pm | IP Logged

Mumbai Diaries **

by Andrew Schenker on January 16, 2011  

http://www.slantmagazine.com/film/review/mumbai-diaries/5243


Everyone's an artist in Mumbai Diaries, Kiran Rao's Bombay-set network narrative—or at the very least aspires to be one. Part wrong-side-of-the-tracks romance, part portrait of the titular city, and part reflection on the class privilege of turning (mostly impoverished) life into art, Rao's film is least clumsy and most interesting when dealing with the latter, even as it's partially implicated in the same thorny dilemmas facing the director's on-screen surrogates.

Following a one-night stand between Indian-American financial consultant (and amateur photographer) Shai (Monica Dogra) and toast-of-the-town painter Arun (Aamir Khan), the two go their separate ways, each increasingly occupied with a third character who shows them new aspects of the teeming metropolis—and fuels their art. When Shai, on extended sabbatical from New York, befriends her clothes washer (dhobi), a handsome young man who fancies himself an aspiring actor and instantly falls in love with the toothsome American, more than a few eyebrows are raised among the locals. That class is a more rigid matter in India than the United States is a point frequently made, most explicitly by Shai's maid who upbraids her for her activity, dismissing the "dhobi boy" as "totally worthless."

Still, despite the bluntness of the class critique, the relationship between Shai and Munna (Prateik) is appealingly modest, the possibility of romance ever present, but nicely sublimated as the character's repression of desire delivers a more telling comment on the social barriers to love than any explicit listen-to-this dialogue. More problematic is Shai's interest in Munna as artistic "material." In exchange for shooting the aspiring actor's portfolio, Munna agrees to let Shai photograph him at the various stages of his washing work, a project that expands to guiding the young woman around the less "glamorous" neighborhoods of Mumbai. While this agreement allows Rao to construct her own cine-portrait of the city, which she does via handsome but not overly prettified views of the metropolis' vivid working-class quarters, she complicates the question of how to film poverty by incorporating Shai's own arty snaps into her shots. Lensing perfectly framed black-and-white pics, Shai clearly aspires to a self-consciously "artistic" brand of photography, and by cutting directly from her more rough hewn framings to Shai's images, Rao calls into question the propriety of mining exotic material for artistic glory.

Or does she simply indulge in the same impulse as Shai? Certainly her film seems more thoughtful about questions of class and aesthetics than does its female lead, but Rao's not above the same mode of easy prettification. In one sequence that seems to define the film's ambiguous attitude toward its central questions of representation, Rao films Munna on top of his shack roof, placing plastic over a hole in order to waterproof the structure in the middle of a nighttime rainstorm. The shot, whose ostensible content is the crippling effects of poverty, is filmed as a lovely overhead nocturnal view, the image of tiny Munna patching the hole set off against two trains zipping by in the distance, their windows lighted amidst the attendant downpour. But then, Rao follows up the scene by showing Shai discussing her adventures in slumming with her real estate magnate father. As the two laugh about what her poverty-phobic mother would say if she knew about Shai's project, the juxtaposition with the previous scene becomes an eloquent testimony to the relative economic positions of Munna, Shai, and Rao herself as a starting point for their participation in the creation of art—whether as author or subject.

Slightly less problematic than Shai's artistic interest in her dhobi is Arun's relationship with his own "guide" to the city. Despite his residence in one of the poorer quarters of Mumbai, the painter is signaled as both financially successful and an outsider to the city (he's lived abroad in Australia). So when he discovers a series of video letters shot by his apartment's former resident on a low-grade camcorder, he becomes obsessed to the point of curtailing nearly all other activity until he makes his way through the tapes. Determined to document the city for her family back in her provincial hometown, the woman, Yasmin (Kriti Malhotra), takes her camera to Mumbai's marketplaces, thoroughfares, and public trains, opening up the metropolis for the reclusive painter in the same way that Munna did for Shai. But if Arun, like Shai, is a self-conscious artist, than Yamin's work is that of a primitive, her nauseous zooms and choppy handheld work a more turbulent version of Rao's own rough-hewn aesthetic. As he makes his way through the tapes, and Yasmin's sadness turns to genuine despair, Arun becomes fascinated by the woman's face, eventually working her teary-eyed visage into his latest painting, a questionable decision that the film doesn't quite question and which becomes especially dubious when we learn Yasmin's ultimate fate. Still, even apart from the uncertain propriety of Arun's project, the scenes with the painter suffer from a certain static quality, mirroring the character's own hermetic orientation and diverting attention from the more vibrant question of Shai and Munna's romantic and (especially) artistic relationship.

A deceptively simple tale of four Mumbai residents, Rao's film is animated by its inquiry into the not always mutually beneficial symbiosis between artist and subject that complicates so much of human-centric art. That film is among the most human-centric of arts and that Rao doesn't adequately interrogate her own relationship to her subjects means that Mumbai Diaries can't quite match its own ambitions, but unlike popular Indian-set entertainments like Slumdog Millionaire, at least it knows enough to pose the right questions.


  • Director(s): Kiran Rao
  • Screenplay: Kiran Rao
  • Cast: Aamir Khan, Prateik, Monica Dogra, Kriti Malhotra
  • Distributor: UTV Communications
  • Runtime: 100 min.
  • Rating: NR
  • Year: 2010

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

noor_ayesha

noor_ayesha Groupbie
noor_ayesha
noor_ayesha

Joined: 21 November 2010
Posts: 58

Posted: 20 January 2011 at 12:04am | IP Logged
Cool...excited to watch it this weekend!
Lighthearted IF-Rockerz
Lighthearted
Lighthearted

Joined: 01 December 2005
Posts: 7771

Posted: 20 January 2011 at 1:13am | IP Logged

i love to watch Aamir's movies

theprince IF-Rockerz
theprince
theprince

Joined: 22 December 2010
Posts: 7348

Posted: 20 January 2011 at 3:06am | IP Logged
Prateik wows in Dhobi Ghat

Sonil Dedhia reviews Dhobi Ghat. Post YOUR reviews here!

It's important for a first-time director to get things right. And mind you, debutante director Kiran Rao [ Images ] almost does. But just when she gets to the top of the hill, an avalanche strikes.

Dhobi Ghat is an unusual 95-minute film without an interval, unlike regular Hindi films. You don't know what turn the story will take. Even the characters are unpredictable.

And if you're expecting an Aamir Khan [ Images ] film, let me tell you, it's not.

Dhobi Ghat is a film about four people from different backgrounds: Arun (Aamir Khan) is a painter, who's a complete loner. Shai (Monica Dogra) is an investment banker from America, who is on a sabbatical. Zohaib alias Munna (Prateik Babbar) is a dhobi by day, rat killer by night and a wannabe actor in between. Yasmin (Kriti Malhotra) is a naive and shy newlywed.

The four stories get entwined with the fifth character, Mumbai [ Images ], the city of dreams, hope and survival.

Mumbai has been an inspiration for many filmmakers and has been highlighted in many films. But it is Dhobi Ghat that gets you into the small by-lanes that we haven't really seen before.

Cinematographer Tushar Kanti Ray deserves a standing ovation for showing off beautiful landscapes, colourful sunsets over Marine Drive [ Images ], the festival of Ramzan being celebrated at Minara Masjid, the constant traffic, crowded streets and heavy rains, where one can actually feel the raindrops.

Full marks to Kiran Rao for using an innovative idea of capturing the essence of Mumbai through multiple formats. Yasmin's character is shown as a video diary, and that is amazing.

Jyotkia Jain's black and white still photography is a treat to watch. She explores the different kinds of people in the city.

The paintings, done by Ravi Mandlik and Sukanya Ghosh, stand apart and brings out what goes on inside Arun's mind. Oscar-winning Argentine composer Gustavo Santaolalla's (Brokeback Mountain and Babel [ Images ]) music deserves a mention. It is in sync with the mood of the film.

Kiran Rao has tried to be as realistic as possible, and that's the USP of the film. Her choice of subject and handling is one of the reasons that makes this film watchable. But the film is not a straight-line narrative and so gets complex, and lacks clarity. The editing could have been tighter as well. The tense moments get too heavy after a point and would work only for a handful who appreciate realistic cinema.

The film clearly belongs to Prateik Babbar and newcomer Monica Dogra. Prateik gets under the skin of the character with ease and performs beautifully. His mannerisms and body language take you by surprise. Dhobi Ghat will definitely open many more avenues for the young actor.

Watch out for him in these two particular scenes: When he gets jealous with the liftman and in the end, when he chases Shai's car.

Monica is splendid to watch. She makes her presence felt everytime she's on screen.

Kirti Malhotra, as Yasmin, leaves a solid impression.

Aamir Khan's presence in the film, however, is a big question. He tries to restrain his character and that does not work for him. His English dialogues don't sound fluent. In fact, he's quite the misfit in the film. Wacko

Dhobi Ghat is sure to find a niche audience and will be a hit in festival circuits. Being a Mumbai-centric film, it may connect with the audience in the city. But it needs to be seen whether it will find takers in other parts of the country.

3/5


The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

BheegiBasanti

ruky786 IF-Stunnerz
ruky786
ruky786

Joined: 12 August 2006
Posts: 42345

Posted: 20 January 2011 at 5:08am | IP Logged
Originally posted by azeeblowing

Thanks Kiran for this lovly movie.


Wonder what Kiran is thinking? ROFL
Meena1 IF-Stunnerz

Joined: 27 December 2005
Posts: 27397

Posted: 20 January 2011 at 5:17am | IP Logged
THE ACCOUNT OF THE MEMBER WHO POSTED THIS MESSAGE HAS BEEN TEMPORARILY BANNED.

If you think this is an error please Contact us.

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

ruky786

ruky786 IF-Stunnerz
ruky786
ruky786

Joined: 12 August 2006
Posts: 42345

Posted: 20 January 2011 at 5:18am | IP Logged
^^ROFL Meena you make me laugh

Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Author Replies Views Last Post
EXCLUSIVE Dhobi Ghat Stills-Aamir Khan

2 3

Author: MissIffiy   Replies: 23   Views: 3262

MissIffiy 23 3262 24 December 2010 at 9:17pm by anjali10
Raajneeti Reviews: First one up (ALL Reviews Here)

2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 31 32

Author: Mistyy   Replies: 248   Views: 48014

Mistyy 248 48014 14 August 2010 at 4:47pm by .shona.
Dhobi Ghat is a love letter to Mumbai

Author: desihamesha   Replies: 0   Views: 528

desihamesha 0 528 28 July 2010 at 10:44am by desihamesha
PYAAR IMPOSSIBLE Reviews here + member reviews

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Author: Niti_Angel   Replies: 72   Views: 24833

Niti_Angel 72 24833 13 January 2010 at 9:05pm by Dexterkichokri
REVIEWS REVIEWS REVIEWS!

Author: preity*zinta   Replies: 0   Views: 3540

preity*zinta 0 3540 08 November 2007 at 1:48pm by preity*zinta

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Bollywood News, Bollywood Movies, Bollywood Chat Topic Index

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index