Fan Fictions

   

General Complaints Thread... (Page 70)

Post Reply New Post

Page 70 of 125

InvisibleSmile

IF-Rockerz

InvisibleSmile

Joined: 13 September 2011

Posts: 7217

Posted: 20 October 2012 at 9:09am | IP Logged
Originally posted by Angel-Jot.

Originally posted by V323

 
the details of the entire plot are given on page#2 of the article. She has said that she is 'inspired' by the trailer. But she did not mention that she is copying the plot entirely. Does that not classify as plagiarism?
 
I'm sorry if my complaint does not classify as plagiarism.
 
And she has not created an ID to PM people. She is masquerading as a different person altogether. That isn't allowed... is it?
 
-V

I still can't seem to find a problem with the FF. =/ IF FF continues copying the storyline episode by episode, then it can be considered plagiarism but if it's just the basic storyline taken but the chapters are original with different twists and whatnot, then it's not plagiarism.

As for the ID, if she's harassing members using the other ID or spamming threads on purpose, then it's not allowed. Because she herself admits that it's not her original ID so i'm not sure how she's "masquerading" as a different person?


My question is kind of related to this, so i am quoting here. Like you said, the writer took the basic storyline from another show, hence there is no plagiarism here. Even if the basic characters and plot line are the same.

Now if i were to write a story, take the basic basis for my story from another writer's work, considering i add my own scenes,twists,gradual character development and my own dialogues but keep the characters same, their back story same and perceived ending the same as the author whom i am taking the concept from. That would be okay?  Can i call that story fully mines?

Will be waiting for your reply :)



Dear Guest, Being an unregistered member you are missing out on participating in the lively discussions happening on the topic "General Complaints Thread... (Page 70)" in Fan Fictions forum. In addition you lose out on the fun interactions with fellow members and other member exclusive features that India-Forums has to offer. Join India's most popular discussion portal on Indian Entertainment. It's FREE and registration is effortless so JOIN NOW!

Angel-Jot.

Moderator

Angel-Jot.

I-F Crazy Creatives Head, BollyCurry Screen Writer

Joined: 24 March 2008

Posts: 20807

Posted: 20 October 2012 at 10:12am | IP Logged
^maybe mention the author and give them credit for the inspiration but yeah, that's fine.

Krani

IF-Dazzler

Krani

Joined: 27 September 2008

Posts: 3393

Posted: 20 October 2012 at 10:18am | IP Logged
Originally posted by Angel-Jot.

^maybe mention the author and give them credit for the inspiration but yeah, that's fine.

If the author/writer is from IF, shouldn't permission be asked for as well first?

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

NmyraAngel-Jot.

Nmyra

Goldie

Nmyra

Joined: 25 November 2011

Posts: 2394

Posted: 20 October 2012 at 11:03am | IP Logged
Originally posted by InvisibleSmile

Originally posted by Angel-Jot.

Originally posted by V323

 
the details of the entire plot are given on page#2 of the article. She has said that she is 'inspired' by the trailer. But she did not mention that she is copying the plot entirely. Does that not classify as plagiarism?
 
I'm sorry if my complaint does not classify as plagiarism.
 
And she has not created an ID to PM people. She is masquerading as a different person altogether. That isn't allowed... is it?
 
-V
I still can't seem to find a problem with the FF. =/ IF FF continues copying the storyline episode by episode, then it can be considered plagiarism but if it's just the basic storyline taken but the chapters are original with different twists and whatnot, then it's not plagiarism. 

As for the ID, if she's harassing members using the other ID or spamming threads on purpose, then it's not allowed. Because she herself admits that it's not her original ID so i'm not sure how she's "masquerading" as a different person? 

In bold - Fine. If that is how the DT sees it the story should be put on alert. I say this because the story was originally posted as Arina_R a writer whose work has recently been uncovered to be heavily plagiarized on at least 6 counts. 

The 'new' author - who has now popped up as a new 'ID' once Arina's plagiarism was brought to light has claimed that Arina was only doing her a favor and posting for her - the her being -Titaliya_AP. She has also been relentlessly scrapping random members - I for one am quite fed up with her trying to force her FF down my throat and am willing to file a complaint.





My question is kind of related to this, so i am quoting here. Like you said, the writer took the basic storyline from another show, hence there is no plagiarism here. Even if the basic characters and plot line are the same. 

Now if i were to write a story, take the basic basis for my story from another writer's work, considering i add my own scenes,twists,gradual character development and my own dialogues but keep the characters same, their back story same and perceived ending the same as the author whom i am taking the concept from. That would be okay?  Can i call that story fully mines?

Will be waiting for your reply :)





Um I've seen the Vewbie reply to this but I feel i need to say this - How is it that the DT seems to think it is okay to copy an entire plot and story from another writer FF or Professional and call it someone's own work with a minimal amount of personal 'tweeks' --- that certainly doesn't sound fair. 

However on taking entire character back-stories the concept is called - Crossover Fiction


Such would be a FF that merges two realities such as Harry Potter and IPK and then continues from there on.

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

Angel-Jot.InvisibleSmile

InvisibleSmile

IF-Rockerz

InvisibleSmile

Joined: 13 September 2011

Posts: 7217

Posted: 20 October 2012 at 11:09am | IP Logged
Originally posted by Angel-Jot.

^maybe mention the author and give them credit for the inspiration but yeah, that's fine.


Very interesting. Actually i posed the question because i wanted to know what your answer would be. What you are saying is it would not be plagiarism. But a friend of mine faced a primal suspension for one month, in one of her Literature courses for doing exactly what you said would be okay to do. I think you should not be negligent with such cases. A author puts a lot of work to develop a concept, entwine the characters within the plot, with their back story and how it would all combine towards that cathartic moment. In real life you could possibly face a lawsuit, because what the FF writer is doing constitutes as plagiarism.

Particularly, the story involved, '' there is no beauty without beast''  the concept is taken from a show, Beauty and the Beast. I find it odd how any writer would allow some other writer to divulge into the character they had so carefully built. I have seen the show and read the first update of the FF.  Ie; Beauty in the show is a cop, haunted by her past relating to her mother. In the FF, the character khushi is also a cop haunted by her past, relating to her mother. And than in the show, there is an investigation going on where Catherine(beauty) is dealing with a case and finds finger prints on the victims body who is model, leading her to discover the beast (Vincent). Primarily in the first update of the FF the writer has just switched the victim from a model to a fashion editor, and instead of finding a finger print, there is a hair found on the body leading her to discover; Arnav Singh Raizada. I just find it ironic that you found nothing wrong with this.

And the FF writer has not credited the show, she has been vague that she was inspired by a show. Also, please ask her, to keep her characters and twists distinct from the show, or add a disclaimer in relation to it.

Just my personal POV, no offense to anyone.





Edited by InvisibleSmile - 20 October 2012 at 11:29am

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

NmyraAngel-Jot.vfordonkey

Nmyra

Goldie

Nmyra

Joined: 25 November 2011

Posts: 2394

Posted: 20 October 2012 at 11:32am | IP Logged
Originally posted by InvisibleSmile

Originally posted by Angel-Jot.

^maybe mention the author and give them credit for the inspiration but yeah, that's fine.


Very interesting. Actually i posed the question because i wanted to know what your answer would be. What you are saying is it would not be plagiarism. But a friend of mine faced a primal suspension for one month, in one of her Literature courses for doing exactly what you said would be okay to do. I think you should not be negligent with such cases. A author puts a lot of work to develop a concept, entwine the characters within the plot, with their back story and how it would all combine towards that cathartic moment. In real life you could possibly face a lawsuit, because what the FF writer is doing constitutes as plagiarism.

Particularly, the story involved, '' there is no beauty without beast''  the concept is taken from a show, Beauty and the Beast. I find it odd how any writer would allow some other writer to divulge into the character they had so carefully built. I have seen the show and read the first update of the FF.  Ie; Beauty in the show is a cop, haunted by her past relating to her mother. In the FF, the character khushi is also a cop haunted by her past, relating to her mother. And than in the show, there is an investigation going on where Catherine(beauty) is dealing with a case and finds finger prints on the victims body who is model, leading her to discover the beast (Vincent). Primarily in the first update of the FF the writer has just switched the victim from a model to a fashion editor, and instead of finding a finger print, there is a hair found on body, leading her to discover; Arnav Singh Raizada. I just find it ironic that you found nothing wrong with this.

And the FF writer has not credited the show, she has been vague that she was inspired by a show. Also, please ask her, to keep her characters and twists distinct from the show, or add a disclaimer in relation to it.

Just my personal POV, no offense to anyone.





AGREED.AGREED.AGREED.<------ Not much else to say here.

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

Angel-Jot.InvisibleSmile

vfordonkey

IF-Rockerz

vfordonkey

Joined: 24 April 2012

Posts: 7805

Posted: 20 October 2012 at 11:46am | IP Logged
Originally posted by Nmyra

Originally posted by InvisibleSmile

Originally posted by Angel-Jot.

^maybe mention the author and give them credit for the inspiration but yeah, that's fine.


Very interesting. Actually i posed the question because i wanted to know what your answer would be. What you are saying is it would not be plagiarism. But a friend of mine faced a primal suspension for one month, in one of her Literature courses for doing exactly what you said would be okay to do. I think you should not be negligent with such cases. A author puts a lot of work to develop a concept, entwine the characters within the plot, with their back story and how it would all combine towards that cathartic moment. In real life you could possibly face a lawsuit, because what the FF writer is doing constitutes as plagiarism.

Particularly, the story involved, '' there is no beauty without beast''  the concept is taken from a show, Beauty and the Beast. I find it odd how any writer would allow some other writer to divulge into the character they had so carefully built. I have seen the show and read the first update of the FF.  Ie; Beauty in the show is a cop, haunted by her past relating to her mother. In the FF, the character khushi is also a cop haunted by her past, relating to her mother. And than in the show, there is an investigation going on where Catherine(beauty) is dealing with a case and finds finger prints on the victims body who is model, leading her to discover the beast (Vincent). Primarily in the first update of the FF the writer has just switched the victim from a model to a fashion editor, and instead of finding a finger print, there is a hair found on body, leading her to discover; Arnav Singh Raizada. I just find it ironic that you found nothing wrong with this.

And the FF writer has not credited the show, she has been vague that she was inspired by a show. Also, please ask her, to keep her characters and twists distinct from the show, or add a disclaimer in relation to it.

Just my personal POV, no offense to anyone.





AGREED.AGREED.AGREED.<------ Not much else to say here.
 
Agreed
 
ps- you put the point across more clearly than I ever could. :)

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

Angel-Jot.InvisibleSmile

Angel-Jot.

Moderator

Angel-Jot.

I-F Crazy Creatives Head, BollyCurry Screen Writer

Joined: 24 March 2008

Posts: 20807

Posted: 20 October 2012 at 2:03pm | IP Logged
Alright so,  maybe I need to consider this more than I did. I guess unless the author themselves gives the other permission to use their concept, it shouldn't be allowed. Is that fine with you guys?
Just crediting isn't enough correct?

And as I mentioned earlier about the FF, if the member is taking each episode of the show and the incidents and using those in each chapter, I can take action. And InvisibleSmile, thank you for letting me know that, that is in fact the case.

We're always open to ideas and suggestions of the members of this forum guys. If you don't agree with our decision and feel we're not doing the right thing, you can always call us out on it -which is exactly what you guys did right now and i'm actually thankful to you all for that. It helps us make the forum a better place. =]

Oh and the MID. Ermm I'm still not getting this here. She's not just using it to post her FF, is what you guys are telling me? She's sending PM's to read her FF? Have you told her not to? If she's still bothering you guys, i can bring that up with her as well. And if it's really serious, I can get the ID banned.

UPDATE!

I've posted a note at her thread and locked it.
http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=3223389&TPN=27&#67693574

I've also sent her a PM. Just waiting for her response now.


Edited by Angel-Jot. - 20 October 2012 at 2:15pm

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

NmyraKraniInvisibleSmile

Post Reply New Post

Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Topic Starter Replies Views Last Post
FF.manneet-**ANIMOSITY** Thread 1 pt 16 new thread

2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 152 153

FireSafireFiree 1219 247388 25 August 2013 at 7:55am
By PoojaSheth
MG FF:Limitless -Thread 3- NEW THREAD LINK PG1

2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 147 148

maan-ki-sanjana 1176 102586 25 November 2012 at 12:42pm
By FairyAngel12
FF-M&G-**ANIMOSITY** THREAD 3- link to thread 4

2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 146 147

FireSafireFiree 1174 180487 29 November 2011 at 6:23am
By jafrin
FF-Enigma- THREAD 7 (thread 8 link on 1st page)

2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 140 141

FireSafireFiree 1127 101035 05 July 2011 at 3:55am
By khwaishfan
-kashish-maaneet ff THREAD 2..link new thread add

2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 159 160

muskanp 1276 185549 15 March 2011 at 7:54pm
By preethia

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category

Active Forums

Fan Fictions Topic Index

Limit search to this Forum only.

 

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.