Originally posted by: crazy_sunny
I must have traveld to wrong time zone then. Thats what happens when 1 is not very punctual. *sigh*
Originally posted by: crazy_sunny
I must have traveld to wrong time zone then. Thats what happens when 1 is not very punctual. *sigh*
Originally posted by: crazy_sunnyIt wasnt me ! I m not very fond of jalebis .
Originally posted by: DM01Ramayana and Mahabharata have evolved over a course of centuries. Both epics were much shorter in its initial stages. Linguistic and statistical research have manage to identity the different layers in the texts, and have assigned a time period in which they were interpolated into the epics.
Tradition teaches us that Ramayana was authored by Valkmiki, and Mahabharata was authored by Vyasa, however research has revealed that both texts were written by many authors in different time periods over course of centuries.
The question of myth or fact is extremely hard to answer, while the core story of both epics are very archaic, and may indeed have been based on a real event or at least inspired by a real event, however due to many centuries of interpolations, it is very difficult to separate fact from myth.
Ramayana and Mahabharata is much more than just a tale now, both epics include a range of diverse topics such as, moral/ethics, philosophy, politics, social mores, religion, arts, and has influenced many cultures outside of India, especially South-East Asia.
Originally posted by: crazy_sunnyare we to now have a debate if Ramayan is bases on facts or fiction?
Originally posted by: chal_phek_mat
Coming to the debate, If you were to assume, Kauravas won the war in Mahabharata, Duryodhan and Karna would have been heroes instead of Arjun and Krishna. Actually if you were to ignore that Krishna was a incarnation of Lord Vishnu and Pandavas won and if you compare the character of Krishna to that of Karna. Karna comes out better. Talking about ethics etc. There were equal number of unethical actions against the Kaurvas as much as the Kaurvas committed. But still the Kauravas are villified. Huge lesson that comes out of Mahabharata is the winner ends up writing the history and everything you do gets justified by some means or other. So concentrate on winning the battle,
Originally posted by: return_to_hades
To those who believe and have faith these stories are historical facts, and to others who do not they are mere stories. I think when you take these mythological tales like Ramayana or Mahabharata or others, whether it is a fact or fiction is an irrelevant question. What is more important is what lessons can we learn from them. Are these tales applicable in our lives in some manner, what do they show about the character of humans.
Harry Potter, Lord of the Rings, Chronicles of Narnia - they are all fictitious novels too. However, one cannot deny that they represent the battle between good and evil. The conflicts and choices faced by human. They can be morally and philosophically debated, and the actions of these characters can be analyzed.
To some people comparing these works to religious scripture is blasphemy. But the truth of the matter is that some authors intend to put their religious beliefs into these books too. For example C.S. Lewis was a devout Christian, and he intended the character of Aslan to be modeled around Christ. Aslan sacrifices himself and is resurrected.
So I think the debate is not if these stories are true or not, but what can we learn from them. Its about analyzing characters in these myths and their actions.
Originally posted by: return_to_hades
I think if anyone can remake these epics with true justice is Peter Jackson. I was really impressed with the way he put Lord of the Rings into a movie. Unlike Harry Potter movies which left the characters and plots being underdeveloped and meaningless - the Lord of the Rings movies do best justice to the character.
Ever since I saw LOTR I have been fantasizing of having an Epic movie series based on the Mahabharata hit the theaters. You know the scene where Arwen has the river rise into a stampede and wash away the ring wraiths, imagine how awesome it would be if Varunastra etc could be portrayed with such CGI effects. It would be mindblowing.
I've actually been planning my starcast too Viggo Mortensen as Yudhishter, Eric Bana as Bheema, Orlando Bloom as Arjuna, Diego Luna as Nakula and Sahdeva, Hale Berry as Draupadi, Tom Welling as Abhimanyu, Ian McKellen as Bheeshma, Dwayne Johnson as Duryodhan and so on and so forth.
comment:
p_commentcount