Originally posted by ankit_nyc
Wow so we have a handfu of people passing judgement on the public at large by saying that the only reason the show didn't do well in ratings was becasue public likes drama and this show didn't have any.
Actually I gave a hell of a number of reasons why this season might have had low ratings. I made a whole post on that actually. I think there were low ratings mainly because there were already many singing shows this year, which had more popular judges.
They don't consider marrying of contestatns, groping of female contestatns, love stories of contestatns, snatching mics away by mentors from contestants as drama........So the few elitist are actually saying that the show didn't do well because public doesn't appreciate quality only drama...........
As I've said many times but you've fail to register. That IS drama. But I consider it the lesser of two devils. You may disagree with me. It's personal preference. I never said the public appreciates 'quality' and 'only drama'. You've accused others of putting words in people's mouths but what are you doing here?
ummmm can those people explain how DID did so well, that show was relatively drama less, how did Sonu Nigham's Sa Re GA Ma did so well, that too was dramaless..........how did Sa Re Ga Ma lil champs do so well, that show was relatively dramaless as well.........if drama is all that the public at large craves how does Rakhi Sawants' show not do well? How does Big Boss not to do well in ratings?
Drama is not successful. Entertainment is. Having said that, drama can be entertaining and it can keep people hook. i know drama kept me hooked to mkmm this year.
It's highly simplistic and down right biased to discount the TRPS by saying oh the public doesn't know anything........
I never said the public doesn't know anything. I said that TRPs are not always correlated to musical content. Celebrities, timing, the contestants' likeability, the choice of songs, the overall ratings of the channel - these all are also factors.
Some people may like girls being married in the show, and mentors pouncing on female contestants and snatching mic away from contestatns, but most people don't.........People are actually saying Rini was a willing participant in the whole wedding and hence it's not the mentors fault......I guess all the girls who were groped by Sajid/wajid were also willing participant, contestants who had their mic snatched in the middle of their performance were also wiling participants..........
I dont like girls being married etc. I think there WAS drama but it wasn't as bad as previous seasons.
I wonder how those same people would feel if it was their family member being pounced on my the mentors, or being married off on stage?
So it comes down to oh the public doesn't know anything onlya couple of people know about quality...........interesting
^^ All of this is just a desperate attempt at saving your argument.
The public made Sa Re Ga Ma a big hit, it was the public that supported Sa RE Ga Ma during Sonu NIgham time, it was the public that supported Sa rE Ga ma during C 05 and C 07 and this year just because the public didn't like the drama and the classless behavior of mentors they stopped supporting it, and now the public doesn't know quality..........interesting.......so the public knew quality when the made Sa Re Ga ma the most successful singing show during Sonu Nigham time and now that same public doesn't appreciate quality just because they got turned off my Paaji's standard feedback of chak de fatte, and rab rakha, got turned offf my sajid wajid's groping of female contestants and marrying off of teenage girls......
The public has made many great shows indeed. And it has rejected many great shwos too, e.g. Powder and Maahi Way on Sony.
Some people may find fighting amongst judges more objectionable then groping of female contestatns, and marrying off of teenage girls, but public clearly has said that it will not tolerate such behavior.........
LOL you think TRP's represent a public mandate.
the public was right to support Sa Re Ga ma during Sonu's time and C 05 and C 07 and they were right not to support it this time........
Right. That's your opinion. I respectthat.
the cheap behavior from these classless mentors turned a lot of people off.........
It must have turned many people off. It turned me off a bti too. But so did the behaviour of the judges on previous seasons.
to those that loved the show,
I don't think anyone loved this show.
good for you but stop putting down the general public by saying they don't appreciate quality and only drama and stop defending marrying off of girls, senseless comments from the judges, groping of female contestatns, and constant interruptions of contestatns in the middle of performance just so the mentors can showcase their talents.........
I'm not saying any of that. Neither is anyone else. I don't put down the general public coz I'm part of the public.
Read my posts half as many times as you repeat your own comments. I will edit this soon.