10 boys/6 girls Fair or Unfair?

Woahh 1o Boys, and only 6 girls...is this fair...should they have equal amount of girls n boys like they usually do?? What do you guys think? did u like the way they came up with the top 16?Edited by raju786 - 13 years ago

Unfair since Geetesh is out....😈

Sixteen good singers. That's all that counts in the end!!

I hate it when they divide with genders --- it causes good singers to be eliminated because of the limitations.

@ Tia Kar - Kya Raju. Ladkiyan kam hai jo tum ladke bhi good looks pe jaane lage. And don't you dare give me the she's-a-good-singer excuse, no doubt she's good, but others are better! 😛

@Varsha di - I'm SO SO SO upset about Geetesh's elimination. 🥺

I may not watch the show after all. Just because I am fed up of even going to near the TV. And I did not even watch the theatre round.

It's unfair.. but Indian ppl are always like that...

Originally posted by: Raj*

It's unfair.. but Indian ppl are always like that...

 

But yeah Tia and Manisha are the best! ;)

Now thats generalization...u are an indian too, don't forget it.

@Gender equality, hardly makes a difference as long as quality singers are in (though i wonder if that happened this time or not)

Originally posted by: *Woh Ajnabee*

Sixteen good singers. That's all that counts in the end!!

I hate it when they divide with genders --- it causes good singers to be eliminated because of the limitations.

@ Tia Kar - Kya Raju. Ladkiyan kam hai jo tum ladke bhi good looks pe jaane lage. And don't you dare give me the she's-a-good-singer excuse, no doubt she's good, but others are better! 😛

@Varsha di - I'm SO SO SO upset about Geetesh's elimination. 🥺

ditto

we need Indian Idol not male or female idol!!!😆...if it cums to fair n unfair...yaaar singing is judged by the "gaala' u r possesing not the gender

btw i love boys😆 🤣😳

Originally posted by: Raj*

It's unfair.. but Indian ppl are always like that...

But yeah Tia and Manisha are the best! ;)

um neither n Indian nor i reside in India ....but i think when it cums to judge singing quality...judges do it with closing their eyes..hearing and feeling the existence of sur!😳

Edited by osprisshowMOU - 13 years ago

Hahaha.. all these days - Vandu and Bhawna.. and now Tia ?? 🥺 🤣 Edited by Angel-likeDevil - 13 years ago

I think there should be equal seats for both males and females. It is not about gender discrimination, but it is about the necessity of more female singers in the industry.

By lessening the number of females in the first place, you lessen their chances of winning to four times. So, that is not fair, both should be given equal chances. Also, we have seen the audience trend, votes come more for the males, so to counter-act that at least the number of males and females should have been equal.

Anyways, I hope that the veto power can help the girls to maintain their presence. Never-the-less, we can also hope that this time the votes come in equal quantities for the males and females. That could help to achieve a fair outcome.