Originally posted by shivani003Hey Shivi as much as I hate Tapasya and wish she rots in hell, I dont really believe she is a born criminal. I mean look at Jogi n Divya. Their behavioural traits obviously are not evident in her phenotypes nor genotypes (the best I can conclude is perhaps she was adopted )
Ok nahi on a serious note, I honestly dont feel anyone can be a born criminal. There are many external factors which shape up a person's behavioural characteristics/personality and it aint just genetics. (Lol this is what happens when I remember what I learnt in neuropsych) I guess i speak in perspective of Freuds theory of personality....
A newborn baby is considered the most purest being because it is unspoilt by the immoralities n negative garbage around it. Obviously we cant blame the parents all the time for how a child turns out (although that is dependant on individual's cases...) Definitely Nani has a strong role in corrupting her mind. And yes she does have an insanely envious green eyed monster residing within her, hence the resentment towards Ichki n her parents for being sent away in childhood bla bla bla stuff she's always on about.
Well I have always been very keen n curious to know about how a criminals mind functions, and well when I learnt from neuroscience and also neuropsych and after watching tonnes of documentaries about serial killers/homocides etc etc; a large portion of them are either mentally disturbed, were abused in childhood or have some sort of psychosocial origin. Iam sure u will understand that Iam not trying to justify their actions but I feel that Taps turned out the way she is due to many external events.
And what more can I say about her being the most self centred cow I have ever seen in my life!!!! The whole world revolves around Miss Tapeworm-ex-Thakur/ex Bundela. She feels resentment towards her parents cos she feels they neglected her n only cared about Ichki (thats what that self-centred cow thinks, not me) I wouldnt be surprised at all if she does have defects in her nervous system funtions. Iam damn sure her frontal lobes havent even fully developed yet cos she has a retarded and illogical way of thinking.
But at the end of the day, she is old enough to differentiate good from bad. And yeap she is responsible for her actions. Whether born or made, she is a CRIMINAL AND MUCH MUCH MORE THAN THAT
yeah shivani i also don't believe in born criminal theory.
and may b in the sense shes not born criminal mind but its also true in this forum if u say shes not born criminal so many ppl jump up & say luk despo is not criminal & she became like this only bcoz naani'd instigated her
but its also truth that dracula'd defntly that violent, narcissist & obssessive streak thats why she became wat shes 2day.
and yes i 2nd ur last para abt old enough 2 differentiate.as i'd already told a saying(from a book) that "we r not wat our capabilities r but wat we chose 2 b" so ultimately its always a prsn's choice & v.rarely sum1 forced 2 chose bad but if it happens also the prsn may bcum thief or dacoit but they'd sum principles which they follow.
i rem in sum movies it was always said that "choron ke bhi kucch ussool hote hain!!
"but this tapeworm/despo/dracula doesn't've any.
even in movies its always shown that if innocent prsn is shown wronged by sum villain then hero may've bcum don or thief but never avenge the innocent ppl or bcum like dracula!!
@gargi dear i think i'd also read sumthing like that in sum newspaper though i don't know which1 but most probably in The Indian express as this type of articles quite common in it!!