Posted: 19 December 2010 at 5:05pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by Tani91
I actually disagree with you about the show degrading....I'm sorry but in my opinion JDJ gets better every season...this season is definitely the best one (IMO) because of Madhuri and the contestants they have picked
now I also disagree that a non-dancer competes with an experienced dancer....which is not true...since you gave the example of Sushant I'll take him....he was in ZND in which two teams competed....he was not an individual winner....in fact the girls won the competition.....and yes the serial crowd has had more experience in dancing....but that does not make them good dancers.....just because they've done it a few times doesnt mean they're good.....given that they probably know how reharsals work and how to move better......but that doesn't equate to good dancing which is what the show strives for (after audiences SMS money of course) which celeb who ISNT from a dancing background improves each week.....
because if going by that standard then Renuka also comes on the same boat....she's also done dancing in HAHK? so why is she excluded from this category....or even Chang who has tried dancing in Badmash Company?
but I do agree about the judging so far...I don't like that they discuss and then give marks....AND also they dont have a set criteria for these performances....what exactly are they looking for? because their comments are different for everyone regarding their judging...I hope they improve on that
Not really, in the previous seasons, there was a large variety of contestants, if someone was a sportsperson, the other was an actor, or a producer, etc...and no one knew dance at all! But I do respect your opinions
Ever heard of 'practice makes perfect'? Yeah, that is exactly what is happening here, these contestants who have already danced before have more experience and are familiar with the basic steps of dance etc, you know what I mean?
Ah, yes, Renuka has danced before....but now has she not gained weight? Does she not have a disadvantage or rather a hurdle in her way too, like the other inexperienced dancers? Let's look at Sudha Chandran from season 2, she was an experienced dancer too, but I never minded her presence. Wanna know why? Because she had a prosthetic leg, which also put her at a disadvantage. Yes, but Chang really didn't dance in BC, he more or less shook his leg, so you can disregard that 'experience'