Posted: 18 March 2010 at 9:55pm | IP Logged
Okies Ash...here I go..
Do you think Sirius was right to break away from the family, even if he didn't agree with some of their values? In my opinion, yes I totally respect Sirius's decision, that was something that he just had to do...always being sidetracked by a family that didnt understand him, or give him taht respect that as a person, an individual he deserved..all his brothers, cousins chose a wrong path,..he happened to choose the right one...I think tahts what makes him soo different and soo special from the others.
Who is a better person in your opinion, Sirius or Snape? Why? Man!...Thsi is hard. I think it would be Snape. Why?..umm I thinks its because of two major reasons...he did everything he could in his control to save Harry, followed two most terrible and powerful guys orders, nicking his safety, just bothering aout Lily..and tht makes him really strong, stronger than Sirius and wht he endured in Azkaban. The other reason, would be because, how much ever Snape hated Harry, and his dad, he still cared, in his own way be it either in alerting Albus or doing it in his own curt style,unlike Sirius, who couldnt care for Harry...he could really never be more helpful at times when Harry needed him..and at all those times it was Albus helping Harry...
If you had the chance to bring Sirius back to life by killing off another good character who lived at the end of the series, who would you choose? No doubt on this Ash..it would be Bellatrix..*I so dislike her*
What were some of Sirius' strongest points? Faults? Strongest points...Umm I think he was the closest to Harry ever, i mean after his parents, and he cared for him the way Harry wished...something that Snape could never do, as he could never face the fact that he cared for Lily and James son! But there was another plus point..he was an animagus....LOL..that saved his life soo many times! He was very honest...something that i think made him really worthy of such a high character.
Weak points... He didnt have enough guts...I think so atleast..given a choice, he wouldnt be able to take Snape's job. Another weak point...maybe that he hated some things around him soo much that they led to negativity..he was always negative...being shut in the order, not allowed to move out, proclaimed murderer..etc!
Nice questions... had me thinking..